Based on 160 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
224 Market St, Brookville, OH 45309
Phone: (937) 833-6030
Website: https://sarahs-pizza-italian-restaurant.business.site/
Hours
| Sunday | 3–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
3–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 3–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–10 PM |
| Thursday | 3–10 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christina Collier
LOVE THIS PLACE! I have been coming here for years and they never disappoint. The staff is so friendly and always get out orders right, even when we make special requests. A nice small- town feel inside. Thank you Sarah’s!
… more
Grant Shippam
Ordered delivery. From phone call to delivery was about 45 minutes. I was staying at the Holiday Inn and they brought the pizza to my room. Delivery guy was friendly and quick. Pizza itself was still piping hot. Looks like care was taken during the in route travel to my room as no damage was done to the box or pizza. I ordered a 4 topping supreme. Ingredients tasted fresh and the pizza was delicious. It has its own local flavor that is better than the average chain you see in every town. Would recommend over the chain places for sure.
… more
Melissa Mares
Family traveling from North Carolina to Iowa. We always trying to buy local so we ordered pizza from Sarah’s recommendation from Holiday Inn. Received order tipped driver. Check bank account we were charged 2x first the one with out tip one week and the next week charged again with tip????? $70 something dollars ??? Called to speak to management told this is not the first time it has happened and call back and talk to management??? Very disappointed
… more
Micheal Snouffer
I’ve been a long time fan of Sarah’s but it’s hard to keep up with a place when you never answer the phone. I won’t be coming back. If you want a good experience with pizza, I recommend Foxes Den at least they answer the phone.
… more
Elizabeth
First time ordering from Sarah’s. Order placed was for take out. For the most part the order was fine. Staff responded reasonably when I went in to pay for the order. Wait quoted over the phone on a Tuesday around 8:30 for a small pizza, basket of wedges, and two large subs was quoted at 25 minutes. Food was ready when I went to pick it up. Pricing is very reasonable.
… more
Jacqueline Slade
Our large pizza was smashed so all the chicken and cheese was stuck to the lid. My gluten-free was topped with cheddar for some reason and overcooked to card board. The lady who took the order on the phone seemed annoyed And the delivery driver drove through my yard ♀️
… more
Brandi R
Waited no time to place my order on a Saturday night, ready in 25 mins and was exactly what I was craving. So good! I forgot to ask them not to brown the cheese, but luckily it was perfect.
… more
umbrellacorpsoldier1
Great pizza. Long time customer of this pizza joint. Want a great pizza get Sarah’s?
… more
Rick Crouch
Small pizza was delicious and of good value. Would have given five stars except for the unexplained delay in receiving order. 15 minutes promised time turned into 30 minutes, only after questioning 20 minutes in as to where the pizza was. I think I may have been forgotten. I will definitely go back and recommend.
… more
Michele Bush
They’re always prompt with deliveries and my order is always correct
… more
… View more