Based on 64 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
203 S Sandusky Ave, Upper Sandusky, OH 43351
Phone: (419) 294-3555
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Susies-Pizza-175313061446/
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jaclyn Mack
Best pizza in upper Sandusky!! You get what you pay for here, they don’t skimp on your toppings!! There subs are delicious!! Everything is cooked to perfection!! I only wish they would deliver to kirby because then they would be the only pizza I would ever order!!
… more
Robert Meyers
Their Sandwiches were Fantastic!!! Very accommodating and personable. CASH ONLY!
… more
Ronald Lewandowski
I ordered two days in a row from Susie’s. I’m an over-the-road truck driver stayed at the pilot and I had pizza last night was the best pizza I could have ever eaten. It was a turning. Sorry. I couldn’t finish it. The delivery person has been very nice. And the first night. I had boneless chicken wings, which were excellent had a little bit too much barbecue sauce, but they’re still good and I had garlic sticks or something, whatever great. Wish I had a place like that around me in, Florida.
… more
Alice Vent
I’ve been eating Susie’s Pizza practically since birth, and after trying pizza all around Ohio, the states, and internationally, it is still my favorite. The signature sweet sauce is unlike any you get from a big bran, and quite frankly it’s my favorite part. The pizza is cut into small squares which makes it easy to eat without making much of a mess, but I mean, it’s pizza, so it’s still going to be greasy and saucy. The crust is thin, as others have stated, but that suits the squares better than a pan pizza ever could, and you never have to worry about a mouth full of bread. When you order something on the pizza, they do not go chintzy on it. You get well what you pay for, in my opinion. Of course, I am very biased (I was literally raised on this pizza), but it will forever be my favorite.
… more
Chris Raby
WORST PIZZA EVER!!! Sause tasted like sugared spaghetti sause, crust was like cardboard & hamburger was like crumbled cat food!!! A quarter of a star because vegetables were eatable. All 7 members of the family tonight agreed that pb&j sandwiches were a better supper substitute tonight!! Never ordering from here again, don’t know how they stayed open since 1959!
… more
Rebecca Rader
Servers and delivery driver were nice. But food was delivered 20 minutes late and they’re food is poor quality. Sauce tastes like chef boyardee, yuck!
… more
Darcey Johnson
Amazing pizza, great staff, first time was driving through
… more
Rocky Davis
Moving to Upper Sandusky I like looking for good pizza Susie’s is the best that I had in a long time the other places are not that good. I never had a bad pizza yet. I will be ordering from Susie’ for along time.
… more
Dane Jones
Pizza is amazing! I missed it when I moved to Marion but occasionally make drive JUST for this pizza!
… more
Sarah Sherman
Pizza is awesome. They need to get a credit card machine.
… more
… View more