Based on 50 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
208 W Fort Morgan Rd, Gulf Shores, AL 36542
Phone: (251) 948-5559
Website: http://sarahshomemade.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–6 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–6 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Danille Ryan
Mostly good, but the vegetables in the Shepherds pie and pot pie are always under done lately, and the meatballs in the meatball stuffed shells are clearly previous frozen meatballs. We purchase Several of the casserole 3 to 4 times a month for dinner, and the chicken and pimento salads often.
… more
Dacri Ann Overstreet
I stopped in for a take-and-bake casserole, which is a life saver on a work night. I noticed pound cakes on the counter that looked too yummy to resist. They both tasted as good as they looked, but my favorite was the Red Velvet. The icing was pure velvet creaminess and the cake was so moist my fork glided right through it.
… more
Baileigh Bolden
I went in to Sarah’s shop today I was on my lunch break I go in often.But I purchase one of the chicken salad today the cashier put salad in the bag and handed to me without crackers so i ask could i get some cracker she gave me this weird look and put three pack in the bag that equal to six cracker. That’s telling me that you long needs my money because I will not be returning
… more
Mayuri Patel
Their Buffalo chicken salad is AMAZING! And if you’re a cookie fan or not, those chocolate chip cookies are so darn good!! My husband who isn’t even a cookie fan loves them! They’re not too sweet, you can taste a touch of salt, and it’s just perfect!
… more
Dana
I usually grab something from here on my lunch break when I have to run into town for work. Their chocolate chip cookies are delicious (they top their’s with a pinch of salt) and so is the chicken salad. Tried the spinach dip for the first time this week and it was tasty! The lasagna roll-Ups are a nice take and bake item if you don’t feel like cooking, but get the larger one even if you think you won’t eat that much
… more
Scott A
Mostly good. The banana pudding was fantastic. The Shepard’s pie and chicken pot pie were both too soupy. The lasagna roll up was excellent too. Would give 5 stars if the pie dishes had been thicker…. Could’ve just added a little flour or corn starch or reduced down.
… more
DixieDoug
This homemade food store is righteous! One of today’s made-fresh items was bacon, ham and cheese quiche. I bought two personal size quiche, but they did have family size too. There are homemade salads, sides and pies in the coolers. I bought a container of Craisin Chicken Salad. I love that stuff! Be sure and follow them on Facebook for updates of daily items. I ate half a quiche when I got home. OMG, it was awesome! The crust was so flaky and delicious. The filling was oh so good! I shall return!
… more
Shelli Wohlhieter
Every food we tried is awesome and fresh !
… more
Shana Bell
Lived here for years and hadn’t explored this little gem until today. A friend told me about it (and shared a yummy treat from there with me). I took my daughter there for her lunch break and she says it beats Subway—if you knew her, that’s a HUGE compliment! We will be repeat customers.
… more
Whitney Wall
I love ALL of the chicken salads and pimento dips here – and the chocolate chip cookies are to die for! They also have a ton of casseroles to take & bake if you’re not wanting to fight the crowds at the restaurants. I highly recommend this little shop & will definitely be back!
… more
… View more