Historic Tavern serving British and American Pub Grub. Full restaurant and bar with table service and outdoor seating on nice days. Oldest building in Metamora originally the canal office our tavern was established in 1856 and the hotel was started in 1870. We have a small gift shop featuring T-Shirts and tin items made locally. Come check us out!
Based on 95 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
19038 75 Main St, Metamora, IN 47030
Phone: (765) 207-1111
Website: http://www.themartindalehouse.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–4 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | 11 AM–6 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
C Sparks
This was a pleasant little restaurant that has a history of a hotel. The staff were very pleasant and food was delicious and reasonably priced. There several neat antique decorations throughout the restaurant.
… more
Randy Fedorchak
Lunch after getting off the train. Historic old building. There is outside seating in the back. The Rueben and cole slaw (substituted for the fries) was excellent. They were short staffed but didn’t mind the wait since we were not in a hurry
… more
Cole Swaf
The Martindale House was a cozy experience. The staff was very exceptional with their hospitality and welcoming. For my lunch here I had their Martindale Burger, which was a fresh hand-padded hamburger topped with hot pepper cheese and savory bacon jam all on a pretzel bun. I also had one of their local crafted sodas which was highly delightful. Overall the entire experience was very charming.
… more
Elizabeth Taylor
If you are able to get service, I hope it’s worth it. My husband, friend, and I decided to try this place out. When you walk in, you seat yourself. We sat down for about 5 minutes and waited for someone to arrive to take our order. A couple came in after us, and the man (i believe owner) went to the couple and took their order. He never came back for ours. 15-20 min go by, the chef brings their food. I didn’t get to catch him to tell him we had been waiting. He rushed out of there. After 30 min of waiting for someone to take our order we left. I was trying to give them a chance, since it looked like they were short staffed. Even though they had seen other people in the same room waiting, no one came out to take our order for drinks or food. Poor service. We went across the street for a burger and I would recommend that, because you get to order and get your food. The burgers across the street were great!
… more
Derek Dishman
What a neat place to eat. The food was great, the staff were so friendly. Highly recommend a visit to The Martindale House and the old town of Metamora, Indiana!
… more
Ava H
Had a wonderful time! Food was very good, the service was nice. Had a great atmosphere and a nice old-timey vibe. There were also cats you could see wondering outside which was wonderful to watch as my boyfriend and I enjoyed our meal.
… more
Yolanda
Very hospitable staff. Delicious food. We loved it!
… more
Martin Cabela
Friendly place.
… more
Robert Shidler
Stopped in for the first time yesterday. One of the best burgers I have had. It was cooked perfectly. Wait staff was very informative about the area. Definitely a positive experience.
… more
Back Man
went here last weekend, and, my salad had a long hair in it
… more
… View more