Down-to-earth standby in basic digs serving New York–style pies, slices & casual Italian eats. Based on 781 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2974 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Phone: (414) 967-8040
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jessica Bunny
This place is absolutely fabulous!! The food has been delicious since they opened. Their prices are totally affordable, and you definitely get quality food and service.
… more
Lucky Hachi
By far the best pizza I ever had in my life. Ever since I started school at UWM, my friends suggested the place and I’m glad they did. Amazing pizza and environment. Also, the ranch is fantastic!
… more
Adrian D
We were in town to visit UWM and passed this placed on our way to the hotel. Stopped in the next day and did not disappoint. There isn’t a ton of seating but it was pretty quiet when we came in. Bathroom was a little dirty but I’ve seen much worse. Ordered a lunch special which is 2 slices, a garlic knot and drink for $9.50. Worth every cent. I’m bringing a sharpie next time!
… more
David Gallegos
Delicious huge slices of pizza . We got the stuff slice with pepperoni and sausage, chicken bacon ranch, bbq chicken, pepperoni, pep and sausage, supreme and a spinach slice. Also got the mozzarella sticks and some garlic knots I believe that’s what they call very tasty too.
… more
Kari Bourget
I wish I could give them 100 ⭐️. Genuinely the best pizza I’ve ever put in my mouth. It was everything and more. I truly don’t ever want any other kind of pizza. My husband and I were both like “well, we found the best we will ever have in our whole lives”.
… more
Julvania Correa
Their pizza is by far the best one I’ve had. My choice was the BBQ chicken. The slices are a nice size. The sweet and tanginess of the BBQ compliments the well seasoned chicken. The crust was perfect in thinness, not to crispy not to soggy. The flavors were on point. The little bread knots are cool, I think they should add a flavor bomb in the center of it that’ll melt inside when they cook and burst in your mouth when you bite into it. I enjoyed the customer service and will definitely order again and recommend.
… more
Joy Wiley
I didn’t really like the sauce but the service was great and they have deals and a nice variety to choose from..I love the decor was so expressive and from real customers..
… more
Renee Davidson
Ordered delivery. It said it would be at my home in 50-60 minutes. It arrived 20 mins after I ordered! 🙂 fast and friendly service!! I feel so bad that the delivery driver had to come out in the pouring rain, but he had no complaints and was awesome!!
… more
Ron T
I grew up in Brooklyn. For many years the main thing I missed, in Wisconsin, was NY pizza. My sisters still live in Manhattan. It’s getting hard to find good pizza in NYC. Sal’s is great. If you are a displaced NYer head here.
… more
Kev south
Wow! Say it again Wow! Company gave grubhub for working the weekend and I had to spend it before it expired so i went outside my preference for mediocre calzones found in the area of the country and which by the way has no Ricotta cheese in it and I am from New Orleans and they always have this as a base but Rosati’s does not so I went out and searched and found Sal’s! My new goto! Freaking taste of garlic and freshness and hugeness of the calzone is awesome and theybput ricotta cheese as a base! Such flavor and freshness! From a picky eater this is awesome. Cannot wait to taste a pizza next! Cheers to u guys and sorry u r not closer to bayshore mall aprtments! Great taste. Will be back!
… more
… View more