Based on 206 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
77 E Dayton St, West Alexandria, OH 45381
Phone: (937) 839-5499
Website: https://sarahspizzawestalexandria.hrpos.heartland.us/menu
Hours
| Wednesday | 2–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 2–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 2–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 2–9 PM |
| Monday | 2–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 2–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Shelby Hager
Our family has been eating Sarah’s for about 25 years.. I remember loving it as a toddler. Unfortunately I live about 40 minutes away from West Alex now, but every single time I come over to my parent’s house – they just expect that I’m going to want to order Sarah’s. My go-to is a Sausage Ranch pizza (not on the menu, but they know what it is!) and their Cheese Stix. I also love their Pepperoni with Extra Cheese – it is always perfect! Their Spuds, Steak Subs and Wings are also delicious. Service is always fast, even during busy times, and delivery drivers are always at your house on time!
… more
Beth Rickert
Service is always friendly and professional! We have never had an issue with any of our orders. The driver are courteous, respectful and quite prompt! Highly recommend!!
… more
Bj Ryan
I love the little mom and pop on pizza place the only thing I dislike is the one small table that’s crowded behind the door entrance it would be nice if there was room to eat in but overall I love the pizza and everyone that works there is very welcoming and patient with me
… more
Zach Upp
Hands down, by far the best pizza place around. They have a lot more than pizza too, I’ve been going for over 3 years and I’m always highly satisfied. I come in every time now to pickup my food because I love the staff there too and we’ve become good friends. I’ve eaten pizza all over this country, and I know pizza, and Sarah’s pizza is the best!!!!!!
… more
Christina Setters
I get Sarah’s every chance I get. The food is always delicious
… more
Tree Man
We always do carry out and the service is great and so is the pizza.
… more
Cody Morgan
Always good food Darren tearing it up fast service try the taco pizza
… more
Jane Hill
VERY disappointed with the lack of proper customer service tonight. I ordered a small pizza and loaded potato wedges and when I picked my order up I received regular wedges, which is not what my husband ordered. So I went back in and said hey you didn’t make the right ones but it’s no big deal I will pay for a new order, seeing as they had just rang it up wrong. So then waited another 10 minutes while my other food was getting cold. As I was handed the wedges I simply asked if I could have an extra sour cream packet, this guy REALLY went to the register and said that will be 99 cents. AFTER YOU MADE THE WRONG ITEM IN THE FIRST PLACE? It’s sour cream… are you going bankrupt? Do better LOL.
… more
Carla Fee Homsher
First time trying Sarah’s and it was great! Courteous customer service!Loved the garlic parmesan boneless wings and mashed potato pizza! Looking forward to trying their sandwiches next time!
… more
Dan S
We ordered from Sarah’s while camping near West Alexander and must say 5 stars for another local eatery! Great service and Great food!
… more
… View more