Based on 198 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
Address:
215 E State St #5547, Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: (607) 272-2666
Website: http://www.sammyspizzeriaithaca.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jack Morgan
Soda fountain had no syrup, guy behind the counter just shrugged and walked away. Pizza was ok, not really worth the price. Place was filthy, looked like it hadn’t been cleaned in a week. Only went here because it was the only pizza place open that wasn’t Dominos. Kinda wish i’d gone there instead.
… more
Desh Cooper
Convenient location in the commons. Everything seemed relatively clean when I went. The bomber sandwich and fries I got were nice and fresh. Good service and friendly staff.
… more
Mark J. Radzikowski
Went to order a whole pie ToGo, when I got to counter I was informed, ” we are out of cheese , someone is going to store”. So instead I bought a few premade slices. The garlic pizza slice was dry while the plain cheese I found greasy.
… more
Peter Clark
The restaurant appeared dirty and not well taken care of. The gentleman cooking behind the counter was handling cooked and uncooked food without gloves. I ordered 20 wings, which were absolutely horrible. I ate one. The rest went in the trash. The wings were soggy and crumbly, obviously cooked plain and tossed in a minimal amount of mediocre sauce. Will never go back. Unfortunately Google will not let me give it zero stars.
… more
Martha Dunkelberger
The gentleman who greeted us was so kind and helpful in a pinch! We are from out of town and didn’t realize that everything would be closed so early and he gave us food after hours.
… more
Sanatana Infiniti
The pizza is very good. I would go back for a pizza any day of the week. Thin crust, perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni.
… more
Leafafarian
How do you like burnt pizza? I used to go to your place quite frequently back in the day with friends so I stopped by today for a dose of nostalgia. I regret that decision. $7+ for 2 slices of pepperoni extra extra crisp. No regrets leaving a bad review for bad pizza. Interior is great if you like concrete for a back rest when you eat.
… more
Kim Pang
The only way to get this review submitted was to give it a star. It’s not even worth a star. The establishment is dirty and the restroom sink looked like it hadn’t been cleaned for a while. We ordered personal pizzas and some fried chicken (dine-in) . We were told it would take 25 minutes. 45 minutes later, we were still waiting. There was no communication from them about why it was taking so long. When I finally went to check on the order, I was told that the pizzas were burnt and they had to make another batch. The pizzas were nothing to write home about and our chicken was over cooked and dry. I’m not going back any more.
… more
Debi Davis
Really love their pizza and atmosphere. Always very happy and friendly. Reasonable prices.
… more
CS RG
I’d take some of these reviews with a big grain of salt. It appears some people don’t know what pizza is supposed to taste like. But that’s okay, some people don’t know about authentic pizza. I just got back from Italy, and this pizza was actually quite close. It’s very delicious. I can’t comment on the delivery process, but if you go there you’ll get a very good slice of pizza.
… more
… View more