Based on 138 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
255 S Wellwood Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
Phone: (631) 225-2020
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Valentina Rodriguez
Pizza got delivered very cold, but has a good taste to it. Hot wings were crispy, also cold though… garlic knots tasted different from ones I had in the past (Brooklyn native) but they were alright . Price was fair. I would have Wish the food was nice and hot, maybe I would of given them better review and more stars…
… more
Anthony Milazzo
65 dollars down the tube…..
… more
Nick
I’m never ordering from here again, I ordered today and they told me 45 minutes for a hero and wings… at an hour not here I called to order another hero and they said the guy already left, I order a new hero and went to the store topick it up. (Mind you I live 2 blocks away). This delivery driver still isn’t here with original order it’s been 1 hour and 15 minutes.. you’d think the owner would accommodate me somehow but nope not even an apology. well enjoy you just lost a customer..
… more
Talen Stormclaw
I am a regular customer to this pizzeria for several years. Not once have I ever had a bad slice of pizza and I come back weekly for their long island famous Buffalo pizza pies. No other pizzeria makes buffalo slices like Stellas II and when I have visitors from other states I always bring them to stellas so when they think of New York Pizza, they remember the best pizza in new york.
… more
Andrew Reynolds
Spent a long time loving this pizza. Theyre still good, but not the same. I came in and got 3 slices, was told the pie just came out. Maury would agree that was a lie, since they had to go back in for 15min to heat up and were over-heated(couldnt eat the crust). Plus I paid full price for a soda, so $10 for 3 slices and a 20oz soda? Shoulda got a full pie and it woulda been fresh and a couple dollars more.
… more
Fred Hofmann
No question.Simply the Best in Lindenhurst by far.I love their food and its ALWAYS fresh…Unlike other pizzererias that you go in and see the slices look gross old etc Stellas has EVERYTHING FRESH EVERYDAY!
… more
Matt Rampersad
Amazing!! Great atmosphere, good food and an awesome secret dessert only available on Fridays!! What more could be asked of a restaurant? I recommend this place for whenever you’re in the mood for a nice slice or some delicious pasta!
… more
Thomas Benci (lowfuyr)
We had plain large pie. Good cheese, sauce and crusts 5/5. Grilled chicken Caesar salad was good too, just not enough dressing on the side.
… more
Barry Scarth
I ordered with a delivery time if 7:00pm, it was just delivered at 6:25pm. Guests are not here pizza will not be fresh when I wanted it at 7:00pm.
… more
Vanessa Doyle
It’s our Friday go to! I love the crispy wings! We get the family special.. cheese pie, knots, salad and wings! You can’t beat it! Yummm!
… more
… View more