Enduring tavern specializing in thin-crust pies, burgers & brews in simple, tin-ceilinged digs. Based on 287 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5813 Main St, McFarland, WI 53558
Phone: (608) 838-8511
Hours
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
iNguyening Tran
Pretty good food/pizza, service was ok…I say it’s at least 3.5 ⭐️ but that’s it. I would try it again just in case it was an off night for the services. Pretty decent price considering there are lots of crazy places with high prices out there.
… more
Kathy Huseby
This place is wonderful, I have eaten at green lantern and maple tree, no one compares to this great restaurant. The shrimp dinner was wonderful. Our server was excellent! This is the place to go! Thanks for the great food, service and fun !
… more
Russel Reppen
Spartan has great pizza and large selection of beer. Went for dinner of pizza. Was really taken away by a special pizza on the menu – BBQ – Blue Berry. Outstanding and only seasonal because of blue berries. Note photos for ingredients. They have very good food, but this was unbelievable. Limited time so don’t hesitate.
… more
Sarah Coon
The Pizza was great. The delivery was bad. The delivery was Eat Street. The delivery man left the pizza on the steps….didn’t ring the door bell. ANTS WERE CRAWLING ON IT. Needless to say we were not happy.
… more
Lexi D.
The chicken bacon ranch pizza is always spot on! I typically hate getting food to-go because it’s never as good as where it’s cooked, but this pizza is!!!
… more
Brian Storms
Been visiting McFarland’s big 4: Spartan Pizza, Angelo’s, Green Lantern, & Toby’s for 20+ years. I recently went Spartan Pizza with my wife and it was the worst service we’ve ever had. The bartender denied the cocktail we asked for (they had the drink in stock) and said “I won’t put a mixer with that” and proceeded to not make the drink. We ordered a different bourbon that he said he would mix with and it was very weak. We took one sip each, then cancelled our pizza order, paid, and left. The bartender’s customer service and attitude was one of the worst I’ve ever seen. We won’t be back, not even for the pizza.
… more
Cindy Mortensen
In the 47 year I’ve been ordering food at this awesome Family restaurant, I can only ever remember having great food and service. Tonight was another great experience.
… more
Catz Mamaz
I had the “brat pizza” it sounded SO different…and it was in a really good way! Dill pickles and brats on pizza? It sounded like my kind of weird…sooooo I wished I had ordered a larger size to have some left over, the cheesy garlic bread was excellent as well. I’m knocking off one star because I ordered a “side salad” and the lady called telling me they only had “pizza toppings” for their salads so I ended up with a small container of iceberg lettuce with black olives on top. That was kind of a rip…but it IS a pizza place not a salad place so to speak…and that pizza was the bombdiggidy.
… more
James Crowell
Best cheeseburger pizza I’ve ever had. Great crust, generous toppings, good price, clean nice environment, and superb service. Wanted to go back the next day, but we still had half a pizza leftover in fridge. Also recommend the cauliflower bites.
… more
Scott Sawyer
Great pizza. Veggie, Meat Lovers and Spartan Deluxe are all really good. The pizza has thin crust and is cut into squares. It’s original. Great beer also
… more
… View more