Based on 240 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
8567 Linwood-Southmont Rd, Lexington, NC 27292
Phone: (336) 798-1030
Website: http://thenewyorkerspizza.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Charley
My family used to come here when I was a kid, it was like a hidden gem every-time we went to the lake!! So happy to have found it again.
… more
Heather A
Huge slice. Almost couldn’t finish it. Delicious. 10/10 recommended.
… more
Christa Corkins
Food is amazing. Giant pizzas, I don’t like wings, but I’ve gotten their wings for all of my wing connoisseurs and they have all hands down said their wings are the best.
… more
Yvette Spivock
Located inside a nondescript gas station and has little advertisement except for word of mouth. Which is how we came to stop. Friendly helpful staff, ingredients looked fresh. Only 15 minutes from order to getting. Piping hot! Delicious
… more
Alberta Seabright
My family and l ordered from here about 4 days ago while on vacation. Ill have to say this is prob the very best pizza l have ever had! The stuffed meat lovers pizza is delicious! Crust was perfectly done and just stuffed full of a delicious assortment of meats! Makes me want to drive back to Lexington to eat here often! The calzone was equally delicious with a generous amt of cheese. Wings were a hit also! I wish l could give this more than 5 stars!! HIGHLY recommend eating here! You wont be disappointed!
… more
Nicole Schill
I was told this is the place in the area to get pizza. My family and I have tried it two times and both times we felt the food was not good at all and it was extremely overpriced. They say this is the New Yorkers place to get pizza. I lived in NY for 28 years and this is nothing like NY pie. Their crust is like cardboard, their sauce is flavorless and their toppings are low quality and skimpy!
… more
Angela Jones
Country store with a twist New York style food. It’s great love the food.
… more
Chris Wahly
It’s an actual shame they can’t seem to get things right recently, the food they make is actually good if they actually manage to get the order right. We were regular customers for over 3 years and in the last year the customer service has completely dropped off the face of the earth. 1 out of every 2 or 3 orders was wrong or missing something, calling did basically nothing as they are more concerned with arguing that they didn’t do anything wrong rather than trying to provide the most basic level of customer service, on top of having no issues with calling us and as well as others liars outright. Beyond the orders being outright wrong or missing items, recently they can’t even seem to deliver an order to the correct house and then want to argue over that too trying to tell us that we had the missing food that had never arrived and we were liars and even went as far as refusing a refund for an order already paid for by phone that they made the delivery mistake on. This is a place that has no pride in what they do, no shame in how they act, and they will not care about you as a customer. I would love for this place to come back around but as it is now all I can do is say to think twice before going here unless you want a 50/50 chance of being ripped off or outright disrespected.
… more
Lisa Hurt
I am only giving 2 stars because the food is great, when the order is right. We have ordered from here MANY times but the management has been going down for a while and the past months it has fallen WAY off. I could make a list of the issues we have had but instead I will just say you should have a back up plan if this is your dinner plan. ☹️
… more
Jonathan Reina
Food was actually pretty good but I think their prices are a little high for the amount given.
… more
… View more