We are a neighborhood landmark that is family run. The Milevski Family started on Plauderville Ave 33 years ago when we opened Tommy’s Deli and Pizzeria, right down the block from the Firehouse Restaurant. Our pizza experience started back then when Tom Sr., our father, purchased what was then called Paul’s Deli & Pizzeria from our uncle Paul. So technically, our family has been doing business on Plauderville Ave. in Garfield for almost 50 years. Our Business is our life, and we respect every patron we serve. Eat in, order online or have your next catered event here, at our house, the Firehouse Family Restaurant!
Quirky, firehouse-themed eatery offering thin-crust pizza, plus pasta, salads & steaks. Based on 521 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
42 Plauderville Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026
Phone: (973) 478-2226
Website:
Hours
| Tuesday |
3–10 PM |
| Wednesday |
3–10 PM |
| Thursday |
3–10 PM |
| Friday |
3–11 PM |
| Saturday |
3–11 PM |
| Sunday |
3–10 PM |
| Monday |
3–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
worldoffrancis –
Very nice, cozy restaurant and bar.. exceptional service from Tim the bartender, he made my experience totally remarkable.. the food was good very flavorful and the staff is great.. highly recommend for a chill dinner afternoon..
… more
Brian Taylor
This is one of those nice hidden gems that most people don’t know about cause it’s not on the main road or highway.
… more
A break with Kathy
Firehouse
… more
Theodore Trickovic
Their food is amazing. I wish I discovered this place sooner. I have ordered to go 4 times and not once was the quality anything less than perfect. The atmosphere seems very family friendly aswell. I also have to add that the prices are beyond fair for the portion and quality of food you receive.
… more
Jess R
Great place food was awesome & the service was great too they have a small bar but it definitely gives you a feel like a Cheers Bar for sure everyone there is like family. I felt like I have been coming to this bar for years, even though it was my first time. We will be back soon for sure. thin pizza rocked
… more
Elaine Puzio
Friendly, inviting “Cheers” type of atmosphere. Delicious fare abounds to suit even the most particular palate on both the regular and special menus. Everyone is welcome here. Last night there was great live music to accompany our meal. The four of us didn’t want to leave, but other patrons awaited. Well worth weekly stops for dinner or a pizza!
… more
Roman Villanueva
Great place, great food and great atmosphere. The food and the service are absolutely amazing.
… more
Bryan Essing
Expect the unexpected in a completely unexpected location. Super nice people, great food, excellent service. The owners are fantastic people, and you will not be disappointed. Highly recommended
… more
paola esteves
I love everything about this place, the staff, the food, amazing drinks and we always have such a good time each time we go. Thin crust pizza is usually a miss for me but I LOVE their pizza, drunken grandma is to die for!
… more
Robert Brodka
Went there a communion party. They have an upstairs hall great for parties of 50 to 60 people. Food was really good, thin crust pies, calamari, antipasto salad for apps, and then the usual chicken marsala, penne, chicken fingers, the highlight was the tender juicy roast beef. This place is great for a small party try it you won’t be disappointed.
… more
… View more
