Based on 54 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
20 County Rd 39, Southampton, NY 11968
Phone: (631) 377-3909
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sally Doulton
Kudos to Peter and the staff for making a delicious grilled chicken club for me. The chicken was tender, and the tomatoes with lettuce and red onion were fresh. I was also impressed with my slice of “Peter’s Drunken.” I haven’t had a tasty slice of pizza like that in a long time. I will return to try their other sandwiches, and salads, and to order a whole “Peter’s Drunken” pie.
… more
Gerard
I stopped in for a quick slice on my way from the airport to the Hamptons. I just wanted a good old NY pizza. Instead I had a slice of their veggie pizza and was blown away. It could compete on the best cooking shows! The staff is friendly and sincerely dedicated to their craft. I’d give them 6 stars if I could.
… more
Anne
I want to start out by saying that the owner Pat has been extremely kind and helpful each time I’ve called for help with an order. I have always mindlessly ordered from Seamless for Slice of the Hamptons but each time they cancelled, and Pat calls right away to make sure that everything gets taken care of. All our orders get delivered on time and delicious at that! I always appreciate Pat’s help so much because I don’t have to worry when placing large orders. They are the best!
… more
Erica Ascher
Some of the BEST and MOST DELICIOUS pizza I’ve gotten to try!! You would never expect such incredible pizza to be inside of a Dunkin. The pizza with fig jam was in-freaking-credible and so creative!! The vodka sauce on the Peter’s Drunken Grandma slice was some of the best sauce I’ve ever tasted! And you can’t go wrong with Peter’s Grandma because that red sauce is so flavorful! We finished off with some cannolis with fig jam and OH MY GOODNESS that was heavenly!!! This place is a must-visit and must-try! 15/10 would recommend!!!!!!
… more
Nick Stratos
My family stumbled upon this place while on route to Montauk visiting from Toronto. Best meal I’ve had on the Island for a fraction of the price. Incredible fresh and great portion. Very delicious!! Wow.
… more
Wendy
Great wraps and other food! Friendly cook and owner! would 100% recommend stopping by here. It’s in the same building as Dunkin Donuts, plenty parking in the back with in door seating and outdoor seating as well. If you like hot sauce I recommend asking he makes an in house mix sauce that’s really good!
… more
J M
5 stars!?! C’mon. Slightly above average pizza from a very nice owner, inside a Dunkin Donuts on the Highway. Slices out here are terrible, and this joint is better than most out here, but it is just semi decent. 5 stars is silly for this spot.
… more
Emily Kyle
The garlic knots are really good. Not greasy like others I have had. The bread used to make them was fresh & fluffy. Friendly service. However – my calzone was so disappointing I had to knock off 2 stars. I would definitely return to try their pizza as it seems to have food reviews. But this calzone… do not recommend. There was so much ricotta cheese in it that the bread was soggy. It was more ricotta than bread, pepperoni & mozzarella combined.
… more
Daniel Slattery
Found this place passing through while driving for work and thought I would give this place a shot and man was I glad I did. Probably some of the best New York style pizza I’ve had in a long time. The sauce is a little on the sweeter side but nonetheless was still great. Counter staff were extremely friendly and gives you that authentic small town/community feeling. The Philly cheesesteak was killer too. Fairly priced as well considering it’s in Southampton where you usually find food places that aren’t fast food to be on the pricier side. Parking is kind of a pain to get in and out but considering how busy the main road is it’s kind of expected. Will be frequenting this place more often.
… more
Seek Submit Surrogacy
Service and atmosphere is good but the food sucks. Do not come here for authentic pizza, they’re cutting corners and it’s operating out of a Dunkin’ Donuts, this must be a locals spot lol
… more
… View more