Locally owned NY style pizza shop with attached gelato shop and market. Dough made in house daily, fresh mozzarella, homemade sauce, and freshly shredded cheese tops the thin and chewy crust. Free delivery and a beer and wine on/off license makes this spot a convenient choice for your family vacation.
Pies, pastas & hoagies from a laid-back, open-late joint with games such as billiards & pinball. Based on 387 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
710 S Virginia Dare Trail, Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948
Phone: (252) 715-3145
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 2–9 PM |
| Sunday | 2–9 PM |
| Monday | 5–9 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gina Griffin
Craving pizza, at the beach, GO!! Some of the best pizza I’ve had Anywhere. We got a large supreme and 2 local craft beers on tap. Pizza was thin, but not too thin, crust was toasty to perfection and the sauce had just the right amount of tang to it, with fresh yummy toppings. The Best. Nothing fancy, paper plates & plastic cups…just great food with good service and small but clean dining area. Plus, they offer free delivery within like a 5 mile area and ordering online. What more could you want?
… more
Rob Spitler
Got a late carry out order. About an hour before close they go to a more limited menu, so get in there early if you want some of their specials. I was wanting the white pizza, which was in the late menus and it was excellent! Had it for three meals!
… more
Sonya Holman
First time in this small but quaint eatery serviced by friendly staff, making hot tasty and plentiful food items. I purchased the eggplant parmigiano sandwich, garden salad, tator tots, and a spinach and cheese roll. I have food for 3 days, literally yall! I just wanted to try a couple of different things to see if the google reviews are true. Guess what? They are!
… more
Brian “WolfmanJack99”
Great pizza and good people. My wife and I sat at the bar, had a cold beer and a dt. Coke along with our MYO pizza. Thin crispy crust, and delicious ingredients. The bar tender and manager? were friendly and gave good service. The restaurant is a little on the small side. You may have a hard time fitting a large party inside. They do offer take out and delivery though.
… more
Ray Munger
Very good service. The girl that took the order said 15 minutes and I was out of there in 13 minutes. Pizza was awesome. Whole cloves of garlic were out of this world.
… more
Rona Hyman
OMG!! The food and portion size is straight out of NYC!! Some of the best food I have had in a really long time!! The food is fresh, delicious and served and prepared with unique recipes and ingredients. I can’t wait to go back. The prices are incredible too!!
… more
Aaliyah Flint
Craving pizza, at the beach, GO!! Some of the best pizza I’ve had Anywhere. We got a large supreme and 2 local craft beers on tap. Pizza was thin, but not too thin, crust was toasty t
… more
Aaliyah Lattimore
Got a late carry out order. About an hour before close they go to a more limited menu, so get in there early if you want some of their specials. I was wanting the white pizza, which was in the late menus and it was excellent! Had it for
… more
Tyrell Debraux
I have been coming to this establishment for the past 10 years. It’s has become a tradition to visit while I am visiting the OBX, and let me tell you. The pizza gets better every time. It’s fresh, authentic, and delicious! I look forward to my next visit!!
… more
Fat Man Reviews
On a soggy night, Fat Man Reviews stopped into Sal’s New York Pizza in Kill Devil Hills, NC. Sal’s is New York style pizza joint serving pies, beer and pasta dishes.
… more
… View more