The Original Josie’s Pizza Menu – Columbus, OH

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Columbus, OH

Based on 517 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

The Original Josie's Pizza 43222

Address:
894 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222

Phone: (614) 224-9637

Website: http://theoriginaljosiespizza.com/?utm_source=gmb&utm_medium=referral

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday 4–11 PM
Thursday 4–11 PM
Friday 4–11 PM
Saturday 4–11 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 4–11 PM
Tuesday 4–11 PM

Menu

Large (14″) Original Pizzas
Large Cheese
Our classic cheese pizza uses a great blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese, cooked in our classic stone ovens!		 $15.50
Large Pepperoni
Our normal pepperoni pizza has the pepperoni underneath the cheese, and if you prefer it to be above the cheese, just ask for it to be above.		 $16.00
Large Original Pepperoni
This pepperoni pizza comes with “Old Fashion” pepperoni that is on top of the pizza and once cooked curls up and holds delicious grease to add amazing flavor to the pizza.		 $17.50
Large B.L.T
Our B.L.T. pizza comes with our classic bacon, and once cooked, gets topped with our fresh shredded lettuce and fresh cut tomatoes.		 $19.00
Large Hawaiian
Wanna feel like your in Hawaii, then this pizza will bring you their. This pizza gets topped with Ham, Bacon and the final piece, Pineapple.		 $19.00
Large Meatlovers
This Pizza is one of the big once, the meatlover! Topped with, pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon, and ham.		 $21.00
Large Combination
Our classic Combination, coming with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion and green pepper. “Mini Supreme”		 $20.00
Large Supreme
This is a big one, the pizza the comes with almost ever thing on it, our classic Supreme, topped with pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive and banana pepper (3 extra toppings compared to the Combination!)		 $22.00
Large Veggie Pizza
For the person who can’t eat meat or is a vegetarian, our classic veggie will fit that need, topped with mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olives and banana pepper. Or even more!		 $19.00
Small (10″) Original Pizza
Small Cheese
Our classic cheese pizza uses a great blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese, cooked in our classic stone ovens!		 $8.00
Small Pepperoni
Our normal pepperoni pizza has the pepperoni underneath the cheese, and if you prefer it to be above the cheese, just ask for it to be above.		 $8.50
Small Original Pepperoni
This pepperoni pizza comes with “Old Fashion” pepperoni that is on top of the pizza and once cooked curls up and holds delicious grease to add amazing flavor to the pizza.		 $9.50
Small B.L.T
Our B.L.T. pizza comes with our classic bacon, and once cooked, gets topped with our fresh shredded lettuce and fresh cut tomatoes.		 $10.50
Small Hawaiian
Wanna feel like your in Hawaii, then this pizza will bring you their. This pizza gets topped with Ham, Bacon and the final piece, Pineapple.		 $10.50
Small Meatlovers
This Pizza is one of the big once, the meat-lover! Topped with, pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon, and ham.		 $12.50
Small Combination
Our classic Combination, coming with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion and green pepper.		 $11.50
Small Supreme
This is a big one, the pizza the comes with almost ever thing on it, our classic Supreme, topped with pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive and banana pepper. (3 more toppings than the Combination!)		 $12.50
Small Veggie
For the person who can’t eat meat or is a vegetarian, our classic veggie will fit that need, topped with mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olives and banana pepper. Or even more!		 $11.00
Additional Toppings
Extra Cheese/Meats/Veggies For A Small
Double Cheese, Pepperoni, Original Pepperoni, Sausage Hamburger, Ham, Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion, Banana Pepper, Black Olives, Green Olives, Jalapenos, Pineapple, Anchovies.		 $1.00
Extra Cheese/Meats/Veggies For A Large
Double Cheese, Pepperoni, Original Pepperoni, Sausage Hamburger, Ham, Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion, Banana Pepper, Black Olives, Green Olives, Jalapenos, Pineapple, Anchovies.		 $2.00
Extra Premium Meats For Small
Bacon		 $1.50
Extra Premium Meats For Large
Bacon		 $3.00
Subs
Italian Sub
Our classic Italian sub is serve with a toasted bun, cold meat, cheese and veggies. It comes with Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Banana pepper & Onion. (We do NOT have space to heat up /warm subs, sorry for the inconvenience)		 $8.00
Super Italian Sub
Our classic Super Italian sub is serve with a toasted bun, double cold meat, cheese and veggies. It comes with Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Banana pepper & Onion.		 $10.00
Stromboli Sub
Our version of a Stromboli is a “steak patty or a hoagie patty” put onto a buttered toasted bun, with cheese and veggies on it. It comes with the Lettuce, Tomatoes, Banana Pepper, and Onion		 $9.50
Double Stromboli Sub
Our version of a Double Stromboli is a “steak patty or a hoagie patty” put onto a buttered toasted bun, with cheese and veggies on it. It comes with Two Stromboli patty, provolone cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Banana Pepper, and Onion		 $14.50
Meatball Sub
For our meatball sub it will come with four meatballs, with provolone cheese on top of it.		 $8.00
Chicken Sub
Our Chicken sub is served with two deep fried chicken patty, along with cheese & veggies. It comes with provolone cheese, two chicken patties, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Banana Pepper, and Onion.		 $10.00
Chicken Parm Sub
Our Chicken Parm Sub is served with two deep fried chicken patty, along with cheese, spaghetti sauce & veggies. It comes with provolone cheese, two chicken patties, sauce.		 $10.00
Appetizers
Small Garlic Bread
Our Classic Garlic bread service on a 10″ pie. With Garlic sauce, cheese and oregano.		 $8.00
Large Garlic Bread
Our Classic Garlic Bread but larger! Served on a 14″ pie. With Garlic sauce, cheese and oregano.		 $15.00
Inferno Wings
6 of our traditional Tyson bone-in chicken wings that have a nice kick when you take a bit. Served with a side of ranch or blue cheese dressing. (Can be ordered in bigger quantity)		 $8.50
Mild Wings
6 of our traditional Tyson bone-in chicken wings that have a nice juicy taste when you bit into them. Served with a side of ranch or blue cheese dressing. (Can be ordered in bigger quantity)		 $8.50
6 Chicken Tenders
6 of our juicy chicken tender always hit the spot! (Check out dinners for meal options.)		 $5.50
12 Chicken Tenders
12 of our juicy chicken tender always hit the spot! (Check out dinners for meal options.)		 $10.50
Cheese Sticks
Total of 5 cheese sticks, served with pizza sauce.		 $5.50
Mac & Cheese Bites
Total of 5 Mac & Cheese Bits. (Just like mom makes it but it’s in bites!)		 $5.00
Onion Rings
Our classic O-Rings or Onion rings!		 $4.50
Broccoli & Cheese Poppers
5 total. Broccoli cut up mixed with cheddar cheese served inside a breaded shell.		 $5.50
Jalapeno Poppers
Total of 4 massive breaded Jalapeno popper packed with cream cheese.		 $5.50
Breaded Mushrooms
Multiple sizes but tons of juicy mushroom flavor with it wrapped in breaded shell.		 $5.50
French Fries
Classic half cut steak French Fries		 $4.00
Dinners
Chicken Dinner
Our chicken dinner is a 4 piece chicken dinner, with french fries, a salad with a dressing of your choice and a roll. Within the dinner you will get a Chicken breast, wing, thigh, and a leg.		 $11.00
Chicken Tender Dinner
Our Chicken Tender dinner is served with 6 tender, french fries, a salad and a dressing of your choice.		 $10.00
Chicken Parmesan & Spaghetti Dinner
Our Chicken Parmesan dinner is served with a piece chicken, with spaghetti sauce, a salad with a dressing of your choice and a roll.		 $10.00
Spaghetti & Meatball Dinner
Classic Spaghetti comes with Two meatballs, Noodles, a salad with a dressing of your choice, and a roll.		 $10.00
Sandwiches
Hamburger
Classic hamburger, served with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Pickle. (Condiments can come on the side.)		 $5.00
Double Hamburger
Classic Hamburger but let’s make it TWO patties!, served with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Pickle. (Condiments can come on the side.)		 $6.50
Cheeseburger
Classic cheeseburger, served with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Pickle. (Condiments can come on the side.)		 $5.50
Double Cheeseburger
Classic cheeseburger but let’s make it TWO patties!, served with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Pickle. (Condiments can come on the side.)		 $7.50
Chicken Sandwich
One piece of chicken breast on a butter toasted bun, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, banana pepper and cheese. Classic cheeseburger but let’s make it TWO patties!, served with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Pickle. (Condiments can come on the side.)		 $5.50
Meatball & Cheese Sandwich
Two meatballs on a butter toasted bun with provolone cheese on top.		 $4.50
Grilled Cheese
Our classic grilled cheese, with two slices on american cheese.		 $3.50
Texas Toast Grilled Cheese
Texas Toasted grilled cheese, and within two slices of American and Provolone cheese.		 $5.00
BBQ Sandwich
A great tasting BBQ, with cooked beef, put in between a butter toasted bun. (No pork within ingredients)		 $4.50
Salads
Italian Chef Salad Large
Our iconic Chef Salad comes with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Banana Pepper, Onion, Chefs meat, Pepperoni, American and Sheared Cheese. (Comes with 3 dressings as well.)		 $9.00
Small Italian Chef Salad
Our iconic mini Chef Salad comes with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Banana Pepper, Onion, Chefs meat, Pepperoni, American and Sheared Cheese. It Comes with 2 dressings as well.		 $6.00
Quart Tossed Salad
Our Tossed Salad comes with Lettuce and Tomatoes, along with 2 dressings of your choice.		 $5.00
Pint Tossed Salad
Our Tossed Salad comes with Lettuce and Tomatoes, along with 1 dressings of your choice.		 $3.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Denzel Pitman
I placed an order on Wednesday for an Italian sub, perfection, I loved it. Fast forward to today and I wanted pizza first thing that came to mind was Josies, so I call and the lady who answered remembered who I was and the day I ordered! In this day and age, where customers are just a dollar sign, it felt great be genuinely acknowledged. I will be a regular because she made me feel like I already was! Great food great vibe great people! I will definitely be returning and will definitely recommend them to anyone who wants a pizza, sub, or wings, and to anyone who wants that nostalgic, “come back again y’all hear?!” Feeling. Kudos You guys kudos.

… more

Samantha Byrne
I ordered Josie’s while on a trip because of the reviews. I ordered a large pepperoni well done. My favorite part, the dough. Super fresh and was great tasting. The sauce was okay. The price was a little steep for the pizza I ordered. The area surrounding the building was a little suspicious. When I pulled up, I thought this cannot be the right building however, it was. The parking lot was weird and the entrance that you had to go when you had to park further because there was only handicap parking right by the doors. I would try again but wouldn’t go out if my way to stop here.

… more

Shoe Hudson
The pizza was very much MID! It did not look like the pizza posted on the website. I ordered a pepperoni pizza. There were NO pepperoni on the pizza. The pepperoni was placed on the sauce and then topped with cheese to hide the fact that there were NO pepperoni on the pizza. Grocery store pizza is better than this place.

… more

Theresa Kayalar
The pizza was delicious, but the crust was outstanding! I’m not sure I can describe it properly. It was crisp, like buttery crust, and then immediately tender. I don’t know how they do that on a thin crust pizza . . . But they do. I worked at Mount Carmel West for 37 years, so I had Josie’s a lot and it was so good then, but, honestly, I feel it’s even better now! I love the spot they are in, just down the street from the previous location. There is lots of room for dine in. The staff was so friendly and welcoming!!

… more

Christy Hart
I’ve always had excellent service and have yet to have any issues with my order. I have recommended Josies to several people and they now order from them on a regular basis. All the employees are always friendly even when they are very busy they all hold their composure. The only thing I have to say in a negative way is they are only open until 10pm.. Josies Pizza is my favorite pizza place. They also offer dinners, salads, and fried foods with reasonable prices that everyone can afford

… more

Jason Dodson
Josie’s is easily one of the best pizzas in Columbus and a true to form Columbus style pizza. I always go for the classic Pepperoni, but their specialties are great too. They’ve got great subs and apps as well! Definitely get yourself some Josie’s if you’ve not already!

… more

Nick Begovich
Very good pizza. Will try double pepperoni and well done next time. Nice drivers. They don’t make tipping very easy, though, I’ll say that.

… more

Leavy Peretto
Pizza was the bomb even though cold because mix up on locations. MAKE SURETHE LOCATION IS CORRECT. This is critical for great pizza. The salad was interesting. The lettuce was fresh but all it was lettuce and tomato. Really should of had something because it felt like it was missing that. The pizza was on point tho. Great crust and sauce. Like no other.

… more

Relish Mac
Been eating this pizza since a little girl. Will always hv a special place in my heart! Hands down thee best pizza in the Midwest

… more

lucille koval
Been going there since my dad toke me my dad knows the workers good people best pizza

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch