Based on 96 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
Address:
81 Croix St, Negaunee, MI 49866
Phone: (906) 242-3034
Website: https://www.teallakepizzeriamenu.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
brayden jedra
Gave them a 10$ tip to get a half cooked pizza with 3 pieces of pepperoni. Called and let them know the situation, they refuse to believe me, said we’ll get 10% off next time 🙂 great people.
… more
Sean Lawrence
A lovely little pizzeria right on the lake. While they are takeout only, there are some public park benches nearby with a great view. The pizza itself was a little less impressive. There are no vegetarian pizzas on the menu (including a lack of a plain cheese pizza), and making a veggie equivalent of the supreme costs more than the supreme with meat on it. Our veggie custom pizza had way too much cheese on it, and both pizzas were floppy with mostly soggy crusts. It was an average experience overall
… more
Christine B
Teal Lake Pizzeria was amazing. We got the fire station pizza. It was super filling and unique (in a good way). It was a flavor explosion. I wish we had a Teal Lake in Grand Rapids. YUM 10/10
… more
MTGUNVEILED
What a fantastic pizzeria! Teal Lake Pizzeria has the friendliest workers, and unbelievably delicious food!
… more
jrzyGrl75
Gourmet sandwiches are tasty, but they should offer some accompaniments in addition to just chips or slaw for the price you pay. Need to shore up order accuracy, having gotten two back-to-back orders wrong. Recommend, depending…..see below.
… more
Sara Johnson
I just moved to Ishpeming and drive past this place every day. Finally got around to trying it and it’s now one of my fav go-to spots. Their new chef is great and has a ton of delicious new menu additions. My fav are the bagel bites and jalapeño popper pizza. Everyone wants to know “HOW’S THE CRUST?” It’s fanfriggintastic. I’d describe it as a hand tossed crust. Good crispy bottom, but it has a nice chew to it. The folks that run it are kinda, friendly, and seem to really enjoy what they do. Support a great local business and satisfy your hunger.
… more
Jessica Juchemich
I gave it 4 stars instead, nice workers and corrected my sandwich but the reason for it not being 5 stars is because I got a banana smoothie and there was pineapple on top? I’m assuming because the right topping wasn’t available? Also forgot the chips but it wasn’t worth calling back about.
… more
Sarah Santiago
I’ve eaten here twice now and both times I’ve been extremely impressed! The Thai bites and the pesto bites are both wonderful! Their pizza dough has a hint of garlic in it and tastes really good! I don’t usually eat pizza crust but I do with their pizza because I enjoy the flavor of their crust! I appreciate the diverse menu choices offered for such a small town: vegan cheese, Thai pizza, chickpeas! Highly recommend!
… more
Daniel Morgan-Heredia
This place is great, always friendly staff. The food is always good. The only complaint i have is the wait time, but it really isn’t that bad at all. Really though, come here and try their menu. Especially the mac and cheese pizza creation (forgot name). And smoothies! Love me the smoothies
… more
Theresa Marie
First time will be my last time… after reading reviews I was sure this would be my new go to place for those nights I just don’t feel like cooking but unfortunately it won’t be so.
… more
… View more