Based on 269 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
78 Island Ave, Peaks Island, ME 04108
Phone: (207) 766-2800
Website: https://www.facebook.com/CockeyedGull/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
3:30–8:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 3:30–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 3:30–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 3:30–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 3:30–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Carly Jae
On our first trip to Portland my husband and I decided to hop the ferry to Peaks island for dinner at The Cockeyed Gull, on the glowing recommendation of our Airbnb host. We’re SO glad we did! The food was AMAZING! The views were divine and the service was unmatched. I highly recommend the salmon! 10/10! We can’t wait until our next trip to Portland to come back for another delicious meal.
… more
Vibha Amblihalli
This place was recommended by a local. We had higher expectations, but disappointed. Service is very slow and they didn’t seem to care about the delay. The food was ok. Salmon wasabi dish ordered by SO was good. I ordered chicken Marsala and chicken was over cooked. Pricey, but that is expected for dining at restaurants in island.
… more
Amy Hofmann
This little diamond in the ruff is everything I love about Maine! Vacationing with family and they brought me to the island for this wonderful little ocean front cafe! I cannot wait to go back! Everything about this place was wonderful. We were there in the off season so crowd control was awesome! The view was still stunning and the folks that work here are wonderful! Food was great! We ordered so many different foods and all of them were excellent!
… more
Dena Sutton
As of right now this place is open 7 days a week. It is absolutely fabulous! We got to watch the Sunset on the Patio while enjoying eachother, drinks and delicious food. For Appetizers we ordered the seaweed salad and the shrimp special. The Shrimp were plump with a very subtle crunch which was smothered in a decadent cream sauce. For dinner Fiance got the Shrimp Scampi, and I the Tuna Special both generous portions and cooked perfectly. We live in Portland and it was a great nightly adventure with fabulous food and service, we look forward to becoming regulars here!
… more
MH Moto
We loved the Caesar salad, the tuna tacos, the pork bulgolgi lettuce wraps and the cold beverages. We got to sit outside on the deck on a sunny 4th of July. Awesome view of Portland. Four stars for atmosphere because, while it is incredibly charming, some aspects could use a bit of a new shine. Will love to go back!
… more
fred rozell
Great little restaurant on Peaks Island. Very friendly staff and the food was excellent. Lots of options on the menu. My son has celiac and they were knowledgeable and accommodating. The Korean Bulgogi was fantastic and all 5 in our party enjoyed the meal and great sunset views of the city. For dessert the Boston Cream Pie and Carrot Cake were both delicious. We will make a point of returning here in the future!
… more
Christiana D’Arceuil
My husband came to this place already and he said it was nice so i decided to come this time and I Loved it. The Waitress was so nice, the food was Amazing! The ambiance was Fantastic! I would definitely go back whenever im in Maine again. I had the Smoked Salmon with capers and the sesame seed crust salmon with wasabi sauce and seaweed salad and roasted veggies and it was Amazing!
… more
Chris Merrill
The views were amazing. Service was stellar. The food exceeded my expectations for what I would get on Peaks Island. I had a crusted haddock. The fish was very good. The sauce was well done. The sticky rice was just that.
… more
Zommy NL
We had lunch here and the view is amazing. The food was even better. We had 2 of the daily specials and both were excellent. Potato cakes and crab cakes were nice and crispy and the Caesar salad with Cajun salmon was awesome.
… more
M Langbein
My friend and I were eager to try this little spot. We drove for 5 hours (June 3) and arrived at the inn across the street ….extremely hungry. We arrived and were told they didn’t open until 3:30. We came back a while later and were told they were fully booked. We saw people were finishing up at the bar so thought we’d wait a few minutes. The host (young woman was beyond rude & unfriendly) extremely Kurt & unhelpful.
… more
… View more