Brothers Sonny and Tony along with their father, Dominic, opened Sonny and Tony”s Pizza and Italian Restaurant in late 2005.Combined, they brought over a 100 years experience in the restaurant business serving pizza and Italian food and catering to Mahwah, ramsey and the suffern ny . Their love for the taste of the old country, as well as their commitment to excellent, friendly service is evident to everyone who frequents the restaurant. Today, their passion lives on as Sony and Tony’s is among the most popular spots to eat in the northern Bergen County. We’d love to have you come on in and see for yourself!
Easygoing choice for classic pizzas, as well as red-sauce Italian dishes & sandwiches. Based on 522 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
400 Ridge Rd, Mahwah, NJ 07430
Phone: (201) 529-4001
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: sonnyandtonys.com
Reviews
Heather Laski
I moved out of NJ 7+ years ago, but every time I visit, Sonny and Tony’s makes the go-to list. I get the stuffed rigatoni vodka and a cappuccino for dessert, and am never disappointed. They’ll be a favorite for life! Also love that it’s BYOB.
… more
Jon Ansell
Over on a business trip and called in for some pie. Amazing restaurant and great staff. Faultless experience. I was defeated by a very large best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. Thank you for helping make my Mahwah trip memorable.
… more
K J
Phenomenal chicken francese. There were two cutlets of this size in the photo and came with plenty of sauce for dipping with fresh bread and a lovely salad. My husband loved his pizza as well. Thank you so much Sonny & Tony’s!!
… more
Rosemary Brennan
Love the food here,friendly staffand can bring the family here plus inexpensive. Update just went back here last night food is so good love the pizza.update just had a delivery from here got a personal pizza with extra cheese it arrived on time and it was in perfect condition the cheese didn’t slide off the pizza .When I get it at other places always find it is a mess cheese all over the place except the pie.Great job Sonn and Tony’s a the delivery man.udate 4 /26/23 Had a delivery made pizza very good but they have to cut the pit better this isn’t the first time had this issue trouble pulling apart and finding where one slice ends and one begins. Other than that pizza was delicious.
… more
James M
Update September 2022: Without warning they stopped honoring and participating in the pizza points on the slice app. However, you still need to order the pizza off slice and pay the local fees without any benefit. Unfortunately I have 7 pizza points and needed one more for a free pizza. I accepted that they needed to raises prices on their menu and I continued to order, but this is one more way to alienate and be cheap towards loyal customers. You’ve lost my business of purchasing weekly, what a shame, but shame on you.
… more
michael baum
We were tired after driving all day and decided to order a takeout pizza. We just gambled on this place and it was a definite home run. Had the personal size house special, garlic knots, and cannoli. When I walked in to pick up the order I realized that we should have dined in. The pizzas in the showcase looked awesome along with all the other items they offered. Our own order was one of the best pizzas we’ve eaten and was plenty big enough for two. The garlic knots were great and the cannoli was fantastic. A definite surprise hit. Next time we dine in.
… more
Dan Cohen
Friday Night 05-12 Younger Mexican Waiter with Black curly hair – He was really bad forgot to bring part of the dinner out told him about it, instead of just going to get what I needed to start eating he went to another table took their check first – struggled to figure out their tab, had to get up & ask him again. He went on with the other tables bill & then finally took care of us – Take out only from now on – Food is good never had a problem here till this bad service with this one waiter.
… more
Soraida Valentine
Great food at reasonable prices and the salad comes with your entree asking with delicious bread and 2 pieces of bruchetta. The staff are very attentive. Hubby had the grouper special with shrimp and clams but he doesn’t like clams so Oscar gave him more shrimp! I had my chicken piccata and spaghetti on the side with marinara sauce delicious I came home with the doggy bag as I also ordered the sauteed spinach with garlic yummy!
… more
Luisa Gonzalez
After a great dinner a delicious cappuccino made by our favorite Oscar at Sonny and Tonnys. We love going there, the staff is so friendly and attentive, we have been going for 15 years now! Always great food and great service.
… more
Gary Vaughn
Found ourselves in New Jersey and decided we wanted to try something Italian and local. The food was excellent. Delivery was extremely fast. Special instructions were followed perfectly. If I am ever back in the area we will be a return customer! Next time we want to visit the restaurant if at all possible. Thank you for making a rainy evening fun!
… more
… View more