Based on 245 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4529 University Way NE, Seattle, WA 98105
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sierra Crawford
¹/²cheese/pepperoni Pizza was on Point Delicious! When it was our turn at the counter, staff was kind and happy to make what we wanted happen. Those cooking the Pie were so friendly and happy to be there. We waited & had drinks at the bar…. we recommend (adult beverage) Hawaiian blue iceeeee. Cody served us, he was RAD! Staff had our Pizza ready half way through our drinks and held it for us in the warmer so it was hot n ready to walk the few blocks to our flat. We walked in the rain and the pizza was still hot when we got back. 10/10 recommend this spot
… more
Paul Zenone
This used to be the Original Pagliacci but now it’s this Rockn bar and Pizza place . Came in for a slice and stayed for some beers will be back the Bartender was Awesome the food was great and the beer was COLD and YUMMY
… more
Garden Evils
By far the best pizza dough in the city. The flavor symphony on each slice will always leave you satisfied. Don’t skip on the garlic knots either, they are KILLER. Grab a slice, order a pie, take a bite of your friends pizza… doesn’t matter. Get this pizza in your mouth and you won’t regret it.
… more
Ian Suchon
New York pizza is the best pizza and Supreme has good pizza for good prices – a good place to relax with friends too. I tried the frozen cocktail and it was really sweet and took me kind of a while to drink. But the regular drinks are good so I recommend going that direction. Nice ambience & friendly staff as well. Been there, recommended to friends, and came back!
… more
BrewGirl China
A bit too oily to my liking, but they are delicious! Favorite is chicken teriyaki.
… more
zh vl
Pizza was ok, a little bit greasy, not expensive.
… more
Andrew Lee
I had heard about Supreme in West Seattle but I’m not around those parts often so I was happy to hear that a location was opening on the Ave. I believe I visited right after they got their liquor license which meant they had expanded their hours to 2am even on Sundays, which is the day I visited. The ambiance is dark and at night the neon gives off a reddish glow. There is a 21-and-over area in the back half of the bar and an all ages area where you order the pizza. When I went, the bouncer/security was the one to check IDs if patrons were going to the bar. The bouncer was friendly and was probably the most approachable of the people working that day. When it comes to the pizza I had a slice of the Hawaiian which had Portuguese sausage, pineapples, and jalapenos. It is similar to a NY slice with its thin crust. It tasted really good and the saltiness of the Portuguese sausage was balanced with the sweetness and tartness of the pineapple and the spiciness of the jalapenos. Come to think of it, the Portuguese sausage was probably used because that is more Hawaiian than Canadian bacon. I also had a few bites of the square pizza slices. It was thick and doughy with pepperoni, scoops of ricotta, and Carolina reaper pepper somehow integrated. It had quite a kick and tasted really good. The slices were around $5 which is a nice price for the quality and size of the slices you’re getting. I definitely hope to return and try the garlic knots and the Ono slice that has fried chicken, kimchi, and American cheese.
… more
B- Lieve
As someone originally from back east, I’m used to places like Regina; in North End, Boston; or Lombardi’s; on Spring St, NYC. This place can’t compare to those fore mentioned. However, Supreme does remind me of the taste back home; enough that I’ve gone eatin’ there three times already!
… more
Jen Ralston
This is the place on the Ave. Delicious huge slices and my favorite frozen booze, the Blue Hawaiian. The music is good, too!
… more
Plural Love
Went here for the happy hour but sadly they don’t have it anymore. Still a great deal they sell pizza by the slice. They have great selection of new york style pizza and also deep dish and a variety of bread and salad. Cocktails are ok, I like sweet but strong cocktails. Shots are good.
… more
… View more