Sweet Tomato Menu – Oyster Bay, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Oyster Bay, NY

Quaint New American cafe serving breakfast, sandwiches, salads & more amid a display of student art. Based on 162 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Sweet Tomato 11771

Address:
91 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

Phone: (516) 802-5353

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 8:30 AM–5:30 PM
Wednesday 8:30 AM–5:30 PM
Thursday 8:30 AM–5:30 PM
Friday 8:30 AM–5:30 PM
Saturday 8:30 AM–5:30 PM
Sunday 8 AM–4:30 PM
Monday 8:30 AM–5:30 PM

Menu

BREAKFAST Til 1130
Ranchero
Two scrambled eggs with tomato, mushrooms, onion, choice of bacon, ham or sausage on a wrap (jalapeños optional)		 $8.95
PANCAKES
Buttermilk Pancakes with Maple Syrup and choice of toppings		 $7.95
French Toast
Three slices French Toast with butter and Maple Syrup		 $9.95
HungryMan/Woman
Scrambled Eggs with American Cheese and choice of two meats (Bacon, Ham or Sausage) on a wrap		 $8.95
The Waterfront
Two eggs your way with choice of bacon, ham or sausage and two buttermilk pancakes		 $10.99
Santa Maria Burrito
Two eggs, bacon, rice & beans with cheese on a wrap		 $10.95
Omelettes
Three Egg Omelet served with Homefries & Toast		 $11.45
Oatmeal-Loaded $6.75
Egg Whites With Turkey & American $5.99
Breakfast Quesadilla
Quesadilla with scrambled eggs, sausage, scallions, cheddar-Jack cheese and Pico de Gallo		 $10.95
Power Bowl
Protein infused Quinoa, Crumbled Bacon, Roasted Portabello Mushrooms, Tomato, Spinach, Parmesan and Extra Virgin Olive Oil with choice of Cage-Free Egg or Grilled Chicken on Top		 $10.95
Champion Wrap
Three egg whites, steamed vegetables, chopped chicken, homefries and Jalapeños on a wrap		 $9.95
Bagel – Plain $2.00
Bagel With Butter
Fresh, locally baked bagel with butter		 $2.75
Bagel With Cream Cheese
Fresh, locally baked Bagel with cream cheese		 $3.50
Avocado Toast
Smashed Avocado, hard Boiled Eggs and Scallions on Rye or Sourdough Toast		 $9.95
Bacon Egg & Cheese
Double Egg Sandwich with choice of Bacon, Ham or Sausage and American Cheese on a Kaiser Roll		 $6.49
Buttered Roll
Kaiser Roll with Farm Fresh Butter		 $2.75
SOUPS
Chicken Noodle
Homemade chicken-vegetable noodle soup		 $0.00
Broccoli Cheddar
Creamy Homemade Broccoli Cheddar		 $0.00
Sweet Tomato Bisque $0.00
Caribbean Red Lentil
Homemade red lentil soup (Vegan delight)		 $0.00
Italian Wedding
Homemade Italian Wedding Soup		 $0.00
Hungarian Mushroom $0.00
Split Pea $0.00
Lobster Bisque $0.00
Turkey Chili
Domingo’s very meaty homemade turkey chili		 $0.00
New England Clam Chowder $0.00
Thai Pumpkin $0.00
Manhattan Clam Chowder $0.00
Golden Split Pea $0.00
Vegetable Quinoa
Homemade Vegetable soup with quinoa		 $0.00
Portabello Brie $0.00
Corn Chowder $0.00
Chicken Spinach & Tortellini $0.00
Carrot Ginger $0.00
Gazpacho $0.00
Potato Scallion $0.00
French Onion $0.00
Spinach & Stars $0.00
Minestrone $0.00
Spinach & Tortellini In Broth $0.00
Chipotle Black Bean With…Group 2 $0.00
Pablano Chicken Stew $0.00
White Chicken Chili $0.00
Moroccan Lentil Stew $0.00
White Bean Kale $0.00
Brown Lentil $0.00
Mushroom Chicken Spinach $0.00
HOT BOWLS
Turkey Chili Rice Bowl
Turkey Chili over Brown Rice with Shredded Jack-Cheddar Cheese, sour cream (Jalapeños optional)		 $12.04
Mykonos Bowl
Gyro Meat over chopped Lettuce & Tomato over Brown Rice with Tzatziki Sauce		 $11.45
Rainbow Bowl
Chicken, Corn, Tomato, Cucumber & Organic Chipotle dressing over brown Rice		 $12.20
Greek Bowl $12.20
Brown Rice Bowl W Chicken $11.99
Brown Rice Bowl
Black Beans, Caramelized Onions, Fresh Pico and Shredded Jack Cheddar Cheese over Brown Rice		 $11.99
Brown Rice Bowl W Veggies & Chicken
Brown rice with Black Beans, Caramelized Onions, Fresh Pico de Gallo & Shredded Cheese (optional Veggies or chicken)		 $12.99
PANINI
Rosemary Focaccia
Honey Grilled Chicken with melted Brie and sliced Tomato		 $12.70
Tuscan Focaccia
Grilled Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, sauteéd Portabello Mushrooms & Onions and Roasted Red Peppers		 $12.70
Veggie Panini $12.70
Sicilian Panini
Marinated Grilled Chicken, thin sliced Prosciutto, Provolone Cheese & Sliced Tomato with Sun-dried Tomato Pesto		 $12.70
Frost Hall Panini
Sliced Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella & Basil pesto		 $12.70
Hammerhead Panini
Thin Sliced Turkey, with melted Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil Pesto		 $12.70
Blue Panini
Grilled Chicken, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Caramelized Onions & Dijon		 $12.70
Bombay $12.45
Meat/Cheese $9.25
WRAPS
Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Garlic Croutons & Caesar Dressing		 $11.50
Oyster Bay Wrap $11.50
The Port Wrap
Marinated, Grilled Portabello Mushroom, Tomato, Roasted peppers, Sauteéd Onions & Mozzarella with Mixed Greens, Drizzled with Balsamic Vinaigrette		 $11.50
CALI $11.50
CAJUN RANCH WRAP $11.50
Roosevelt Wrap/Salad $11.50
Waldorf Wrap
Cubed Chicken, Tossed with Toasted Walnuts, Granny Smith Apple, Celery, Red Grapes & Mayo		 $12.70
Greek Wrap $12.20
Turkey Brie Wrap
Turkey Breast with Brie Cheese, Bartlett Pears, Mixed Greens & Dijon		 $12.20
Vodka Wrap $11.50
Grilled Veggie Wrap $11.50
Turkey Club
Sliced Turkey Breast, Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato with Mayo		 $11.50
Turkey Muenster Wrap
Sliced Turkey, Muenster Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Honey Mustard		 $11.50
Tuna Club
Tuna Salad, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Swiss Cheese with Mayo		 $11.50
Veggie Hummus
Marinated, Grilled Vegetables, with Garlic Hummus		 $12.20
Grilled Chicken Fajita $11.70
Extra Veggies $1.75
Chicken Salad Wrap $12.20
Chesapeake Crabcake $13.70
BLT $8.50
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $11.70
Meat/Cheese $9.25
Wrap Combo
Soup Half Wrap Combo Group 1
1/2 any wrap from our menu and one 12-oz soup from our Group 1 soups		 $12.49
Soup Half Wrap Combo Group 2
1/2 Wrap from our Wrap Selections and one 12-oz Group 2 Soup		 $12.99
Soup Next Size $1.00
SALADS
Portabella Salad $11.70
Mandarin Salad $12.70
Valley Salad $12.00
Greek Salad $11.70
Cove Salad $12.70
Ensalata Balsamica $10.70
Cobb Salad $11.70
Waldorf Salad $12.70
Caesar Salad $10.70
Fajita Salad $12.70
Health Salad $12.70
Lobster Salad $13.70
Garden Salad $10.70
Avocado Toast
Smashed Avocado, hard Boiled Eggs and Scallions on Rye or Sourdough Toast		 $9.95
Chicken For Salad $5.25
Chopped $1.00
Tuna For Salad $3.75
Extra Dressing $0.75
GOURMET
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $11.70
Chesapeake Crabcake $13.70
Lobster Roll $12.95
Quesadilla $11.20
Grilled Cheese Classic $9.95
Fish Sandwich $11.95
Roosevelt Wrap/Salad $11.50
Waldorf Wrap
Cubed Chicken, Tossed with Toasted Walnuts, Granny Smith Apple, Celery, Red Grapes & Mayo		 $12.70
Greek Wrap $12.20
Turkey Brie Wrap
Turkey Breast with Brie Cheese, Bartlett Pears, Mixed Greens & Dijon		 $12.20
Veggie Hummus
Marinated, Grilled Vegetables, with Garlic Hummus		 $12.20
Baltz $11.70
TACOS
Fish Taco $10.45
Lobster Salad Taco $11.45
SMOOTHIES
Smoothie 16oz $7.99
Smoothie 24oz $9.99
Smoothie 36oz $11.79
Smoothie
Blended to order with fresh ingredients		 $7.99
CANDY & PROTEIN BARS & NUTS
Nutella $2.75
COOKIES & CAKES
Cookies , Individual 3pk Homemade $3.00
Cookies – Black And White Or Linzer $3.00
Bagel – Plain $2.00
Bagel With Butter
Fresh, locally baked bagel with butter		 $2.75
Bagel With Cream Cheese
Fresh, locally baked Bagel with cream cheese		 $3.50
GLUTEN FREE
Gluten Free French Toast $9.50
Gluten Free Omelettes $9.50
Avocado Toast
Smashed Avocado, hard Boiled Eggs and Scallions on Rye or Sourdough Toast		 $9.95
JUST KIDS
Kids Turkey & Lettuce White Or Ww Bread Only $6.99
Kids Grilled Cheese White Or Ww Bread Only $6.99
Kids PB&J White Or Ww Bread Only $6.99
Penne With Vodka Sauce $6.99
MUFFINS & BAGELS & CROISSANT
Bagel – Plain $2.00
Gourmet Muffins
Fresh baked muffins		 $3.00
Extra Cream Cheese $2.25
Toast
Toast SIDE $2.50
BEVERAGES All
ICED COFFEE Or TEA
Fresh Brewed Iced Coffee or Tea		 $0.00
Tea Hot 12 Oz $2.00
Coffee Hot 16 Oz
Fresh Brewed Hot Coffee medium size		 $2.75
Hal’s Seltzer
20-oz bottle Hal’s Seltzer		 $2.00
COKE, Diet Coke, Ginger Ale CAN
12-oz Can Soda Coke, Diet Coke, Gingerale		 $2.00
COFFEE Hot 12 Oz
Fresh Brewed Hot coffee		 $2.25
Tea -Hot 16oz $2.50
Poland Spring Half Litre
16.9oz bottle Poland Spring Water		 $1.75
Poland Spring Sport
Poland Spring 700ml Sport Bottle		 $2.50
4 Jacks Nitro $5.50
Coconut Water $2.99
Specials
Miami $11.45
Fish Taco $10.45
Mex Lob Taco $12.45
Fish Sandwich $11.95
Avocado Toast
Smashed Avocado, hard Boiled Eggs and Scallions on Rye or Sourdough Toast		 $9.95
Chicken Salad Wrap $12.20
Bagel – Plain $2.00
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $11.70
Chesapeake Crabcake $13.70
Bombay $12.45
Sweet Grilled Cheese $9.95
UNCATEGORIZED
Gluten Free Wrap $1.40
Veggies For Salad $3.50
Core Water $2.75
Nachos $10.95
Milano $1.50
Fig Grilled Cheese $9.95
Coastal Kombucha $4.99
Nonnis $2.50
Breakfast Special $6.49
Lettuce Wrap $1.00
Grilled Chicken $4.00
Buffalo Wrap $10.45
Buffalo Panini $10.95
Arizona Cold Brews $2.75
Arizona Fruit Snacks Large $2.50
Lemon Perfect $2.50
Hot Chocolate $2.50
Kid’s Pasta With Butter/Vodka $6.99
Planters Nutrition $2.00
Kombucha $4.95
Montauk Tea $2.50
Gluten Free Toast 2 Pcs $3.00
Chicken Piece $5.00
Homefries $4.00
Toast Extra $1.75
The Cajun Ranch Wrap Group 1 $8.59
The Cali Wrap Group 2 $11.59
Group 2 Soup $1.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Serenity Hart
Rosemary Panini + Hungarian Mushroom soup for the win! I love stopping here on the way to Roosevelt Beach. I haven’t tried many options on the menu because my regular is bomb every time but I encourage you to explore. Great quality, just enough food for lunch and outdoor seating. Also, dying for Costal Craft to come back. We love a good local kombucha.

… more

In Wonder
Amazing soup and some yummy paninis. My favorite thing on a cold day in Oyster Bay. The seating area is small so I suggest plan to get your stuff to go. Also be patient waiting for your food it takes a bit to prepare but the wait is worth it

… more

Bruce W
I ordered The Vodka wrap for me and the Chicken Caesar wrap for my wife. The Vodka was well made the pasta in the wrap was cooked just right, however, it was very flavorful. My wife’s wrap was missing the croutons.

… more

Danielle Elsener
Sweet Tomato has become one of my go-to lunch spots in Oyster Bay! Their soups and salads are fresh, quick, and on point. It’s a great local spot.

… more

Judie Thompson
While visiting friends, went to Sweet Tomato for lunch. Disappointed was not waitress/waiter service. Food quality was on point. So many soups to choose from, a little something everyone.

… more

Matthew Frisch
I got food poisoning. I ate a pannini with mozzarella, tomato and pesto yesterday for lunch. I believe the pesto was bad. Terrible night last night and still sick today.

… more

Isadora Costa Cardoso
Waited 40 minutes for a sandwich. They were extremely short staffed and not very nice to customers waiting.

… more

Kelley Smith
This place was SO good. Line at first went a little slow, but the wait was worth it. I had the tuna club which they were able to make as a panini instead. I also had a side of tomato bisque soup. Both were so good, I went back the next day for the same thing!!! The rosemary ficcotia bread that they make it on is out of this world. You have to go here!!!

… more

A
I placed a catering order with Sweet Tomato for a ladies’ luncheon at the end of January 2023.

… more

Sue Pitchford
We are boaters visiting Oyster Bay from Annapolis staying on a mooring. The owner came outside to greet us suggesting we could sit outside if we prefer and they would bring the food to us. We decided to sit inside and we had great breakfast wraps. We chatted with the owner and told him we were in the mooring field. We were walking back to the boat when a car came up behind us and starting honking. The owner jumped out of his car waving at us. We had dropped some cash out of a pocket and he was racing to return it to us before we got to the launch to our boat. Now, that’s customer service!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch