Simple stop for thin-crust & Sicilian pizza by the pie or slice, plus calzones, wraps & more. Based on 365 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
831 Bass Pro Ln, Cary, NC 27513
Phone: (919) 677-8484
Website: http://www.theoriginalnypizza.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Maple Roads
A New Yorker I am….this pizza was good. Very close to the pizza I’m accustomed to! Friendly staff, clean and decently priced. Here in NC it’s challenging to buy slices, I was happy to try after shopping next door at Bass Pro Shop. Great location! Enjoy!
… more
ryan bitner
Pizza had no flavor. The sauce and sausage were bland. It was a big pizza the crust could have been a little bit thinner. I asked for extra sauce and well done pizza and that was not accomplished. I remember this place having good pizza years ago. I moved out of the area and I breezed true today and was not impressed. Maybe the ownership changed.
… more
Tracy Helms
This was my first time dining at this restaurant. The stromboli was the best I’ve ever eaten. It had just the right amount of toppings and a generous amount of cheese. The crust was light, soft on top, and crispy to bite into.
… more
Vikki Martin
I debated on the rating because there are good and not good things experienced. I opted to be more generous versus more critical. 3.5 would be true rating. The positive is they are very fast with delivery compared to other places. The ingredients are good quality. Salads are nice and they’re generous with dressing. Usually the amount of toppings is good but we had a few times in recent months where things were skimpy, to the extent I started ordering double toppings. On this occasion they were back to being generous so double meatballs was overkill. We find the veggy toppings are barely cooked but if you ask for the pizza more done the crust is too done. Favorites are meatball parmesan and ham and pineapple. Husband always gets pepperoni and mushroom. Their wings are pretty good, 7 out of 10 according to wing connoisseur husband. They do have a reward program so you earned $10 off after you spend so much and they periodically send me a we miss you $5 off or free garlic knots offers.
… more
GB Crush
The Original NY Pizza really has that NJ/NY corner pizzeria feel to it. The staff is friendly, the pizza is divine, and it really is the kind of place where you pop in, get a slice, and just sit down for a moment to chow it all down. I usually take home whole pies I love these guys so much. Today, however, I tried a slice of their Sicilian and…mmMmmm! We are talking about a thicc brick delicious buttery-savory deliciousness, and a wonderful crisp outside edge. The dough in the middle has a wonderful chew to the bite and the sauce has just the lightest tang. Yum.
… more
MJ Worldwide
Excellent pizza, I mean truly exceptional, taste just like some of the best spots in NYC. Now the wings …. hmmmm … kinda dry. I will not order them again. I’ve been coming here for years and will continue to eat here.
… more
Natalie Hatter
I’ve been looking for this pizza for years. I can’t get enough! The crust is perfect texture and flavor. The sauce is amazing and the sausage single slice. Oh em gee.
… more
Angela Chappell
Our pizza orders have been perfect every time, delicious and hot, and the staff is friendly. This is our No. 1 pizza place now!!
… more
Tam Midkiff
Had never seen the place, but that’s where the folks I was meeting suggested to sit and talk.
… more
Russell Villard
Great Pizza takeout. Nice little sitting area.
… more
… View more