Based on 369 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
32620 State Rte 26, Carthage, NY 13619
Phone: (315) 493-4444
Website: http://www.stefanospizzeria.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Marc Palmieri
SAVE YOUR MONEY!!! The food was below average. If you can I would save the money you are going to spend and make a dish at home. As an inspiring food critic I have visited over 30 different states, 4 different countries and ate at countless restaurants and I wouldn’t recommend their food to anyone. My wife and I got charged a 8 dollar delivery fee that was never disclosed to us as well as spent 70 dollars to feed a family of 3. After I called with a complaint that my food was not fresh and was refrigerator cold he said that “ he’s over this conversation” and he refunded our money back. Below I will post how the wing sauce separates which is not normal and the honey mustard separates as well.
… more
David Stenberg
Pros:
… more
Tony Swann
Well above average pizza! This place is kind of out in the middle of nowhere just past Fort Drum military installation. Is super convenient to get to very quick service! I’ve eaten here for lunch it’s lunch about 4 times in the last 3 weeks and have not been disappointed. Their pizza prices are absolutely fantastic a drink and 2 huge slices of pizza come to $7.83. There are about 6 booth style seats inside is inside and a few bistro tables outside. The table next to me had Buffalo wings which looked fantastic, so that’s my next sampling on the next trip.
… more
Brad Paradis
We finished up with an event at the Carthage school I need a quick place to eat before heading back home.
… more
Mick Giroux
Last night (8/8/23) on a return from the ADK’s we stopped in for a meal and were very well pleased. We had the Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Parm and a Pizza to go for work the next day. The food was genuinely excellent. The pasta was perfectly cooked. with flavory sauces in both cases. The tomato sauce “did not” taste like store bought but home made and the Alfredo sauce was just as good. The pizza is not limpy and weak. During the meal the chef came out to ask us how we liked the meal which I appreciate. I highly recommend Stefano’s in Watertown.
… more
T A
It’s hard to stop in Carthage for a family get together over the holidays without stopping by Stefano’s for some pizza.
… more
Mr. TDY Man
Stopped at this pizza place on my way back to my hotel from Ft. Drum. It is conveniently located just off post. The restaurant is clean, staff was friendly and most importantly they have a pesto pie. I ordered a large and it did not disappoint. The cheese on it is what other places would consider extra cheese. The crust has good flavor all to itself. I absolutely loved their Pesto pie. I highly recommend. If I lived here this would be my go to pizza place.
… more
Karen knellinger
Very good, quick & hot. Definitely be back.
… more
E W
Food is amazing and so are the employees. Only downfall is, if you live on post it will take over an hour to get your food. So make sure you order way ahead of time so you don’t get hangry. Lol
… more
Jacob Deck
SO DISAPPOINTING! Actually not sure… MIGHT have tasted better than it looked, but three of the items we ordered, we DIDN’T EVEN TRY (See photos).
… more
… View more