Based on 236 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086
Phone: (716) 681-1111
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ash G
I wish I would’ve taken pictures! I ordered three different sheets for a party to be ready by a certain time. These guys had the pizza coming out promptly and cut as I was there to pick up. Pricing and quality were on point! Definitely check them out for any large (or small gatherings)!
… more
Joella Laramay
I feel like I got a steal, pun intended, a small chicken finger salad and mozzy sticks for 11 bucks! The salad was delicious, perfectly portioned, had plenty of chicken in it with fresh lettuce, tomato slices and cheese. The mozzy sticks were a little too crispy but were definitely fresh. I’m definitely coming back!
… more
Sheila Mamon
I ordered a pizza & boneless wings combo
… more
William Knauber
Had a party at como park for 60-70 people, everyone coming from all over Wny, everyone commented on the pizza and boneless wings, that they were great, the quality and the price will keep me coming back as really impressed
… more
jessica kendall
I’ve been going to The Pizza Heist for years. Food is very good and consistent. I highly recommend this pizzeria. My favorite is their white pizza.
… more
Scott Horvatits
My kids and I rate a different Pizza joint every other week! This one just took the lead! We even ordered two nights in a row we loved it so much! Great Pizza and Friendly Team at the counter!!! Highly recommend! Wings perfect!
… more
Sharon Steck
Great food with an affordable menu! Nice, friendly service! A hidden secret in Lancaster, NY!
… more
Sharon Believes
What happened? We got five pizzas on a Monday in late July and they were so good. Yesterday we got two pizzas. The price had gone up to $11.95 but the taste of the pizza isn’t good anymore. The sauce is awful. I’m not sure why they changed it or if the sauce was just starting to go bad. But I think the worst part was how thirsty we were. All night yesterday we were drinking water and couldn’t quench our thirst and then we had leftover pizza for breakfast and we couldn’t get enough water to quench our thirst all day. Sorry but I don’t think we’ll be back. It’s sad that things changed so much since July. The pizza used to be so good.
… more
Peter Notaraz
This place is exactly what it claims to be, a meal for a steal !!! Delicious food at great prices. The owners are friendly and it’s family owned ! I really can never complain when I order pizza here. It’s a great sweet sauce and I the ingredients are fresh. I love trying new things and I ate the thin crust with hot peppers and pepperoni, well done !! It was awesome all at the owners suggestion. Good people, great food!
… more
Mary Ellen Weiss
We usually love their pizzas our favorite is the steak pizza. We ordered today and our pizza was only ok a first for this business. The crust was burned. We felt
… more
… View more