Based on 171 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH 43026
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 3–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
bryan rooth
We wanted pizza, and the Gahanna location didn’t open till 3 pm on Sat, so we made our way out to Hillard. As expected, it didn’t disappoint. It was great pizza with an awesome crunch and a perfect amount of cheese, pepperoni, and sauce. It was super busy as they had all the tables full and even a birthday party. It didn’t affect our experience, and we received great service. We will definitely be back if in the area. Looking forward to trying the Detroit style next time.
… more
E B
We loved it. The pizza is fantastic. Perfectly cooked, fresh, hot, and nice crisp. 8.1 for sure and I got the shirt to prove it! The bartender was awesome, great drinks, great service, very clean, keno! The pickles are even more awesome. I ate the whole jar of ’em. Ranch dressing is wonderful. Really nice place. We’ll be back.
… more
Midwestern Eats
Average pies at best, The $8 order of Fried Pickles was very small. Got 2 NY Style Pies one just pepperoni, The other was one of their Specialities with Fried Chicken Chunks & hot honey. The crust was perfect. The pies as a whole weren’t anything to go crazy about. It’s definitely better than your chain joints, of course.
… more
Megan Roof
Food was delicious! They were crazy busy but it was a Friday night and the weather was beautiful. Seat yourself, their outdoor patio is nice and offers a lot of additional seating. The ranch is yummy and they have a large drink menu. There is a lot of free parking in the area, but it fills fast on nice evenings, especially since Crooked Can is close by.
… more
Adriana L Amezcua
The place is cool and the patio is really nice! The food was good, but not very healthy. The chicken for the pizza is fried and the mozzarella sticks very greasy. Even the coliflower crust was greasy! It took forever to get 9ur food… Not for a quick lunch I know now.
… more
Darian Louke
Got a pizza from here for the first time last night. The crust was fantastic and crunchy with just a bit of char. The sauce was good though a bit mild. The price for a large was not too bad. It’s a sort of small hole in the wall place, but definitely worth a visit.
… more
Cefcef Cefcef
REVISED 5/5/23 – They had the correct crust available this visit… and it was fantastic! Service was also much better this visit! The Smokey Robinson was delicious! Upping my review to 5 stars.
… more
Donna Celotto Keller
I recently heard about Sexton’s (Hilliard) and finally tried it on 6/25/23. I ordered the Ezzo Pepperoni and it was amazing. I’m originally from Connecticut and I’m a diehard New Haven Neapolitan style pizza girl. It’s taken me years to find anything in the Columbus area that even comes close. This pizza hits every mark!!! We will be back again, again and again!
… more
Jesse G
Best pizza in the area hands down. They make there pizza with a nice char and it comes with a nice well done consistency. Good service and friendly staff!
… more
Constance Kenney
We were highly impressed! Crust was absolutely amazing and the pepperoni was crisped perfectly! Highly recommend trying. Staff and atmosphere were both awesome! We will for sure be back!
… more
… View more