Supreme Pizza lives up to it’s name offering exceptional tasting pizza with great customer service to match. The restaurant is contemporary and clean with convenient parking in the area. Customers appreciate the portion sizes and praise menu items such as the sub sandwiches and the fries. Dine-in or order online for takeout/delivery.
Based on 136 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
67C Main St, Medway, MA 02053
Phone: (508) 533-7723
Website: https://www.supremepizzeriamedway.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Becca Tomlin
Standard pizza place. While they are consistent it is consistently not what is ordered and it’s frustrating. This is the fourth sub I’ve ordered toasted and the bun couldn’t be softer if it tried. As you can see, toasted was ordered and noted by the person taking the order however it doesn’t seem to quite reach the kitchen.
… more
J Muller
If greek style is your type of pizza, this place is good. A bit greasy, but it’s what you’d expect . Very traditional pizza place menu. Subs are good, nothing fancy. Quick service. Mostly pleasant.
… more
Tracy Jansen
This is our go to takeout food when we are short on time on school nights!
… more
Brandon H
D lish. Southern sub on a wheat wrap was huge, bbq chicken with hint of smoke flavor was totally different than any cheap bbq anywhere. Bacon really set it off. Im a big eater and it filled my belly. Small O rings were sized well too.
… more
jocelyn mahoney
Great food and friendly staff! I brought a dog training class for outdoor seating pizza party and they were fantastic
… more
Jenna Freeman
awful, awful, awful. i usually always loved supreme and the service was wonderful. a few weeks back i received my chicken fingers and fries and i got extremely sick. i was throwing up that evening for an hour or two. the food seemed to be raw because the cooks did not take their time and it was uncooked. i was very displeased and upset. it looked pink at the bottom when i saw the remnants.. not satisfied with this place anymore and i will not order anymore because i always gave good service to this place. it seems to be just the food besides the pizza. the pizza is pretty much satisfactory but i am nervous to eat whenever we get pizza from you guys and i have heard from others that you guys give food poisoning. i am not pleased. never thought i would get sick from supreme.
… more
Chris Wickson
Best subs around. Great mozzarella sticks. Will try more but what I have purchased has been excellent. Not a fan of the service fee though on top of tip if you order online
… more
Tara Johnson
First time eating from Supreme Pizza. Omg! My chicken kabob dinner was bomb. Chicken cooked perfectly and spice and flavor was on point. Probably best chicken kabobs I’ve ever had. And portion is enough for 2 meals.
… more
Albert Small
Outstanding customer service. Awesome food. Definitely recommend
… more
Rebecca Brent
I got a slice of pizza and the buffalo chicken fingers. The pizza crust was nice and thin and light. The real winner was the buffalo chicken fingers though. I had them 3 weeks ago and I still think about them sometimes. They were nice and thin, super saucy, and the breading was crunchy and not crazy heavy like some chicken fingers I have had. 10/10 will eat here again…probably soon too because I need more of those chicken fingers in my life.
… more
… View more