Based on 114 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
58 Garth Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583
Phone: (914) 472-9725
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rosalynn M
We’ve lived in the area for years but never came across this place. The logo and name of the restaurant made me think it was a new place but once inside it is an old-timey pizza place with pressed tin ceilings and tables and chairs from places I went to growing up in the old Italian parts of Brooklyn. We ordered the Grandma’s pizza and a sausage roll, thinking that all good pizza places should be judged by their Grandma’s pizza. I was a little disappointed with the pizza, since the crust was a little light, the sauce flavorless, and the slices of tomatoes were no better then those from the mass supermarket. There was also not enough basil or other herbs to call this a Grandma’s pizza. Or I wouldn’t want to put my Grandma’s reputation on this pizza. However, the sausage roll was surprising. I didn’t know what to expect when ordering this – is it a sandwich, a fancy garlic knot, or a calzone? It turns out it’s like an open calzone with a side of tomato sauce to with it. The crust on this was way better and chewier than the one on the Grandma’s pizza, and the ratio of sausage to crust was a good ratio. Also, dipping into the sauce elevated it that much more so that you get the flavor but not the sogginess. Would order this again!
… more
Mandy Roberson
My family and I decided to try this pizza shop after reading a few reviews online. Although they do have indoor dining, we sat outside and enjoyed the beautiful weather. We had the plain slice and pepperoni slice. It was unanimous…..The pizza was sooo good. The sauce was delicious. The crust was thin with the right amount of crisp. It wasn’t too greasy and it didn’t flop over when I picked it up. We will definitely make the trip again.
… more
Arthur Glauberman
Slice of Scarsdale is a great neighborhood pizza parlor on Garth Road in Scarsdale. They have excellent pizzas and a friendly staff. Fortunately, they are providing an essential service during our pandemic and are offering delivery and take out. They will also sell pizza dough for $3.50, which is a great bargain! For years they have posted clever signs in front of their store that have brought desperately needed smiles during these crazy times.
… more
Thomas Gherardi
Quality good at reasonable & fair prices. Love their Italian Sauce…..
… more
Midiam Diaz
Very thin slices not worth the money. The only good thing I ordered was the garlic knots, but the pepperoni pizza was bad. Me and my son got sick a day later with stomach aches. I’m thinking because we were the last people to order before closing ♀️ it’s just unacceptable the delivery man took about an hour in a half we had to call them to see if our food was still going to be delivered. I def won’t waste my money here again not sure how clean they really are
… more
Ayan Barnwal
The pizza is very good- better than most in the village. It’s your classic New York-style pizza. It’s usually not soggy, although it is sometimes when there are many orders at once. The buffalo pizza is my personal favorite, but they’re all pretty good.
… more
Ramon Abdullah Hilario
I spend my lunch buying this roll and when i finally opened this is waht i got, over cooked roll then when i went back they dont even apologized. Poor customer service
… more
Cartara Emma
Went here yesterday and the pizza is awesome! 😀
… more
Kenneth de la Torre
Best pizza in this neck of the woods. The white slice and pepperoni rolls are so dang good. Never a disappointment, you always get great food at Slice!
… more
Maria
Just awful food. I ordered eggplant parmigiana and regular pizza. The eggplant was mushy and rubbery with practically no breading. The pizza is mostly dough. I threw away eggplant, it was inedible.
… more
… View more