The Pizzeria of Islip Menu – Islip, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Islip, NY

Based on 272 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

The Pizzeria of Islip 11751

Address:
591 Main St, Islip, NY 11751

Phone: (631) 581-9500

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9 PM
Sunday 12 AM–7 PM
Monday 11 AM–8 PM

Menu

Beverages
20 Oz Coke $2.50
Coke Glass Bottle $2.50
20 Oz Diet Coke $2.50
20 Oz Sprite $2.50
20 Oz Dr Pepper $2.50
20oz Ice Tea $2.50
Smart Water $2.50
20oz Lemon Aid $2.75
Case Of Poland Spring
2Lt Coke $4.00
2Lt Diet Coke $4.00
2Lt Sprite $4.00
2Lt Fanta $4.00
2Lt Ice Tea $4.00
Food
Large Pie $19.95
Sicilian Pie $22.95
Grandma Pie $22.95
White Pie
Square Pie w/Ricotta, Mascarpone, Mozz & Truffle Oil		 $27.95
The Islip Pie
Our Sweet Red Sauce on Olive Oil Crust w/ Fresh Mozz. Our Version of a Margherita Pie		 $27.95
Vodka Margarita Pie
Olive Oil Crust Topped w/ Fresh Mozz & Vodka Sauce		 $27.95
Tri-Fecta Pie
Olive oil crust with fresh mozzarella cheese. Topped with pizza sauce, vodka sauce, pesto and parmesan cheese.		 $27.95
Bar Pie
Olive oil crust with pizza sauce and light mozzarella cheese. Topped with hot honey and dollops of burrata cheese.		 $27.95
The Uncle Benny
Olive oil crust with light pizza sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, crumbled sausage, cup and char pepperoni, hot honey drizzle and fresh basil		 $28.95
The Honey Pep Pie
Sicilian with Pepperoni & Mike’s Hot Honey Drizzle		 $28.95
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
Thai Chili Sauce on Pizza? Yes, Trust Us		 $28.95
Upside Down Pie
Fresh Mozz Under our Sweet Sauce on Sicilian Crust		 $27.95
Meat Ball Burrata Pie
Meatballs, Burrata, Basil & Red Sauce		 $28.95
Crumbling Vodka Pie
Grandma crust with fresh mozzarella cheese, crumbled sausage and seasoned vodka sauce.		 $28.95
Detroit Pie
Crispy Multi-Cheese Crust, Straight from Motor City		 $24.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Pronounced: C-B-R		 $29.95
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Wings + Pizza, it’s a Good Thing		 $29.95
Bruschetta Pie
Balsamic Infused Crust, Cherry Tomatoes, Burrata & Glaze		 $28.95
Gluten Free Pie
Gluten free and dairy free crust		 $15.95
Salad Pie $28.95
Nonna’s Non-Dairy Pie
Olive Oil Crust, Veggies & Red Sauce		 $27.95
Regular Slice $3.22
Sicilian Slice $3.68
Grandma Slice $3.68
Islip Slice $5.06
Vodka Margherita Slice $5.06
Uncle Benny Slice
Our olive oil crust with fresh mozzarella, crumbled sausage, cup and char pepperoni, Mike’s hot honey and basil.		 $5.06
The Honey Pep Slice $5.06
Tri-Fecta Slice
Olive oil crust with vodka sauce, pesto, red sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese		 $5.06
Thai Chili Slice $5.06
Meat Ball Burrata Slice $5.06
White Slice $5.06
Upside Down Slice $5.06
Detroit Slice $5.06
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice $5.06
Buffalo Chicken Slice $5.06
Bruschetta Slice $5.06
Salad Slice $6.50
Bar Slice $5.06
Crumbling Vodka Slice $5.06
Garlic Knots
No Order is Complete Without Them
Buffalo Knots
Knots Tossed in our Specially Formulated Buffalo Sauce. These are Special.
Chicken Roll
Breaded Chicken Cutlets w/Mozz Cheese, Red Sauce and Seasonings		 $9.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap $9.95
Prosciutto Street Sandwich
Prosciutto, Fresh Mozz, Tomato, Basil, Olive Oil on Freshly Made Focaccia		 $12.95
Pesto Chicken Street Sandwich
Freshly Made Focaccia w/ Grilled Chicken, Pesto, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers		 $12.95
Caprese Street Sandwich $10.95
Pepperoni Pinwheel
Cup and Char Pepperoni with Mozz Cheese twirled in our Fresh Dough		 $4.25
Vegetable Pinwheel
Broccoli, Cheddar, Mozz & Freshly Chopped Garlic all wrapped up		 $4.25
Single Rice Ball $1.50
Rice Ball (3)
Risotto, Chop Meat, Mozz Cheese and Red Sauce. (No Peas)		 $4.50
Fried Ravioli (9)
Breaded Ravioli w/ Vodka Sauce to Dip		 $10.95
Side Meatballs $10.95
Mozzarella Sticks $10.95
Wings
10 Wings Per Order		 $14.95
Garlic Bread W/Mozzarella $5.95
Calzone $8.95
Chicken Parm Hero $12.95
Eggplant Parm Hero $12.95
Meatball Parm Hero $12.95
Shrimp Parm Hero $12.95
THE Hero
Chicken or Meatball with Burrata, Fresh Basil, EVOO & Shaved Parm on Seeded Semolina Bread		 $14.95
Sausage & Pepper Parm Hero $12.95
House Salad
Mixed Field Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Freshly Made Croutons & Mozz Cheese		 $12.95
Cesaer Salad
Romain, Shaved Parmesan cheese, Parm Crisps and Croutons		 $13.95
THE Salad
Field Greens, Honey Crisp Apple Sticks, Cherry Tomatoes, Croutons, Candied Pecans, Parm Crisps and Cheddar Cheese		 $14.95
Side Salad $6.97
Penne Alla Vodka $18.95
The Mezzi Rig
Mini rigatoni pasta with seasoned vodka sauce and melted mozzarella cheese		 $18.95
Beggars’ Purses
5 cheese pasta pouches with vodka sauce and crumbled sausage		 $18.95
Broccoli Rabe
Orecchiette pasta with crumbed sausage, garlic and broccoli rabe		 $18.95
Baked Ziti $16.95
Pasta With Meatballs $17.95
Spaghetti With Tomato Sauce $12.95
Chicken Parmagiana $23.95
Eggplant Parmagiana $23.95
Shrimp Parmagiana $23.95
Chicken Francese $23.95
THE Pizzeria Chicken
Chicken Cutlet Topped w/ Arugula, Cherry Tomato & Balsamic Glaze		 $23.95
Meatball Parmigiana $23.95
Sausage And Peppers $23.95
Zeppoles $0.75
Mini Cannoli $2.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Magali Gomez
I found this place by change in Google. We were 3, and loved the fact that we could sit and dine in as an informal setting. We ordered a few slices and wow, everything was delicious! Drinking a refreshing beer made everything better. I will definitely go back when in the area again.

… more

Michael Kaiser
Great Buffalo chicken slices and I like the Buffalo garlic knots. I need to try the regular knots next time. The only thing that through me off was there are 3 doors in the front. 2 go to the pizzeria but only 1 actually opens and the middle door goes upstairs.

… more

Krystal
5 Star for both food and Price. 2 huge slices of NY pizza, 8 garlic knots, and a drink for $10 and change. That’s amazing to me.

… more

Joseph Armetta
I ordered a regular pie half pepperoni, After I waited over 1hr I received an uncook pizza, therefor, I called to complain and they offered to send another pizza which I specified well done! Unfortunately, I didnt receive a well done pixza but worse than the first pizza. Don’t waste your money in this place….. unprofessional pizza makers

… more

Sharon Hendricks
Just tried this pizza spot for the first time today. I tried the one in Islip because the Bay Shore one doesnt deliver yet where I live. The pizza tasted really good. The ingredients tasted fresh, crust was baked to perfection and sauce did not tasty like it was canned. Unfortunately, the garlic knots disappointed in size as they were not actually “garlic knots”, but ” garlic bites”. They were however really good well seasoned and not soggy like other pizza places. I think if anything they should change the name to, ” garlic bites” and charge according to that size.

… more

Glenn Brewer
This pizzeria gives us one more reason to LOVE our town. Delicious, hot , fresh pizza. Before we left, they even asked if our two kids wanted to come behind the counter and help! These people know how to make excellent pizza , but also know excellent service and genuinely love what they do. We will be back!

… more

sharon butler
One of the best pizza places around. Great variety, clean restaurant, friendly attentive staff. Kassy is the sweetest. Such a warm welcoming smile in her face.

… more

Matt Ferraro
Very Good food, very good local business that appreciates the town and allows kids to go there after school….and a huge bonus they have clean bathrooms! Well done pizzeria!

… more

Lois Kim
Chicken bacon ranch is mediocre, it’s under seasoned. The zeppolis are way too doughy. It was still wet inside. Mediocre pizza place at best.

… more

Anthony Boodhai
My taste buds are in UTOPIA, this slice of pizza makes me feel EUPHORIC. Exceptional Service. Thank you Danny, Falco, Greg, James and all the staff at “the PIZZERIA. Love you guys!!! Islip/Bayport.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch