The All Star Grill Menu – Riverhead, NY

Type : Bar & grill

Location : Riverhead, NY

Based on 139 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

The All Star Grill 11901

Address:
96 Main Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901

Phone: (631) 998-3565

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 12–11 PM
Wednesday 12–11 PM
Thursday 12–11 PM
Friday 12–11 PM
Saturday 10 AM–12 AM
Sunday 10 AM–10 PM
Monday 12–11 PM

Menu

Main Menu
All Star Nachos
Corn tortilla chips stacked high with topped with fresh pico de gallo, jalapenos, & sour cream, drizzled over with our house blended nacho cheese and Texas style chili.
$13.00
Angus Beef Sliders
(3) 3oz Angus sliders on a local baked brioche slider bun topped each with a different melted topping of mozzarella, pepper jack and American cheese. shredded lettuce and side of tangy smittys signature sauce.
$14.00
Baked Pretzel Rods
(3) rods of perfectly baked pretzel bread, lightly salted with sea salt and served with a side of our blended nacho cheese and house honey mustard.
$10.00
Crunchy Chicken Quesadilla
A tower of toasted tortilla wraps, melted shredded jack-cheddar cheese, topped with a sweet & tangy corn salsa and pulled BBQ chicken. Served with a side of fresh Mexican crema.
$13.00
Battered Mozzarella Sticks
Battered & fried sticks of melted mozzarella & crunchy deliciousness, served with a side of house made marinara.
$9.00
Mango Chicken Tacos
(3) pulled chicken, mango salsa, cilantro and shredded cheddar jack blended together on a soft tortilla wrap. topped with our fresh Mexican crema.
$12.00
Banana Pepper Crunch Rolls
(4) crunch rolls with banana peppers mixed in a four-cheese blend, chopped garlic and spices, wrapped in a crispy crunchy-shell and served with sweet chili sauce on the side.
$9.00
Cheese & Charcuterie Board
An assortment of thin sliced cured meats accompanied by Asiago, manchego and sharp cheddar cheeses. Toasted baguette slices & a variety of fruits and nuts served with a house made avocado ranch spread.
$16.00
Garlic Butter Bacon Knots
(6) house made knots brushed with garlic & herb butter, wrapped around applewood smoked bacon, baked and sprinkled with parmesan cheese with a side of house made marinara.
$8.00
On The Bone $11.00
Boneless $11.00
Fresco Chicken Salad
Crispy chicken on a bed of mixed greens, shaved carrots, red onions, red beets and corn. All tossed in a tangy southwest dressing.
$14.00
Smitty’s Waldorf Toss
Romaine lettuce tossed together with blue cheese crumbles and diced apples, sprinkled candy pecans topped with a rich champagne vinaigrette.
$13.00
Iceberg Wedge Dish
Chopped bacon, roasted almonds, red cabbage strips all on top of an iceberg wedge glazed with an avocado ranch vinaigrette.
$13.00
Southwest Chicken Salad
Chopped grilled chicken breast on a bed of romaine lettuce, tossed with house made pico de gallo, shredded monterey jack cheddar and creamy chimichurri sauce, sprinkled and served with crumbled tortilla chips.
$14.00
Long Island Duck
Sweet chili & BBQ sauce topped with oven roasted local pulled duck, shredded Asiago cheese, diced red onions, sliced apple & roasted almonds.
$16.00
Classic Pie
Freshly shredded mozzarella, house made sauce, sprinkled oregano on a hand tossed dough.
$13.00
Margherita
House made chunky “grandma” sauce on top of fresh sliced mozzarella cheese, chopped basil leaves, sea salt drizzled with basil-oil.
$14.00
Four Cheese
House made ricotta & thyme blend spread, topped with Asiago, shredded mozzarella and sprinkled parmesan.
$14.00
Buffalo Chicken
Grilled chopped chicken breast, tossed in buffalo sauce, fresh shredded mozzarella, sprinkled with blue cheese crumbles & scallions.
$15.00
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Fried crispy chicken, diced red onion, applewood smoked bacon, on top of melted shredded pepper jack cheddar cheese, drizzled with buttermilk ranch sauce.
$17.00
Pizzeria Style Pizza
Fresh shredded mozzarella cheese and house made pizza sauce.
$18.00
Bucket O’ Fries
Bucket full of crispy coated fries.
$9.00
Bucket O’ Onion Rings
Bucket full of battered large onion rings.
$11.00
Bucket O’ Sweet Potato Fries
Bucket full of crispy sweet potato fries.
$12.00
Bucket O’ Waffle Fries
Bucket full of deep fried waffle fries.
$11.00
Bucket O’ Mac & Cheese Bites
Bucket full of crispy battered bite-sized mac & cheese triangles.
$13.00
The Cuban
Bourbon BBQ pulled pork topped with fried pickles, glazed ham, melted manchego cheese in between a toasted sourdough bread with yellow mustard and a side of kettle chips.
$15.00
Prime Rib Baguette
7oz of roasted prime rib dripped in a garlic & rosemary au jus on a baked baguette topped with crispy onions, horse radish sauce spread and a side of waffle fries.
$18.00
The New Ruben
Sliced corn beef dipped in a garlic & rosemary au jus topped with a remoulade coleslaw, melted Swiss cheese on a toasted sourdough bread and a side of cripsy fries.
$14.00
Hand-Breaded Chicken BLT
Breaded chicken breast topped with shredded lettuce & tomato slices on a toasted sourdough bread with a mayo-aioli and a side of crispy fries.
$14.00
Signature Steak Handheld
Sliced sirloin steak marinated & topped with red peppers, crispy onions melted mozzarella cheese & sprinkled parmesan on a garlic-butter spread baguette with a side of onion rings.
$16.00
Battered Shrimp Po-Boy
Hand-battered jumbo shrimp, tossed in our house blend of spices on a toasted baguette, sliced tomato and remoulade coleslaw served with kettle chips.
$15.00
Lamb Chop Pilaf
Pan seared lamb chops rubbed in a blend of garlic, crushed red pepper and rosemary herb served pink or no pink, on a bed of rice and vegetable pilaf.
$25.00
American Style Fish & Chips
Beer-battered icelandic cod filets deep fried and rubbed with our blend of herbs and spices served with crispy kettle chips, coleslaw & tartar sauce.
$19.00
Baby Back Ribs
Baby back ribs tossed in our sweet and smoky dry rub, slow cooked and glazed over with a bourbon BBQ sauce on a bed of waffle fries.
$16.00
Firecracker Crab Cake
Fresh crab meat folded into a crispy 6oz cake seasoned with old bay®, chipotle peppers and a blend of our house seasoning topped on a bed of rice and vegetable pilaf.
$22.00
Flatiron Sirloin Skillet
10oz of grill-marked sirloin steak marinated & served with roasted fingerling potatoes and grilled zucchini, topped with our house steak sauce.
$23.00
1lb Prime Rib Dinner
One pound herb & butter rubbed prime rib, oven roasted and sliced think to order, served on a bed of sauteed broccoli & carrots, glazed over with gravy with a side of homemade mashed potatoes, served pink or no pink.
$27.00
All Star Burger
Angus beef grilled & topped with American cheese applewood smoked bacon, shredded lettuce and tomato, all on a fresh baked brioche bun & a side of waffle fries.
$14.00
Smitty’s Barnyard Burger
Angus beef grilled & topped with melted pepper jack cheese, shredded coleslaw, crispy onions, diced bacon and bourbon barbecue pulled pork, all on a fresh baked potato bun and a side of onion rings.
$17.00
Pizza Burger
Angus beef grilled & topped with red onion, fresh mozzarella and pepperoni slices, all on a fresh baked brioche bun brushed with our margherita pizza sauce and a side of crispy fries.
$15.00
Nofo Turkey Burger
8oz Turkey burger grilled & topped with local sauteed mushrooms, shredded lettuce, melted Swiss cheese, chipotle mayo, all on a fresh baked potato bun and a side of sweet potato fries.
Brunch Burger
Angus beef grilled on a toasted English muffin, served with crispy onions, pepper jack cheese and a fried egg on top with a side of onion rings.
$16.00
Campfire Burger
Angus beef grilled & topped with wood fired onions, shredded lettuce, applewood smoked bacon, melted cheddar cheese with our house made campfire sauce on a local baked brioche bun.
$14.00
Fruit & Pastry Skewers
Three skewers sequenced with strawberries, blueberries and apple slices in between soft fresh baked pound cake drizzled with dark & white chocolate.
$9.00
Death By Chocolate
Gluten free rich chocolate cake drizzled with melted chocolate and whipped cream.
$8.00
Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake
Layered peanut butter and cheesecake sprinkled with crumbled peanut butter cup and drizzled with cannoli cream.
$8.00
All Star Milkshakes
House made chocolate & vanilla milkshakes served with a dollop of whipped cream and a cherry on top.
$9.00
Drinks
Goose Island IPA
Budweiser
Bud Light
Shock Top Belgian White
Blue Point Toasted Lager
Greenport Other Side IPA
Long Ireland Celtic Ale
Stella Artois
Yuengling
Hofbräu München
Coors Light
Guinness
Delirium Tremens
Angry Orchard Hard Cider
Miller Lite
Montauk Wave Chaser IPA
Leinenkugel Harvest Patch Shandy
Blue Point Citrus IPA
Brooklyn Brown Ale
Radiant Pig Gangster Duck
Barrage Chocolate Peanut Butter Porter
21st Amendment Hell Or High Watermelon
Pumking
Hofbrau Oktoberfest
Michelob Ultra
Miller Lite
Budweiser
Bud Light
Coors Light
Corona Extra
Amstel Light
Ace Perry Hard Cider
Heineken
Heineken Light
Corona Light
Stiegl Radler
St Pauli Non-Alcoholic
Lagunitas Little Sumpin’ Sumpin’
Modelo Especial
Land Shark Lager
Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA
Smitty’s Rum Punch
Bacardi mango, captain morgan, grenadine, pineapple, oj, meyers float.
$10.00
Bourbon Bacon Mary
Redemption bourbon, bacon, bloody mary mix, bacon salt, celery.
$10.00
The Bulleit Manhattan
Absolut, bacardi, tanqueray, 1800, triple sec, sour mix, shaken & topped with Pepsi.
$10.00
Patron Margarita
Roca patron, cointreau, grand marnier, fresh lime, simple syrup, sour.
$10.00
Spiked Berry Lemonade
Titos, lemonade, raspberry & strawberry purée, blue Curacao.
$10.00
Cucumber Martini
Crop organic cucumber, st. Germaine, lemon juice, muddled cucumber.
$10.00
The All Star Strike
Absolut citron, amaretto, midori, cranberry, lime juice, simple syrup.
$10.00
Today’s Old Fashion
Makers mark bourbon, cherry, orange, bitters, simple syrup, water.
$10.00
Grand Slam Lit
Absolut citron, amaretto, midori, cranberry, lime juice, simple syrup.
$10.00
White Chocolate Martini
Stoli vanilla, godiva white chocolate liqueur, crème de cocoa, cream.
$10.00
House Made Sangria
Red berry | peach | watermelon.
$10.00
Shark Attack $20.00
The Mike Wazowski $20.00
Tropical Punch $20.00
El Toro $25.00
Canyon Road Cabernet Sauvignon (California) $6.00
Canyon Road Merlot (California) $6.00
Colores Del Sol Malbec (Argentina) $8.00
Mark West Pinot Noir (California) $8.00
Da Vinci (Italy) $30.00
Robert Mondavi Cabernet Sauvignon (California) $30.00
Macari Merlot (Long Island) $30.00
Canyon Road Chardonnay (California) $6.00
Canyon Road Pinot Grigio (California) $6.00
Canyon Road White Zinfandel $6.00
Kono Sauvignon Blanc (New Zealand) $8.00
Relax Riesling (Germany) $8.00
Malgra Moscato (Italy) $8.00
Macari Early Wine Chardonnay (Long Island) $8.00
Macari Rose (Long Island) $30.00
Cupcake Pinot Grigio (Italy) $30.00
Callie Collection Chardonnay (California) $30.00
Happy Hour
Vodka Cranberry
Tequila Sunrise
Gin & Tonic
Cosmo
Sangrias
Long Island Iced Tea
Margarita
Whiskey Sour
Rum & Coke
Bay Breeze
Parties
Chips & Dips
Tortillas with Guacamole & Salsa
All Star Salad
Caesar Salad
Penne A La Vodka
Pasta Primavera
Penne Marzano
Basil & Fresh Mozzarella
Bowtie Pasta
with Broccoli & Oil
Macaroni & Cheese Bites
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Teriyaki Skewers
Chicken Wings
Bruschetta Toasts
Bakes Pretzels
Boneless Wings
Fried Garlic Bacon Knots
Chicken Empanadas
Cookies & Brownies
Includes Soda, Coffee, & Tea
Open Beer & Wine $20.00
Open Non-Premium $25.00
Open Premium $30.00
Primavera Pasta
penne pasta with seasonal vegetables
Bow Tie
w/broccoli, garlic and oil
Penne W/ San Marzano Tomato Sauce
basil & fresh mozzarella
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Chorizo Chicken Paella
Chicken Parmesan
Pulled Pork
Coleslaw
Chicken Francese
Sausage & Peppers
Flat Iron Steak
House BBQ Sauce
Chicken Marsala
Spiral Ham
Infused Pineapple
House Mashed Potatoes
Roasted Fingerling Potatoes
Toasted Garlic & Rosemary
Green Beans & Toasted Almonds
Mustard Vinaigrette
Seasonal Mixed Vegetable
Mixed Vegetable Pilaf
Cookies & Brownies
Soda, Coffee, Tea
Open Beer & Wine $20.00
Open Non-Premium Bar $25.00
Open Premium Bar $30.00
Cheese
Pepperoni
Vegetable
Mushroom, Peppers, & Onions
All Star Salad Or Caesar Salad
Grilled Chicken Caesar
Chicken BLT
Cubano
Veggie Burger Wrap
Tortillas
with Guacamole & Salsa
Cookies & Brownies
Includes Soda, Coffee, & Tea
Specials
A Pint Of Beer
A Pint-Full Of A Chocolate Or Vanilla Milkshake
18″ Plain Big Round Pies
Don’s forget to add your favorite toppings!
Wings
Choose your Sauce
$0.75
Whiskey Cocktails $5.00
Glasses Of Wine $5.00
Prime Rib Special
1Lb. Slow Cooked Prime Rib
$20.00
All Well / House Drinks & Select Glasses Of Wine
Monday: Burger & Pint Of Beer Or A Milkshake
Tuesday: 1/2 Of Big Round Pie
Large Plain + Add Your Favorite Toppings!
Wednesday: Wings – Whiskey – Wine
$0.75 Wings + $5 Whiskey and Wine
Thursday: Buckle Down!
Prime Rib Special
$20.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Xiomara Penafiel
It is a spectacular place both the decoration and the delicious food and the excellent attention. very friendly and friendly. I recommend it excellent, I loved everything and next time

… more

Tara T
We happened to come across this as we were heading back from the wineries and hungry. Next to a bowling alley we were unsure but as soon as I saw the Barstool flag I was sold. The food was great, service was quick and friendly. This will definitely be a place I come back to. Fantastic atmosphere.

… more

Mike Taggart
Place is empty, just waiting forty minutes for appetizers that never came out. Also, place was full of idiots cursing and playing pool. Definitely not coming back here.

… more

Anthony Jude
Delicious food and great environment for family fun or date night. Arcade games need a bit of an overhaul (games not working after they have been swiped, balls missing, etc.) but overall we had another amazing time at Smittys.

… more

Matt Pinelli
Very cool bar. Stadium seating and a wall of tvs. Beer selection is pretty good with lots of local brewers on tap. Service was super friendly and prompt.

… more

John Andrew Brighton
I’m from the UK, and this place has good food. I had a good time when I went to see soccer games like the time I saw the World Cup. I had Colin as my server and he’s very sociable whenever I have him as my server. I’m excited for the Arsenal vs Man United game this Sunday.

… more

Lauren Bretton
Not only were they accommodating when we arrived with someone who couldn’t walk up the stairs – our server, Colin, was amazing. So polite, friendly and attentive. The food was delish – legit everything we ordered was so tasty. We cannot wait to make a return trip.

… more

John Consoli
This place is rock solid. Plenty of seating (stadium style. Very cool) Good bar food, great drunk selection and friendly, attentive servers. It’s my go to place for my Sunday Jets games.

… more

Don J
The Calamari was on point! And the chips and salsa was great!

… more

Judith Lapidus
Great place for drinks & eats after bowling.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions