Spaghetti Incident Menu – New York, NY

Type : Italian restaurant

Location : New York, NY

Homey Italian kitchen featuring a variety of pasta dishes & Sicilian-style rice balls. Based on 757 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Spaghetti Incident 10002

Address:
231 Eldridge St, New York, NY 10002

Phone: (646) 896-1446

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 5–10 PM
Wednesday 5–10 PM
Thursday 5–10 PM
Friday 5–11 PM
Saturday 5–11 PM
Sunday 5–10 PM
Monday 5–10 PM

Menu

Main Menu
Brussel Sprouts
Sautéed with Raisins & Walnuts in Lemon Vinaigrette Dressing
$16.00
Crostini Misti
Ricotta, Caramelized Figs, Mint & Lemon Zest; Sundried Tomatoes Purée & Burrata Spread; Gorgonzola & Roasted Walnuts
$17.00
Burrata
Creamy Mozzarella with Arugula, Celery & Cherry Tomatoes in Sicilian Dressing
$16.00
Polpette Della Nonna
Five Meatballs in our Homemade Tomato Sauce & Toasted Bread
$18.00
Beef Ragu & Fontina $14.00
Artichoke & Parmigiano $14.00
Pesto & Gorgonzola $16.00
Mix Of The 3 $16.00
Caesar
Romaine Lattuce, Croutons & Parmigiano
$16.00
Caprese
Homemade Mozzarella, Arugula & Organic Heirloom Tomatoes
$15.00
Beet & Goat Cheese
Roasted Beets, Baby Spinach, Goat Cheese & Walnuts
$16.00
Chitarra
Homemade Mozzarella & Basil in Fresh Chopped Tomato Sauce
$22.00
Ragu Bolognese
Our Traditional Ground Beef Tomato Sauce
$21.00
Bucatini Amatriciana
Sautéed Onion & Italian Pancetta in Tomato Sauce
$20.00
Rigatoni Salsiccia E Broccoli
Italian Sausage & Broccoli Rabe in White Wine Sauce
$21.00
Carbonara
Crispy Pancetta, Parmigiano, Organic Yolk & Black Pepper
$22.00
Bucatini Pasticciati
Italian Sausage in Pink Sauce
$20.00
Fettuccine Di Spinaci
Gorgonzola Sauce, Parmigiano & Black Sesame Seeds
$22.00
Pesto Di Cavolo Nero (Kale Pesto)
Kale, Walnuts, Parmigiano & EVOO
$21.00
Salmone & Asparagi
Steamed Asparagus, Capers & Fresh Salmon in Creamy Sauce
$22.00
Lasagna Bolognese
Traditional Beef Ragu Sauce & Béchamel
$23.00
Tagliatelle Ai Porcini
Porcini, Cremini, Shitake Mushrooms & Truffle Oil
$24.00
Spaghetti & Polpette (Meatballs)
Grandma’s Secret Recipe in Homemade Tomato Sauce
$24.00
Chicken Cutlet
Breaded & Fried, with Arugula Salad & Cherry Tomatoes
$26.00
Panna Cotta
Budino Al Caramello
Chocolate Cake
Tiramisu’
Montepulciano $11.00
Chianti $12.00
Cabernet $11.00
Nero D’Avola $13.00
Pinot Grigio $12.00
Sauvignon Blanc $13.00
Chardonnay $11.00
Rose’ $12.00
Prosecco $13.00
Peroni $9.00
Menabrea $10.00
Spritz $14.00
Coke $3.50
Diet Coke $3.50
Sprite $3.50
Ginger Ale $3.50
Sparkling Water $5.00
Espresso $3.50
Cappuccino $5.00
Desserts
Panna Cotta $6.00
Budino Al Caramello $6.00
Chocolate Cake $7.00
Lemon Meringue Pie $7.00
Tiramisu $7.00
Espresso $2.50
Decaf Espresso $3.00
Double Espresso $3.50
Double Decaf Espresso $4.00
Cappuccino $4.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: resy.com

Reviews

rohit mehra
We had the worst experience. We ordered chef’s special and explicitly mentioned it to be vegetarian. However our pasta had anchovies in it. We complained and pasta was replaced. However the restaurant did not seem to know the difference between vegetarian and non vegetarian and after knowing we are vegetarians they should have checked the ingredients with us. It was an allergen and against our religious beliefs.

… more

Debbie Vu
Went here on Valentine’s so service was slow and inattentive. They didn’t bring us individual plates to have the bread (we had to take from another table). If you plan to eat here, DO NOT get the burrata app, tasteless. Most of the dishes were heavily under seasoned, especially their pasta special that day which is a seafood one. Their arancini was super fatty and cheesy and just made me bloated and stuffy right after. Also the seating area outside has bugs and mosquitoes

… more

Asaf Israel
Their CHITARRA is best in town. The spaghetti here is phenomenal and very consistent. More people should come here!!!! Great food and reasonable pricing.

… more

Susanna Mostaghim
Really enjoyed the food here. It was delicious and had good portions. If there’s anything “spicy” on the menu think white people medium at most. I got a daily special with jalapenos in the pasta and all I felt was a minor tickle at the end. Service was fast and super helpful. Really cute spot!

… more

Faith Brewster
Very meh. The carbonara wasn’t bad, pretty flavorful. The lasagna was very bitter and underwhelming I could make a better one for a fraction of the cost. Wouldn’t go out of my way to come back. Also kinda overpriced for such small portions.

… more

C. Guese
New York is not necessarily famous for pasta, but if you are in the mood for some, you should definitely go here. It is a quaint little neighborhood restaurant that serves truly amazing homemade pasta. I had the one with asparagus and salmon and it was just delicious. The staff was also super friendly. Highly recommended.

… more

Matthew Anderson
Food was great service was amazing. Enjoyed the chitarra and polpette Della nonna.

… more

Daniel Pino
Layout/atmosphere

… more

Name
Excellent service and excellent food great place to take a date. Update: This place has not changed except for one thing, the place is as great as it always has been. Back to that one change… I think they may have added one or two menu items and the food…. THE FOOD TASTE BETTER!

… more

Christopher Chow
Most excellent pasta ever. I am a fussy Singaporean who loves good food and believe me this place offers one of the best. Warm service and great food. Nothing more my son and I could ask for!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions