Based on 178 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
Address:
1207 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
Phone: (716) 447-1207
Website: https://www.snysliceofnewyork.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Yasmene Dergham
Good prices, great food, super nice service! We walked in and our order was ready fast. Best shawarma we’ve found in Buffalo and fun pizza options (plus beef pepperoni!). We tried the chicken tandoori and it was spiced nicely. We will definitely be back. Extra points for being one of the few quick bite local places open later on Hertel.
… more
Jackie Slattery
This place is DELICIOUS.
… more
Daniel
So I am giving them 5 stars because the food I had was freaking great. I had a gyro, and also tried some pizza slices (don’t judge me, I only at about half). The pizza slices were heated up to the perfect point, so that the cheese was a wonderful golden brown, in contrast to a different pizza place I tried close by, where it wasn’t heated up enough, and it was honestly super gross. The gyro was one of the best I’ve had anywhere (even though I prefer the more spongey naan-type bread, it was still one of the best gyros I’ve had). The service was fine, haha, but could have been better, don’t get me wrong, it wasn’t bad…but honestly, if the food is freaking amazing, then I pretty much forget the service, as long as it’s not bad, and it wasn’t. I plan on coming back.
… more
Rohan Kunchakuri
This place has the best shawarma, the best Stromboli and the best pizza!!! The food here is fresh and very well made, the quality of the ingredients they use is amazing. Its a small place but very cozy and has a good vibe. Its very clean and well maintained. The staff is always amazing and very helpful. The service time is very fast, you get your food pretty quickly. Would comeback here to have their shawarma and Stromboli any day. Its very easy to find and it’s located in the best neighbourhood i.e. Hertel Avenue. The shawarma was authentic and made to perfection. It comes with a side of pickles and was 7$. It’s cheap and best, it’s worth every penny you spend. The Stromboli is so fresh, every bite is a tasty delight, the dip you get with it is delicious. You can’t stop eating it. The quantity is really good for the money that you spend. You’ll never go home unsatisfied, the Stromboli is priced 7$ too. You get both of them in a combo meal as well. They even had the famous sweet, bakalva which was 1$ per piece but I couldn’t try it this time. In my next visit I’ll make sure to try new items for sure. 10/10 recommend this place. It’s a gem!
… more
Kaytlan LoCicero
Recently I was recommended to checkout this place because the quality of the pizza was A1. I was skeptical at first because I have been disappointed too many times by other’s pizza recommendations in Buffalo, but I gave it a try anyway. Little did I know that the pizza shop was once a full-blown shawarma shop that I visited years back! Aside from being familiar with the place, I had the opportunity to meet the owner- very nice guy! He goes above and beyond to give the best customer service offers a bright welcome as soon as you pass through the doors. Although the restaurant is small, it’s the place perfect to stop for a bite to eat with some friends. There’s window seating that’s faces Hertel Ave – which is my favorite- as well other seating areas. The ambiance is warm and full of Buffalo pride, and the pizza is AMAZING! This pizza, in my own person pizza loving opinion, is the closet thing to NY Style pizza if you are a fan of thin crust. My favorite so far is pepperoni! The dessert is tasty too if you enjoy homemade baklava.
… more
Vanessa McGuire
The food was outstanding and extremely delicious. I had the veggie pizza and it was very flavorful! My husband had the Italian Stromboli and was very impressed. We also tried the chicken sambosa which was so good. It reminded me of an empanada. The baklava has the perfect amount of sweetness and is not chewy. I highly recommend this place!!
… more
Eileen Spadinger
Loved the chicken shawarma combo I got, I noticed right away the freshness of the ingredients used. I particularly liked the sauce in the shawarma wrap. Great prices too! The restaurant is very clean and staff was both friendly and helpful. Will be back soon!
… more
kristen sizemore
Their pizza is amazing!!Crust is thin light and perfect amount of crisp.Toppings r delicious.Large slices.Restaurant is clean. Big tv with Buffalo Bill’s memorabilia and cozy seating where u can gaze out full window onto the hertel strip.
… more
Juanita Mathis
If I could rate lower- I would! I ordered the chicken shawarma platter online to get a phone 2mins later from the restaurant telling me that they don’t have ANY chicken at the moment!!! Who doesn’t have chicken?!!? He told me to call Slice delivery to request a refund, which I did to only have the rep from Slice delivery tell me that the store already processed the refund which will take 24-48hrs to return for food I never even got. I understand the reviews are good, but I’ll pass!
… more
taylor nigro
Great slices and I hear the shawarma is awesome too, going to have to try it next time
… more
… View more