Based on 34 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
466 E Division St, Sparta, MI 49345
Phone: (616) 205-5251
Website: https://www.bluetomatosparta.com/
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
al doom
Same service as Papa Picciones. I’ve gotten my order right maybe a few times. Half cheese/pepperoni shouldn’t be that hard to make correctly. We always have to wait to get it remade poorly. It was cut unevenly, the pizza and sauce on the side were super greasy. WAY TOO MUCH SAUCE.
… more
Kiki V
Usually very good, love that sweet sauce getting XXL pizza sometimes doughy and not enough topping. Other size pizzas always taste amazing, love the flavor. My whole family loves their pizza. I’m usually a strict New york style pizza person but this is definitely pizza worth trying.
… more
Doug Fricano
Its nice to know there is another good pizza shop around. And the owner is about the most sincere and thoughtful person you could ever meet. It would do most people good to patronize this location.
… more
Travis Smith
Tried for the first time tonight. The pizza was really really good! Tried the garlic puffs or knots. Whatever they’re called, they’re awesome! Definitely getting again and often!
… more
John Bissard
First time purchasing at this business. I ordered a Pizza Sub, and my wife ordered a ham & cheese. You would think with a pizza sub, you would actually have pizza sauce on it. Nope. Completely dry in the inside, no sauce, no mayo, nothing. The amount of ingredients was very sparse. Barley any cheese, or any meats. Literally 2 slices of ham for a 12″ sub. Plenty of onions though.
… more
Adam Jill Small
The food here is always so fresh and good! They have come up with some unique pizza options. I definitely recommend the pizza puffs, so good
… more
Bailey Hanrahan
I can tell this was good food but we got delivery on a busy Friday night and live about 10 miles away so the food wasn’t very warm once we got it. With the steep delivery fee and tip, this was a bit disappointing. Online ordering was easy though and someone called to let us know they were running behind so that was appreciated! We warmed the food up in our oven and it was good. We’ll give it another try sometime.
… more
Alec Hamelink
Leaving this review again because the owner was not convinced the other review was from a real account:
… more
Jessica Phillips
We ate at Papa P’s almost weekly. Delivery was always long and sometimes orders were wrong but dealt with it because we appreciate delivery to Conklin. Order from here for the first time tonight. They called and told me they were out of an ingredient for my pizza (no biggie, it happens) so we replaced it. Delivery took an hour. Not a horrible wait, it’s Friday night. The sauce did taste just the same as Papa P’s but unfortunately there was hardly any on the pizza. It was so overcooked and dry. That and the breadsticks were so unbelievably hard and dry that we didn’t really eat much. Flavor was just fine. No sauce included in breadsticks order like Papa P’s used to do. Chalking up the extremely dry and hard pizza due to long delivery I suppose. We will give it one more try in person and see if it’s hot and has sauce. Not one to complain, will try again. Honestly though this pizza was a disappointment tonight.
… more
Josh Blough
Not sure what all the hate is for. Went there for the lunch buffet a few times when they first opened, and got everyone I work with hooked on it. Pizza is always good overall, sauce is amazing, and the garlic puffs are a must have every time.
… more
… View more