Based on 33 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
203 North St, Middletown, NY 10940
Phone: (845) 381-5770
Hours
| Tuesday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 12 PM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Trixie Daniels
Food and service were great. Damien was friendly and attentive. Stewed chicken was tender and flavorful. The rice ‘n’ peas and cabbage were cooked perfectly. This will be my late night spot to eat.
… more
Steve Novak
This is the same Peppas family as the famous Brooklyn Peppas. To me, the Curry Goat is even better here than in NYC. Middletowners seem to not know what they have here – every night people line up around the block in Brooklyn. I travel a lot and try goat everywhere I can find it – Nothing remotely as good as this goat around Middletown, and consistently so, it’s always as good as the first time. And the cabbage is perfect – a great mix, not too spicy but flavorful, and a good portion. Rice and peas – Yum. Pattys are good. I can not speak to any other dish. He should get and would do well in a better location – this seems to be the hoodiest looking commercial intersection in town. But worth it, safe, no one will bother you. Just day workers and locals hanging around the deli next door with a small triangle parking lot at the corner makes it look sketchie. And Scotchie is the Mayor around there, as well as a true Chef. Get it here so you can say you did when he’s moved on up to a real place and gets written up. Authentic AF, Undiscovered award winning. I actually don’t like the Peppas in BK, its ok, but there are several places in that central bk region I prefer. But this Peppa (Goat) is better than any of them, easily. Just saying.
… more
Deborah Colley
This was my first time there the food was great I loved it It was well prepared The taste was on point everything about the food was delicious all the way I will be back.
… more
Missy Frost
Service is always wonderful. Oxtail was delicious. Stewed chicken was not as good. Jerk chicken had bone pieces in the rice.
… more
Marilyn Fields
My plate is always overflowing with whatever I order
… more
Maunzel Bamba
Review worthy! Pleasantly pleased! The cook confidently stated that it is “one of the best Jamaican foods in all of America!”… He may just be right! Best in upstate NY & Brooklyn IMO…Thank you for the great service and authentically tasty food!
… more
Monae Fontaine
Update: I’m over this place. It’s lost it’s zeal. According to the cook, they don’t have veggie patties, because we’re upstate and they’re unpopular. The last two times when I conceded for lack of what I WANTED, the vegetable options were limited to cabbage, rice and peas or plantains. Same old same old. I’m just over getting disappointed by sub-par dining options.
… more
Amber Whalen
This place left me speechless. I just tried them today. Ordered through doordash for my first time and food was AMAZING !!! It’s so flavorful and very fresh. The food was still hot when it arrived. I have enough for dinner for tonight and possibly even lunch for tomorrow !! Which is great lol.
… more
Robert Dunbar
Originally from the city, Excited to find this place, and was open late. Family loves the food. Even had food catered. Guest loved the food so much they had food catered and asked us to bring it up to their town.
… more
Kisha Robinson
The jerk chicken is good. Didn’t really care for the stewed chicken. Banana pudding is good as well. The owners are very nice and helpful with your selections.
… more
… View more