Based on 411 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5049 Bobby Hicks Hwy #105, Gray, TN 37615
Phone: (423) 207-0181
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alli Traywick
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had, we did order with light sauce, like light light sauce and it still came with a bit more towards the crust. Toppings were very generous on the meaty one. Over all the entire family rated it 4 stars. My daughter loves the boneless wings, I wasn’t a huge fan they have sauce all over and I prefer regular wings. The ranch is good, surprise cuz most places around here seem watered down.
… more
Margret Adams Porter
Needed a quick stop for dinner and so glad we chose Stephen’s Pizzeria. Quaint little place with super friendly folks. There’s nothing hardly better than a good pepperoni pizza and they have it down! Seriously delicious. Crust on point and so much cheese. One of the best pizzas we’ve had in a long time.
… more
Tiffani Conn
Very disappointed at this meal as I eat here weekly and I never ever have an issue with anything I get, nor with staff. But today I got a simple bacon calzone, that is completely burnt, the top is soggy, and not cooked through all the way. I only give a 4 star for this disappointing meal because the staff was apologetic and gave me a refund without any hassle which is always appreciated, as I said this is the first time I’ve ever had something this terrible here, so I’ll still be coming back but just make sure to check your food before you leave!
… more
Elizabeth Wilson
Parking was much more open than I’ve seen before when the lovely coffee shop next door was closing on Saturday. We ordered a couple of personal pizzas, as well as a 10” plate cheesy breadsticks (just be aware it costs as much as the menu-listed 14”). Service is friendly. I didn’t find the personal pizzas to be “NY Style”, more like a classic crust. Ingredients were great though, no complaints on the flavor or quality! They have cans of Coke or Pepsi fountain drinks, would’ve loved to see some glass bottle options like Mexican Coke or Boylan Crème Soda.
… more
Tim Harpster
This is by far the best pizza place I have ever been to! The food was incredible, perfectly cooked, and it came to our table very quickly. I would highly recommend everyone try out the locally owned pizza place, you will not regret it!!
… more
Tonya Jones
The pizza and bread sticks were great. The pizzas came out piping hot and we didn’t have to wait very long. Staff was very friendly. This will be our go to for pizza for now on.. The restaurant was very clean.
… more
David Henderson
Friendly staff and great pizza. Highly recommend the Philly Cheese Steak pizza.
… more
Colin Kelley
Stopped in after working late, guys were really nice and accommodating. I had a sausage and mushroom calzone with a 1/2 Greek salad, my co-worker ordered a buffalo chicken calzone, which isn’t on the menu, but they gladly gave it a try. We both enjoyed our food, great portions and good service.
… more
Logan Byington
I drove past the location and was excited to see a local pizzeria amid the sea of chain joints. I came back a couple hours later after looking online at reviews, photos, and the menu, all of which impressed. The pricing was on par with other local pizza joints (think Main Street in JC and Kingsport) and the staff friendly enough. I ordered a cheesebread, personal pep pizza, and a philly sandwich. The cheesesticks were good, though a little over seasoned. That’s where any pleasantness ended. My pizza arrived and looked, and felt, like a frozen pizza you can pull out of any supermarket freezer. I took a few bites and asked my co-eater to try a bite and see if it reminded her of anything. She immediately said, “frozen pizza”. Even the crust tasted like it was a Red Barron. I don’t hate frozen pizza, so I continued on at that point only really annoyed by the price. My co-eater then asked me to try her steak from the sandwich and it was…..not great. No real beef flavor and just bland. About halfway through the sandwich, she pulls something out of it and we begin to examine it. It wasn’t a hair but was METAL. I took it up front, where about 4-5 employees were standing around, and produced the sandwich and metal. One girl who was working, took it, turned to a male employee and very matter-of-factly states, “it’s steel wool”. They quickly apologized and offered a remake or refund of the sandwich. I took the refund and left very unsatisfied. I’m not sure if I went on an off day or what, but I’m very puzzled by the other reviews of delicious food.
… more
Melissa Henry
Local, quick service pizza place. Good for take out or an informal bite to eat. Original and traditional flavors. Gluten-free crust is available on request.
… more
… View more