Based on 441 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
130 S Bridge St, Struthers, OH 44471
Phone: (330) 755-2759
Website: http://www.selahrestaurant.com/
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: getseat.net
Reviews
Marcia Kennedy
Saturday before mother’s day. I went with my son for this special occasion. I can tell you was worthy every minute. From the appetizers to deserts, excellent experience. We had a great server, Austin , everything was outstanding. The place used to be a bank, not sure how old. Higlhy recommended, Will be back for sure.
… more
Jeff Mraz
While visiting my mom in Yoingstown she took us to Selah for coffee and dessert. We absolutely loved it! A nice lady that appeared to be a manager took great care of us and was so friendly and down to earth. First of all, awesome coffee! I had way too much for a late evening, but couldn’t stop drinking it. Our two cakes we all shared were melt-in-your-mouth moist and light. The icing looks rich, but it’s like whipped cream. The building used to be a bank and they’ve kept a lot of the original set-up and built the restaurant around that. Very cool atheistic. I checked out the food menu and it looks very appealing. The next time I’m in town I’ll be sure to eat here. Thanks for a nice relaxing evening.
… more
Tom Paisley
Great find. This place has been recommended to us a few times and we just now got around to checking it out. Everything is homemade. The cocktails are excellent and the atmosphere(remodeled old bank) is interesting and beautiful. Best Old fashion(muddled with Italian cherries) that we can remember.. I’ll be thinking of the gnocchi with meatballs until I can get back there. Nice to find a gem with that vibe of the glory days of Youngstown. Definitely going back. Get the lemon tort.
… more
Ralph Fajack
What a cozy place. I went to a wedding reception here and it felt like I was in Little Italy in a big city. Such a cool place and atmosphere. The food was fantastic and what a perfect day!!
… more
Deborah Larson
Honestly, not much I can say other than, try it! You won’t be sorry! I don’t know how they do it! Always a delight and the food, service, and atmosphere is just all delightful to the soul! Homemade pasta, breads, and cakes made in house every day! Wednesday is gnocchi day with different kinds of gnocchi to choose from and dinner is so popular, you probably should make reservations before you go! You won’t be disappointed with their music and shows too. Def follow them on social media!
… more
Craig Kim
You can tell this food was made to order. But that was about the end of the good about it. The food tasted terrible. You were allowed to walk through some of the food prep area and they weren’t bashful about letting you see mashed potatoes there were sitting out for who-knows-how-long. Also there was a bin of breadcrumbs without lid on it and no lid in sight. It makes you wonder how long it’s it’s like that. In the dining area there was a vent that looks like it’s been years since it’s been cleaned. Now for the good. Service was decent and prices were Fair. Being inside that old Bank was pretty cool
… more
Natalee
We finally got to come for dinner and we were not disappointed. The patio was fantastic we had our own little private nook. The large plants were such as nice touch for privacy. I had a Moscow mule and it was delicious. We started with the smoked fried mozzarella. It was a very nice size serving and paired great with the homemade bread. The olive tapanade was also a nice touch. All of our steaks were cooked perfectly. Food was wonderful. Staff was friendly. We loved the passing of the train right next to the patio as well. We will definitely be back!
… more
Mel Noble
I came to hear music and got some good food as well. It was a busy night and service was slow, but since we were there for the show primarily, it worked out well for us! One of our servers wasn’t the most friendly, but the other gentlemen was great and made up for that. Great time overall!
… more
Jennifer Decker
I’m pretty surprised this restaurant is rated so highly. My husband and I went for the first time tonight, and were underwhelmed. We paid extra for patio seating to hear the musician of the night, but he didn’t start playing until we had been there almost 45 minutes. Additionally, the patio was pretty cramped, and the train/loud traffic went by almost continually. We got the aged meat and cheese board as an appetizer, and it came with 10 slices of salami, 2 kinds of cheese, and 2 piles of candied nuts. Tasty, but again underwhelming when you’re expecting a variety of meat and cheeses. The salads were fine. The entrees were pretty good except for the meatballs which were very bland. Not a bad meal, but overpriced and overrated when there are so many fantastic Italian restaurants in Ytown.
… more
Frank Mercatante
Nice restaurant inside an old bank. Food was good, but the cakes are where they shine brightest, you will not be disappointed. Great patio and alley seating with entertainment some days of the week.
… more
… View more