Supreme Buffet & Hibachi Menu – Columbus, OH

Type : Buffet restaurant

Location : Columbus, OH

Utilitarian Chinese & Japanese buffet restaurant showcasing sushi, hibachi grub & other items. Based on 3 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Supreme Buffet & Hibachi 43228

Address:
1323 W St James Lutheran Ln, Columbus, OH 43228

Phone: (614) 870-8888

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 10:30 AM–10 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM–10 PM
Friday 10:30 AM–10 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM–10 PM
Sunday 10:30 AM–10 PM
Monday 10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Tuesday Closed

Menu

Hibachi Entree
Hibachi Chicken $8.95
Hibachi Shrimp $9.95
Hibachi Steak $9.95
Hibachi Chicken & Shrimp $10.95
Hibachi Chicken & Steak $10.95
Hibachi Steak & Shrimp $10.95
Hibachi Chicken + Steak + Shrimp $11.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

D J
Went here for the buffet and hot and sour soup, both to-go. I travel a lot for work and try to hit up Chinese buffet places because I get a lot of food for the money, and one meal lasts me at least a couple days, sometimes three. I got the pictured container of food and soup for $17. No rice, as I get instant rice and make it myself. Rice just adds unnecessary weight. Food was hot, smelled good, tasted good, staff was friendly, and things looked clean. Will visit again. I got a little of everything off the buffet, and it was all good. I’m not a very picky eater tho.

… more

Sam Rus
YUM! I’m not sure why this place gets a bad wrap?! But it’s very well priced and has fresh hot food with plenty of options. There’s an amazing sushi, fruit, and desert bar, fried rice and traditional hibachi choices as well as American options. On top of an unbeatable price for the food, the service was great, quick and easy. I recommend this place 100% if you want a quick and filling meal!

… more

Savannah
Plenty of variety and most dishes were delicious! Some things were hit or miss. Some meats were overcooked, Mashed Potatoes tasted instant and cookies were still in the package they were bought in. The baked crab meat was delicious and the sushi and seafood selection was great! The table and floors were sticky, even the door at the entrance. The place could use a good thorough cleaning. The service was good, refills and clean up was prompt. I don’t believe the hibachi was open so that would of been disappointing if you came for that reason but didn’t bother us. Overall would come back here in the future.

… more

Daren Sanchez
The food was okay a lot of variety to pick from. Everything was fine until the waiter tried to give us the bill and we were not even done with our 2nd plate. We sat down at our tables at 6:35 pm and not even 30 minutes went by, she came to our table and basically said get out. Terrible service never again would we waste our time going to this particular buffet. We are a big a fan of buffets but this one was the worst experience. She even charged us for 2 teas when it was only 1.

… more

chadwick bowling
Well worth the money. Went in a little skeptical cause of the reviews about sticky floors and food that taste like cleaner. Were are fans of a buffet every now and then though. This place did not let us down. When we pulled up they were having the bulbs changed in the sign. Which is a good sign that we might be onto something good since they take care of they’re sign. Seen so many places that could care less they have bulbs out on there signs. Get in the door and here is this oversized buffet area full of food. Good sign #2 no sticky floors and everything was clean and tidy. Good sign #3. Now the taste test. Didn’t have one thing off the buffet that taste like cleaner. It was all very good. They had Italian shrimp that was just absolutely delicious. Alot of typical Asian buffet food but also a few American food items. All the staff were pleasant as well. Were from Dayton so not sure when we will get this way again..but I can assure you if were hungry and in the mood for a buffet this is where we’re coming

… more

Doug Thrush
This place used to be great, not so much anymore. We have given them 3 chances in the past year hoping it was just an off visit. This was the last time we will be going back. The atmosphere is that of wild animals fending for themselves at a hog trough. Children are running around coughing on the food and putting their fingers in the food. The meats are rubbery and if they have any kind of breading, they are mushy. Sushi is warm and looks like it’s been sitting out for long periods of time. Pure and simply put this food is slop and completely overpriced for the quality. I had hopes that the hibachi would be the redeeming aspect. I made my plate and handed it over for it to all be put on the grill, including the egg, at the same time. Most places wait towards the end to add the egg so it doesn’t overcook. Then it all sat there unmoved for about 8 minutes. The cook walked away to make other items for the buffet. The noodles were crisp and charred, the steak had turned into beef jerky it was so over cooked, and the eggs were dry and burned. This place is gross, the food is gross, and someone is going to get sick eating here. Stay far away!

… more

Char Jax
Our first visit. We had an early dinner (05/14/2023), we were seated quickly, our drink orders were taken very quickly. The server was very attentive and gave room/time to enjoy our meal. The food was excellent! I had the honey chicken, potatoes, green beans & salmon. Dessert I had jello, pineapples & watermelon. We ended up spending 2 hours!! We had a wonderful experience!

… more

Evan Vana
My sibling’s favorite go-to for lunch now. With an all-you-can eat hot buffet and lots of options, you can’t go wrong. They love the seafood bake and the stuffed mushrooms, while I’m personally a fan of the honey chicken and the sauteed green beans. It’s a tad bit cheaper. has a tad more selection, and is a tad bit closer than our old buffet, too.

… more

Bonnie Lorraine
We love going here! But the food the most recent time we went was not great. I get they were super busy so maybe that’s it, but how is broccoli going to be mush and hard in the same dish? I was worried about some dishes as they were cold to the touch. Not sure. Other times we’ve been so happy and satisfied.

… more

Kyle Beecher
I should of came a bit earlier so I could of had more salmon nigiri! Pretty spot on food.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions