Riley’s Sandwich Co. Menu – Shorewood, WI

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Shorewood, WI

Based on 180 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Riley's Sandwich Co. 53211

Address:
4473 N Oakland Ave B, Shorewood, WI 53211

Phone: (414) 616-1811

Website:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed

Holiday hours
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 11 AM–3 PM
Friday 11 AM–3 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday 11 AM–3 PM

Menu

Specials
(3) Tacos – Organic Chicken Breast
avocado, cilantro, onion, cheese, aji verde on a grilled flour tortilla
$9.95
(3) Tacos – Roasted Cauliflower
avocado, cilantro, onion, cheese, aji verde on a grilled flour tortilla
$9.95
(3) Tacos – Beef Tenderloin Steak
avocado, cilantro, onion, cheese, aji verde on a grilled flour tortilla
$10.95
Main Menu
Steak Kensington
med rare beef tenderloin, house made horseradish spread, mozz, roasted: mushroom, onion, house roll

“Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.”

$9.95
Steak Kensington – Oakland Style
med rare beef tenderloin, house made garlic spread, mozz, roasted: mushroom, onion, parm

PRO TIP: Spicy Giardiniera is the way we love it!

“Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.”

$9.95
Steak Philly
beef tenderloin steak, cheese, mushroom, onion, house roll

“Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.”

$9.95
Steak & Avo
beef tenderloin steak, avocado, tomato, mozz, aji verde

aji verde – peruvian green sauce, bright & spicy, flavors of cilantro, parmesan, lime

$10.95
Steakin’ Bacon
beef tenderloin steak, bacon, double cheese, tomato, red onion, special sauce, lettuce

Lettuce now served on sandwich to reduce waste.

$10.95
Terrible City
beef tenderloin steak, cheese, onion, beer cheese, dill pickle potato chip, slaw
$9.95
Chicken Philly
organic chicken, mozz, house cheese sauce, roasted: mushroom, onion, house roll
$8.95
Buffalo Chicken
organic chicken, buffalo sauce, mozz, celery, carrot, tomato, house roll

choice of ranch or blue cheese crumbles

$8.95
BBQ Chicken
organic chicken breast, bbq, mozz, slaw, red onion

Pro Tip: We love it with Avocado or make it Hawaiian with roasted cinnamon pineapple!

$8.95
Chicken Parm
organic chicken breast, garlic bread crumbs, marinara, mozz

PRO TIP: add spicy giardiniera

$8.95
CBR
organic chicken breast, bacon, housemade ranch, avocado, tomato, cheese, lettuce

Lettuce now served on sandwich to reduce waste.

$9.95
Chicken Aji Verde
organic chicken breast, avocado, tomato, mozz, aji verde

aji verde – peruvian green sauce, bright & spicy, flavors of cilantro, parmesan, lime

$9.45
Buffalo Cauliflower Sandwich
roasted cauliflower, buffalo sauce, celery, carrots, mozzarella, bleu cheese crumble, tomato.

Make VEGAN – sub mayo and cheese.

$7.95
Aji Veggie
roasted cauliflower, avocado, tomato, mozz, aji verde

aji verde – peruvian green sauce, bright & spicy, flavors of cilantro, parmesan, lime

$8.45
Brussels Sprouts Salad
brussels sprouts, romaine, quinoa, pecan, avocado, red onion, grape, parmesan, champagne vinaigrette

*Dressing is gluten free & Vegan

$12.25
Buffalo Chicken Salad
organic chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce, melted mozz, romaine, carrot, celery, tomato, house ranch dressing

*Dressing & Buffalo Sauce or gluten free

$15.95
SLIDE Chips 2.5 Oz
Made from Wisconsin potatoes, fried and hand packed in Madison, WI. (2.5 0z) bag. Serves (2)
$2.95
Side – Buffalo Cauli
Roasted buffalo cauliflower, now 50% larger
$5.95
SCRATCH Ice Cream
PINTS

We make our ice cream and almost all of our toppings in house, and from scratch. We use Wisconsin Dairy and everything is made in small batches and hand packed. pings in house, and from scratch.

$7.00
Kids Cheesy Chicken
organic chicken, cheese, french sourdough
$6.50
Kids Grilled Cheese
cheese, french sourdough
$5.50
Bottled Water 16.9 Oz $1.50
Diet Coke 12 Oz $2.00
Mexican Coke 12 Oz
Cane sugar instead of corn syrup
$3.25
Catering
Party Platter
For Delivery Orders: Please email [email protected], prior to placing your order to ensure the best experience.

Our almost famous sandwiches
– (18) 3″ sandwiches per platter.
– 6 sandwich varieties per platter.

Includes
-(12) homemade chocolate chip cookies
-CHOICE of: Party Size House Salad or SLIDE Potato Chips

Party Platters – Serves 7-9 guests.

Note: The House Salad cannot be replaced by a different salad from our menu due to ingredient preparation time, cost and availability.

$119.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Mona Bell
This place screams great memories. The dogs are all friendly like their owners. The customer service was beyond rewarding. You felt so accepted because everyone called you and your dog by their names. Almost like you are wearing invisible name tags. The drinks are so good and consistent. I love a place that makes the drinks the same every time. I will be telling all my friends with dogs about this place.

… more

Ryan Yatso
I had the steak & avo sandwich. This was hands down the best sandwich I’ve had in my life. I could eat that green sauce on anything. Steak was cooked perfectly, bread was Devine. I could tell this was made with high quality ingredients. I encourage everyone to go visit Riley’s! I will be back, and will be ordering a full Sammy next time.

… more

Said Hamideh
It may be difficult for newbies to wrap their head around this place. But yes you can order delicious sandwiches here. No cash taken.

… more

Dawn Lopez
What an amazing place! Thank you Riley’s Social House and Sandwich shop for all of the thought and energy you put into making Riley’s such a great place for our four-legged BFFs! The place is adorable, thoughtfully laid out for the puppers, and the sandwiches are chef’s kiss! 10/10 recommend taking your pup there, or even going solo for a drink or amazing sandwich.

… more

Lizzy G
Riley’s offers a fun, friendly atmosphere, and arguably the best sandwiches in Wisconsin. Aji Veggie sammy FOREVER!! And my dog loves Riley’s Fave! I’d like to submit 1,000 votes for future delivery to Oak Creek (maybe with a minimum order amount??)…would literally be my dream come true.

… more

Nell McCaffery
I have been to Riley’s 3x, and each time it gets better and better. First of all, the owners are as sweet as can be and work their tails off! The food and cocktails are top notch, both in quality and diversity of choices. The entire team at Riley’s makes both humans and canines feel extremely welcome. I’m so glad my gal, Sweet Pea, has the luxury of this joint just a 10 minute walk from home. A win for the Third Ward and surrounding communities.

… more

David Nevin
Riley’s Sandwich in Shorewood has become a crammed dog supply store and food is only available from 11-3 – 5 days/wk. Website is pretty, but pretty useless. Have to go to Coast to find out it is closed. Tacos were ok, sandwiches are getting soggy.

… more

Andrew Potter
We’ve been to Rileys a couple times. Sandwiches are amazing, staff is friendly and helpful, and being pet friendly is a major plus. Not a lot of room for dining in, but they have bartop space indoors and a few tables out on the sidewalk in the summer. I’d never let the limited seating prevent me from stopping. I’d recommend this place to anyone and everyone! A must stop when in Shorewood!

… more

Christopher Wright
We got the steak and avocado one and I’d say this is probably the second best sandwich I’ve ever had and I’ve had a lot >.>

… more

Josh R
this place has amazing sandwiches! Very clean environment for being pet friendly and their to-go section is separate from their dog area. so if you for some reason aren’t a fan of dogs you don’t have to worry when picking up an order.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions