New York-style pizzas with offbeat toppings & cocktails in a kitschy, 21+ pizza parlor setting. Based on 407 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4521 California Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98116
Hours
| Thursday | 3 PM–1 AM |
| Friday | 3 PM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 3 PM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 3 PM–1 AM |
| Monday | 3 PM–1 AM |
| Tuesday | 3 PM–1 AM |
| Wednesday | 3 PM–1 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Misha Smith
We had a friend come into town from California & said this is his favorite pizza place. We had never been so we thought we would try it out! The pepperoni pizza was delicious but a lil spicy for myself but still delicious. The potato pizza was surely a surprise, it had arugula & white sauce & these pies are huge with those big bubbles from the crust!! The staff is nice & we got a seat right away granted it was a Sunday but it was nice weather out so there were plenty of people in west seattle at the time too.
… more
Ovidio Escolero
Bartender (Girl with glasses) didn’t wanna serve me pizza tonight because she thought I stole her phone LAST WEEK when I haven’t been there in 2 months. I’ve been living in west Seattle for awhile and never felt so disrespected here. Will never be going supreme again.
… more
Justin Anderson
Cool bar serving not so traditional pizza with other bar food bites and pizza accompaniments. They have a pretty solid happy hour selection for beer a pizza. We went with the non-traditional “Ono” based on a review I read, but was not a big fan. Definitely liked the sauce and bread aspect of the pizza and would like to try some more of their traditional pies. The scallion garlic knots were bomb and a good table share. The wings were okay and kind of small. The place is cool and a great hang out with plenty of games and TVs for sports, though located inconveniently far from Seattle. Would be back if I’m in the area, but not sure I would go out of my way from Seattle.
… more
Jacob Henry
If you come in here looking for a slice of pepperoni pizza, quit wasting your time and go somewhere else. They’re guaranteed to have a nasty, 8-hour-old, untouched, vegetable pizza every time, but they refuse to anticipate the demand for pepperoni. They’re sold out 90% of the time if you’re in after 10.
… more
Lindsay Bowen
This place is great. We did visit on at an off time mid afternoon on the weekend so didn’t experience a busy time, but the staff is wonderful, pies are great and beverage selection is on point. We found our new favorite spot in West Seattle.
… more
Miche
We’d been ordering Supreme regularly after moving into the delivery zone and the pizza was fine. Most recently we received the wrong delivery order. There was no phone number available online so I immediately emailed via the contact info on the website. After no response for several days I tried multiple alternatives (tried an IG DM, found a phone number on Yelp that got me through to a person who told me the email address on the website was wrong, emailed the “correct” address I was given over the phone). I tried. I was always polite. I never received a response. At some point I was refunded for the base pizza price (still paid the delivery fee and tip which was fine, happy to pay the tip) but was never contacted in any way. The experience was so frustrating that I will not order again. If you have similar trouble you might just dispute through your credit card because there is clearly no inkling of accountability to you, the patron, from this establishment.
… more
Jaewook J
Thank you! We tried out you guys last night, for a take-out order and got half Double Cheese and half Hawaiian pizza. Your dough truly rocked, the crust was chewy in the end, and the bottom tasted smoky which was perfect.
… more
Joshua Fulks
This place is fatty juicy for real. Great beer, great pizza, great staff. 11/11 recommend (yes, my scale goes up to 11). Maybe if you start coming here regularly you can get on my level.
… more
Jose Chavez
Stopped in for a quick slice. Ordered a pepperoni slice; was not NY style but was tasty. It just took a long time to get a slice, had to wait around 10 min. It’s more of a bar with pizza option.
… more
Ashley Black
Excellent drinks, good size on the pizza slices, and very very tasty. And the staff are badasses. Highly recommended.
… more
… View more