Casual pizza place with a bar serving a variety of thin-crust pies in strip-mall surrounds. Based on 529 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
138 S Wilcox St, Castle Rock, CO 80104
Phone: (303) 814-1800
Website: http://stumpysnewyorkpizza.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Josh Hay
Stayed at jellystone in larkspur. Called in for pick up. Perfect timing. Pies was ready when arrived. Staff was friendly. Thank you stumpys, for making this camping trip for a pizza night out.
… more
Justin medina
Came from Illinois for a baseball tournament. Wanted some pizza looked at the reviews and man, this place doesn’t disappoint. Best thin crust pizza I had in a while. Definitely NY pizza taste.
… more
Aaron R. (7th sage of Sabian)
Outstanding service, and food. The garlic cheese bread, will break your heart! The pizza sauce has a great taste, and the cheese blend is surprisingly flavorful. Gretchen took top notch care of us, and made sure my beer was frosty cold. I definitely recommend, and I will be going back.
… more
Hope H
After the Renaissance Faire I was hungry for real food so we stopped in here. Reminds me a pizza place I went as a child with my dad. All the pin ball, the atmosphere, the decorations, and even the smell. The burger was fine and the fries were meh. I really enjoyed the garlic knots even if they were swimming in oil it looked like. I should have gotten some pizza bit we couldn’t agree on one to share it looked super good. Margherita was small but well done and a good price. Daily drinking specials and the lunch special is good!
… more
Marilyn M
While both my husband and I were craving one of their delicious burgers, sadly, they were only offering pizza due to staffing issues. We still love them, though, and will continue to be customers!
… more
Zachary Fienen
I enjoyed my visit to Stumpys in Castle Rock. The food was pretty good and it arrived quickly. They also had good appetizers. The atmosphere was friendly and they also had arcade games and pinball. Definitely a fun place to go for a bit to eat.
… more
Joe Winnell
Absolutely stellar NY style pizza. The difference in their fresh ingredients, and the chains, and even non-chains, is significant. The hard part will be not craving their food every day.
… more
Molly L
I was patiently waiting at home for this pizza, I love NY style pizza, I grew up on it. When I opened the box I was so excited, the pizza was perfect if only we didn’t eat it before I took the picture. The crust, crispy and flakey, it had the perfect amount flop when easily folded. Cheese blanketed the sauce like the first snow of the year. The sauce was sweet, with hints of oregano. Dave Portnoy would say 10/10
… more
Jenn R
Food was good! Service wasn’t great. Hoping the waitress was just having an off night. Left her a note and a generous tip considering.
… more
Sean Allen
Easily the best pizza I’ve had in Colorado in 20 years. We drive 30 minutes each way to eat here – it’s that good. Not another slice is in the same neighborhood. It’s the only legitimate NY pizza in this state that I’ve had. The pinball games and affordable beers are a nice plus. They also have really friendly service and great mozzerella sticks.
… more
… View more