Based on 285 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
309 Main St # 3, Sayreville, NJ 08872
Phone: (732) 651-2330
Website: https://rustonis.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tony Simon
Those WINGS!!!!!! The staff at Rustoni’s is nice but those wings!!!! I order the wings every time I go. These are the Sweet & Mild wings. They were freshly cooked and hot! They aren’t breaded but the skin is crisp an the entire dish is delicious. The pizza there is very good. My wife and I have gone there for years. I have recommended them for years because I believe they are one of the best places in the area. Their wings DOMINATE the local restaurants. Take my word for it and give them a try or suffer through the mediocrity of “Mid” wings from other establishments. Highly recommend.
… more
Jason Monserrate
Started ordering from Rustoni’s, maybe 3 months ago, and I’m convinced that this is the go to spot for pizza. Always fresh, full of flavor, most definitely satisfies the craving. Website is easy to navigate and Rustoni’s offers a 10% discount off of orders placed thru the website.
… more
Neema Wooten
I am writing this review before I actually eat the food. I just went in to order and the service and attention to detail was amazing. I ordered off the menu and they accommodated what I want. Also, asked before I did how I wanted it: seperate with the red sauce or together with the dish sauce. I tried to tip extra because they were so warm. They wouldn’t take it but I left it anyway. They are a real Italian restaurant feed you how you want! Can’t wait to eat it!
… more
Mikee535
This is the worst calzone I have ever had I am really surprised because usually food from Rustinos is pretty decent. The ham is lunch meat, the ricotta cheese is pretty awful its like cheese and water, and the mozzarella is barely there. When I cut it in half wet sloppy cheesy water oozed out, whoever was working in the kitchen today should be fired.
… more
Ozan Oral
All pizza in NJ is generally good, but Rustoni’s always delivers with some of the best I have had. I also enjoy the light seasoning on their calamari not too salty. Very on point!
… more
Elizabeth Toscano
So the food here is usually good, in fact very good. prices fair. when they are busy on weekends the quality of everything suffers. When there is a issue with a order, they seem hesitant (at best) to replace/refund. Requires approval/callbacks,etc.Even for long time customers. Otherwise a good choice.
… more
a r friedman
I’ve ordered from Rustons since the day they opened. The owner, his wife and staff are wonderful. I’ve dine in, take out and delivery. The food is great. The chicken used is quality food, as I’m a chicken connosour.
… more
PJ K
Nice pep/sausage pie! Really good sauce and crispy wings like I ordered. Didn’t know about the cash discount until after payment. I’ll be back.
… more
Michael Z. Horvath
Great local spot that has a lot of choices and good food to boot. Visited with my buddy recently for some pizza and it did not disappoint. Would be glad to order from them again when I’m in the area.
… more
William Bowens
I was at work and I drive all day and stumbled upon this golden nugget, the pizza is the truth, and the homemade sauce OMG!!!! I have had the pleasure to taste it on the pizza with chicken my taste buds whent out of control so I went back into the store and brought a couple of bottles of the sauce I wish they would get the sauce into stores so everyone can have this great experience I live 47 min away from them so I will take the drive to vist or maybe I they can deliver the sauce to me I’ll pay the delivery fee for the sauce I can’t wait to be back in the area to try the rest of the food if they can make a great sauce I’m all in and well worth the time. And I want to thank the young lady who observed my interest in the sauce on the pizza she was very informative on what it was and thanks for the suggested sell they have a winner on their team. Definitely will be back, see you soon.
… more
… View more