Sicily brings the New Haven tradition of coal fired oven pizza to Middletown plus freshly made pastas, baked breads and locally sourced products. Our bars feature over 86 beers on tap, craft cocktails, a great selection of wines and Happy Hour Specials Monday through Friday from 3:00 to 6:00.
Based on 614 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
412 Main St, Middletown, CT 06457
Phone: (860) 788-2237
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–11 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11:30 AM–11 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
James Fetta
First time trying this bar. Thoroughly impressed with the service and atmosphere. The food was amazing and priced fairly for the massive quantities that you get. Quality was also impeccable.
… more
Jena Vignola
Awesome spot in the middle of town with excellent food and service. Great menu options and lots of specialty pizzas. Great ambiance at the inside bar area, indoor upstairs seating, and nice outdoor patio seating as well. Large food and beer selection. Food was excellent and their signature fries are incredible.
… more
Dominique Ojoe
ok 2 negatives 1 My order had to be redone, and only because it is fresh pasta made right there it took forever. 2. The noise level was a bit much. ok, the positive 1, the waitress, Laynee was so gracious and polite even when my food took long to come out. the ambiance was amazing. The band had us rocking, and I had these potato wedges with garlic parm to the side that was lick your fingers delicious
… more
Melody Rueangrung
Let me preface by saying I LOVE this place. I’ve been here a few times for dinner, each time I had steak and fries which were perfect each time. Drinks are great. So this review is specifically for this order. I called in for a fig pizza and when I opened it at counter, I decided I wanted some greens. Some arugula with prosciutto and fig jam sounds great right? So I asked to put arugula on it. I got home and this is what I saw. I mean – really? It just made it SO unappealing. It was so excessive, that i had to pick them off and put them in a pile. Also the chicken with the Caesar salad was a little dry. So idk what was going on today but maybe it wasn’t the day to have Sicily 🙁
… more
Kevin
Best Italian food in Middletown. We selected outside dining. Street noise can be a little loud. This place has been busy on every visit. I chose the chicken parmesan that gave me plenty of leftovers for the next night. Tough to not order a appetizer due to the great choices. Good list of beers to pick from.
… more
JR’s Pocket
My first visit here. It was just after 10pm, my roommate wanted pizza and didn’t want to go alone, so I went along, short walk from our apt. Before leaving we called and asked how late the kitchen was open. 11pm. In an effort to not put the kitchen staff to work close to closing time we ordered ahead to be ready for when we got there. We definitely implied we wanted to eat it there, but perhaps were not specific enough. I wasn’t present when he was seated, but joined him after. Our server brought out a pizza in a box and took our drink orders. We dug in and started eating. Later, another Server came out and told us that, “the manager wasn’t happy about Us eating there”. We explained, she seemed to already know. I feel it wasn’t necessary for her to come tell us that, and actually ruined some of the experience for me. I don’t get out very often, the pizza was a little light on topping, with adequate sauce, and if our outside on Main St seating on a nice quiet night, hadn’t been so pleasant, I probably wouldn’t come back. Our server was nice, and I tipped more than the 20% suggestion on the receipt
… more
Erica Holbert
I’ve loved every meal I’ve ever gotten here. The outside patio is adorable. The spicy margarita was strong, and have you seen the size of the kids meals? My daughter got the Mac and cheese and it was a full size plate of Alfredo! Priced perfectly for the quality and quantity of food you get.
… more
Caitlin Gallivan
Amazing from the moment you walk I. The door. Friendly staff clean and welcoming environment. The pizza was great!! We had the YOLO the crust is perfect! Our waitress I believe her name was Ashley was the best. Our food came out fast . Definitely will be returning soon to try more on the menu so many different choices.
… more
Adela Ramirez
It’s bigger on the inside. The portions are a great size for the price and the food is really delicious! I got the screaming scilily and I wondered if it was suppose to be a family size, because the size was huge, not that I wanted to share my delicious pasta.
… more
sway Z
very high priced food items that didn’t really fit the ambience, which left a lot to be desired. i was hoping for more of semi upscale ambience with more emotion for what we paid, however i do feel this establishment has amazing potential and seemed to be a favorite among the locals. i will be back most certainly, and look forward to it. first impressions aren’t always bad. i hope Sicily thrives in their success. cheers.
… more
… View more