Smitty’s Overtime Inn, in Tomah, WI, is the area’s leading restaurant serving Tomah, Monroe County and surrounding areas. We offer fish fry, prime rib, chicken, ribs, seafood, burgers, homemade pizza and more. For your next meal, visit Smitty’s Overtime Inn in Tomah!
Serving homemade pizza until bar is closed!
Kitchen Hours Tuesday-Saturday: 11:00AM-9:00PM.
Kitchen Hours Sunday: 11:00AM-8:00PM.
Based on 509 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No delivery
Address:
8293 WI-173, Tomah, WI 54660
Phone: (608) 372-5499
Website: https://smittysovertimeandinn.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dave ‘Jr’
Stopped in on a Sunday late around 7pm, just the time when most restaurants kick ya mediocre food and send you on your way. Can’t remember our waitress’ name but she was a godsend. Told us she was filling in due to a call off and had been there all day. She was phenomenal. Took care of us and two other packed tables who both arrived same time as us.
… more
Roxanne
The food was delightful, Had the prime rib queen cut. We shared one, perfect amount of food between two people, with an extra salad purchased… And the onion rings were delicious! The waitress was attentive, friendly and helpful. Will be back! Even the other diners were friendly.
… more
Jim Cozad
Definitely a locals hangout. We went in for dinner. Overall, no one in our group was overly impressed. I had the special of the day sirloin tips with mashed potatoes and gravy. The mashed potatoes were good, definitely homemade as was the gravy. Sirloin was pretty dry and not much of it. For the price it I would have liked more. The bartender was very attentive considering we weren’t locals. Sure the atmosphere is better if this is your hangout.
… more
mitch boettcher
Top tier for a small town eatery and bar. Very impressive it still has a salad bar and entrées from simple to above average. The service is great and I have always been welcomed by the locals. Definitely would tell a friend to try it out.
… more
Samantha Maynard
Pretty good place! Never eaten here before, never heard of it, so thought we would give it a shot. Glad we did. Its off the main drag, so prob why never heard of it. I got the pizza, hubs got the Fri special: Prime Rib. He couldnt get over how good it was. I agree…very tender. The pizza was ok-nothing special. Our waitress was nice & very attentive-checking on us & refilling drinks. I ordered a chef salad to go w the pizza-she said i could just go & clean out the salad bar instead-and offered us all salad bar just to get rid of the stuff. Everything u want 4 a salad. The chili was pretty good also! Hubs said he would def go back since hes stationed here!
… more
Jill
Small, Hometown bar/restaurant. What an awesome menu,such variety! We loved our meal! prices were reasonable, service was awesome. Drinks were good. We will absolutely return here on our next drive through town, in one year!! Wish it was closer to home. Would highly recommend stopping here. Dinner and quite a few drinks and still under $60!
… more
Jeffrey Rabold
Went here this morning, wanting their Sunday buffet. Guess what, no buffet anymore. I was so bummed. I just got a grilled cheese, ate and left. The bartender was very nice but this is more of a local hangout than a option to eat something different.
… more
Seth Johnson
It’s 50 50. Here, food is usually good but getting service can be a challenge. Multiple times my party has left after 10 plus minutes of not being seated. But everyone is great and i understand the challenges of today.
… more
Haley McCormick
Fun local restaurant. Staff is always friendly. There is a Bar area and dining area. Food is so freaking awesome. Fish fry is to die for. Burgers are supremely yummy . You gotta try this place.
… more
Jason Young
Good food but no vegetarian burger options. Tap list was small but the best I found in Tomah. Wait staff was talented and personable
… more
… View more