Based on 258 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
6704 Bayshore Rd #101, North Fort Myers, FL 33917
Phone: (239) 567-4743
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kokomo Girl
Two slices. The pepperoni was chopped up into little pieces, the mushrooms were chopped up into little pieces. The cheese and sauce were practically non existent. The atmosphere was okay, although the music was terrible. 2 pitiful slices and a coke, $13.64. Good thing it was the special. I definitely do not recommend this place.
… more
James
Great food. The pizza is amazing as are the garlic knots. We also enjoy the antipasto salad. Never tried anything else. We like to eat in. Never a wait. Very quiet inside as we are usually the only ones inside. Appears to be alot if to go orders. Definitely a try if you enjoy a NY pizza.
… more
Andrew John
$9.00 for 2 very thin cheese only slices with a can of soda, no coke in can so a bottle of coke is $2.25 additional charge. The slices were reheated and tasted day old, left me hungry but not wanting more , cheese had an odd “cheddar” flavor. The place is empty at lunchtime, I guess with those profits you don’t need to serve many customers.
… more
Josh Nahm
It is a great, family run restaurant. I’ve been a customer for over three years now. They are originally from Long Island, and it shows. The pizza is New York style, and the pepperoni is their own spin, chopped up and delicious, you may not even realize it is there. The cheese steaks are fantastic, reminds me of the jersey shore. My wife loves the bowling alley fries, the garlic knots, and the salads. I’d say every other time she orders a calzone, but I think we are addicted to the cheese steaks now. The food is consistent, you get the same great quality every time. The owners (wife some days and nights, husband other days and nights) put in the time and it shows. The staff is always friendly and helpful.
… more
Sherry L
Food is very delicious . Handicap friendly and if you want Takeout they have a Drive thru for Pickup. We got the Ny White pizza and Garlic knots and it was Very Hot and Delicious. The Sweets Treats were scrumptious. Highly recommend next time you want Pizza .
… more
Karen Engelker
Did the 2 slices and pop lunch deal…added pepperoni to one and sausage to the other…was surprised pepperoni wasn’t slices but minced up pieces…I liked the taste and loved that their crust is crispy…good deal for quick lunch! Very clean…
… more
Jasmine Byrd
The cheese on the pizza was very good and pretty oily like a NY pizza but we ordered a medium pepperoni and it didn’t really appear to have pepperoni on it. My co-taster thought the pepperoni could have been chopped up on it and under the cheese but I couldn’t taste them. She clearly called out that our pepperoni pizza was ready. Also the prices seem high a medium pepperoni and 16 wings was around $45 with 1 drink-soda.
… more
JR & Lois Smith
Ordered a pepperoni calzone, got a messy cheesy calzone with no pepperoni but paid for the pepperoni. So much ricotta I am feeling nauseous and greasy. Don’t think I am going back, compared to Heavenly Pizza they make a great pizza that is the place to go!
… more
James bondanza
Coming from a NY background this DOES NOT compare!!!! I ordered the lunch special for $6.99 @2 she rang me up for $22 and change when it should’ve been $14 because she she wanted to charge me $8 for two sodas there was little to no cheese or sauce. Pizza was chewy, dough was surely reheated. I’d give this no stars if I could
… more
red1gem
Birdies 2.0!! Loved Birdies so happy to learn the owner is the same person!! Great pizza so happy to have it again!!!!!!! Who knew the Fat Apple was my fav Brooklyn style pizza????
… more
… View more