The Tally-Ho Restaurant in Tinton Falls, New Jersey, is commonly referred to as the “hidden gem” along Route 33. We are locally owned and operated and have been proudly serving our community since we opened our doors in 1995. Our menu features a contemporary blend of American cuisine with a strong Northern Italian influence. Our dinner menu features enticing appetizers and succulent entrees that range from fresh seafood, to hand-crafted pasta dishes, to deliciously prepared meats. Our lunch menu features pasta, hearty soups, hand-crafted sandwiches, and signature salads. We are open seven days a week, including many major holidays. We also offer catering and private event services.
Enduring local spot features American comfort eats & Italian classics in spacious, comfy surrounds. Based on 309 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4118 NJ-33, Tinton Falls, NJ 07753
Phone: (732) 918-0900
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Steve X
My wife and I had dinner here at 7 pm on a Monday night during the first half of July 2023. The place was pretty empty. That was good because there’s not a lot of parking spots, and no nearby stores to park in. We later learned from our server that on weekends people often have to park on the grass.
… more
Paul Griffin
The flounder almondine over risotto was excellent. Beer on tap and cocktails first rate. Server was very friendly and efficient. I liked this place. Haven’t been here since before the pandemic but I’m glad I went back.
… more
Chris W.
Tally-Ho is a local Italian fine dining restaurant that is popular with local retirees. It’s a bit cliquish. No hostess to greet me. No welcoming orientation. Just a bunch of servers bustling around. The food actually is pretty good, but I expected better service for the price. This is not a very tourist friendly restaurant. It clearly caters more to the local crowd and that’s OK. I will skip this restaurant next time I’m traveling through New Jersey. Also, the dining area is relatively small and there is limited parking.
… more
Jrockbaby 21f2
Sat down to eat. Waited 10 mins before we were talked to. We’re giving the wrong menus. When we finally got our drinks and the right menus, the glasses were covered in crud. The prices were crazy high. We ultimately left without getting our entrees. Would not recommend.
… more
Steven Weston
Impressive range of choices of traditional Italian entrees. Food quality and service were acceptable and modest, as were the prices. Not much atmosphere here.
… more
Cindy Quan
Wow wow wow! The food is absolutely amazing. Come with a huge appetite. Definitely get the escargot with garlic bread and get an extra side bread to dip. Chicken and sausage Murphy with cherry peppers was phenomenal and enough for three people. Can’t go wrong with anything you order. A hidden gem on 33 for sure!
… more
Brett
Had dinner with my wife and son. The french onion soup was extremely salty. Not edible. The chicken and sausage scarpariello was very strange and not what I am accustomed to with this meal. It came with a very oily balsamic sauce. My wife asked the hot sausages but they weren’t hot at all. Maybe they put the wrong sausages. The chicken was extremely dry. Not good. My wife basically left the whole dish. They offered to box it to take home but we didn’t want it. The stuffed sole was edible but not great. The stuffing was supposed to crab and shrimp but it was mostly breadcrumbs. The stuffing was the largest portion of the plate.
… more
MichelePearl
We loved our experience at this place. Food was off the chain. We had the chicken Parm which was excellent and I had the filet mignon. I have nothing to complain about until we hit the restrooms. First of all they need a good cleaning with bleach and a thorough cleaning under the rim of the toilet bowl and the actual bowl, it was yellowed and really in need of some major soft scrub with bleach cleaning. Both bathrooms need a total overhaul as they are dated and worn out looking. And this is a real turn off. I was really shocked with the bathroom conditions and so was my boyfriend. It is a shame because we would have gone back there but this really put a damper on the experience which was otherwise stellar. also the prices were very reasonable and they included a lot with the food.
… more
Amanda
Mediocre food and horrible service – nothing about this place makes me want to return. Had a 6:30 reservation and when we arrived we were told there was no table available despite our reservation… might be 20 min wait. Finally seated at 6:55. Ordered appetizers and meals. Appetizers took almost 45 mins to come out. Never got our dinner until 8:45… TWO HOURS AFTER ORDERING. Our server couldn’t care less. Drinks were never refilled, and we had to ask multiple times before anything we needed was brought to us. Food was average at best. It was our first time here and I will not return.
… more
James Voss
Although short on service like many restaurants, the server was friendly, helpful and professional. The website menu is not up to date. Just went for the cheese steak that was listed on the online menu only to find that it is now a special. Nevertheless I lucked out and enjoyed the ample dish. There are other steak sandwiches on the menu as well as other dishes I will return to try. Although I was only there for lunch and dined in a booth, there is a nice bar area adjacent to the dining area. Will be returning.
… more
… View more