Based on 22 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 5.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
360 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday | 3–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Grant Donnelly
Checked out Sexton’s tonight for the first time.
… more
Mac Zafarana
Couldn’t even wait to take a picture before digging into this beauty. Maybe the best pizza in the city, definitely the best near downtown/campus. The crust is so good, so crispy, nice and charred. The pep cups, forget about it. I’m not usually a ranch on pizza guy but this ranch is so good. Get this pizza.
… more
Thomas Puckett
I’ve had their pizza five times in the last two months, it’s really that good. And *consistently* good, too. Getting just the right amount of char without burning has to be very difficult in terms of quality control, but five times in a row it’s just been perfect. This is easily one of the best pies in Columbus, if not the very best.
… more
Carl Hunter
Hands down the best pizza in Columbus. It’s a NYC style pizza that has the dough to go along with it. Something other places in Columbus can’t seem to figure out. The pizza is also reasonably priced unlike the overrated doughy pizza that Mikey’s Late Night Slice serves up. Great local pizza joint that has tons of potential out of their store. I hope the owners stay true to their roots and keep pumping out awesome pizzas.
… more
Arthur Szu-tu
The Sexton location on third Avenue is just takeout. They have a great system where they tell you when your pizza will be ready (or you can order for it to be ready at a specific time). The pizza offerings are only plain cheese and pepperoni or half-and-half. But this woodfired pizza fresh out of the oven is really good. One of the best in Columbus.
… more
Leigh Oldershaw
Just tried Sexton’s in Harrison West (I live a block away) and it is phenomenal!! Pizza is easily the best in the city, and the staff was super nice too. So, so excited to have this business nearby!
… more
A A
Incredible pizza, best in Columbus and it’s not close, so glad I discovered this place
… more
Mason Liles
Definitely the best pizza in Columbus!
… more
a Jones
Got a pepperoni with basil for the first time and it was amazing! Will be back for sure!
… more
John Swanson
It’s real. Crispy crackin’ crunch that retains the chew, super flavorful dough, little singed pepperoni cups…
… more
… View more