Casual American outfit featuring a seafood-heavy menu, plus a large craft beer selection. Based on 981 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5406 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217
Phone: (941) 778-5092
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 3:30–9 PM |
| Sunday | 3:30–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
3:30–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 3:30–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 3:30–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3:30–9 PM |
| Friday | 3:30–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: thefeastrestaurantami.com
Reviews
Nardeen Morkos
We came here based on the reviews.
… more
IRONMAN27
We at here with a party of 11. We made reservations a few days prior so we didn’t wait long once we got to the restaurant. They had to seat us outside on two picnic tables. Don’t expect too much from their fans if it’s a hot day or evening. We got the Caprese and Spring rolls as an app and they were very good. We ordered a cheese pizza and peperoni pizza for the kids. Was very good. Nice crust. I got the land and sea with the Filet and Diver Scallops. The scallops were great. Nice flavor and big. The filet was not a good filet. More like a Manhattan thick cut sirloin filet. Don’t get it. Wife had the fresh fish with lump crab over it. She loved it. Mom got a slice of key lime pie that I had to finish off. She was not a fan. All and all they have some good things here but the pizza is prob the best thing they have. Was tempted to get the all you can eat crab legs but at $60 seemed a little steep to me. Maybe if it was $49. 1.5 lbs was $35. Next time we eat here we prob will just order pizza for takeout. If you enjoyed this review please be sure to click the like button. Thank you!
… more
Michael C. Delapena
I recently moved to the area and saw an advertisement for this place on the Island. It’s located on a strip mall and parking is not a problem so that’s a plus. The decor is dated but the service was exceptional. Our server Lilly was friendly and attentive. Our appetizer, the fire cracker shrimp, was delicious. My partner ordered the salmon gnocchi and said it was outstanding. My filet Mignon was good, although it would be nice if a sauce was offered (bernais?). I wish them luck.
… more
Kimberly Moy
I came looking for Snow Crab Legs and this was the only place on Anna Maria Island that felt sure to have them. We came early and still had to sit outside but it was so worth it. While it was so hot, the staff was great and ensured we had plenty of cold water. The crab was great and very tasty. I think the all-you-can-eat is probably a bit much but 2 pounds is perfect. Would definitely return.
… more
Grace Haynes
Amazing food and outstanding service! Our server was super attentive and patient! Best dining experience on the island so far and definitely worth your money.
… more
Megan Severson
This restaurant was AMAZING! We ordered the crab and artichoke dip as an appetizer and it was great. I ordered the shrimp, lobster, and scallop alfredo pasta with penne noodles and it was VERY scrumptious (I forget the name of the dish, but it was on the special dinners menu). The alfredo was buttery which paired well with the seafood. For dessert we ordered the crème brûlée. Our waitress was very nice. A 5 star meal that I will be thinking about for a very long time!!!
… more
Jansen Honberger
If you want great food this is the place. No working bar so I deducted a star for atmosphere. But whoever is running this kitchen knows how to cook. The “small” salad portion was just right as a pre-entree selection. The dressings were great and clearly scratch made. I had the Hogfish special topped with lump crab (photo). It was superb. Even the rice was excellent. We did take out pizzas from this place earlier in the week as well. Hot and fresh and very good. This should be in anyone’s vacation rotation on the north end of the island.
… more
Doug Zandstra
The crab and shrimp linguine is fabulous !! The servers are always courteous and friendly. I recently found out they have pizza, and it turns out its the best pizza on the island
… more
Maryann Rainey
Food was good. Coconut shrimp dinner was good, got 9 shrimps and two sides. Sides were a bit small, and could of had more of selections on sides available. Pricy for what u get, but what u would expect since it’s on Anna Maria island. Biggest convenience was take out was available, definitely was busy to eat in at the time. The fried shrimp was not that great, not much flavor and not crispy enough.
… more
Jennifer Eads
Ordered take out and ended up getting the wrong order (innocent mistake) went back in and not only did they give us the right one but they went beyond expectations to try to please us and apologize. We understand its busy and at dinner time so we didnt expect more than the right order and an apoligy but these people really care!!! We will remember the care for their customers when we return again!
… more
… View more