Based on 45 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
10 Chesterfield Rd, East Lyme, CT 06333
Phone: (860) 739-2054
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dan
The service here was great! The person handling the counter was friendly and easy to talk to. I’ve been looking for a good mashed potato pizza for a while so I ordered the large (18″) Loaded Van Gogh (mashed potato, bacon, broccoli, scallions, cheddar, and Alfredo). It tasted great and was right out of the oven when I picked it up.
… more
Matthew Biggins
Dave is amazing! Service was almost better than the food. Pictured is the Ali without cheese but with sauce. Definitely add sauce but go vegan cheese at a minimum or the sandwich is way too messy. Delicious loose sausage and peppers on Gluten-free bread!
… more
Gbottone
Ordered the salami Caesar for pick up.
… more
Robin Soltesz
Food was good. Takeout seems to be their niche though. Dining room experience was more like take out but you can use their tables.
… more
Book Barn
We requested a luncheon for ten people, a selection of their popular dishes, including some vegetarian dishes they delivered large pizzas (excellent crust–and we’re a tough crowd for pizza), a variety of delicious and interesting sandwiches and a beautiful fresh salad. Everyone had plenty, a few lucky people took home extras, and the universal verdict was thumbs-up all ’round. We’ll definitely be going back.
… more
LJ León
The manager was “busy” to come to the front to take my complaint about the meatballs and slice of pizza I ordered, which were all reheated to an improperly internal, consumable temperature. Meanwhile, the cashier informed me the manager would complete the refund when he can and that she’ll remind him to, and that she’ll even write it down to remind him…
… more
Leanna Maio
My husband and I always love getting sandwiches and salads from the Plum Tomato. We had a last minute catering issue with a different restaurant, and the staff at Plum Tomato East Lyme did a wonderful job helping us with a catering order to feed guests for our event. We received many compliments on the catering, and we very happy our party guests enjoyed the food! Thank you so much!
… more
T H
I have loved Plum Tomato in Salem and Colchester, and it’s nice to see in now in East Lyme. The best thing about Plum Tomato to me is their brikini bread. It’s pretty tasty made into a sandwich. We love the Titanic Turkey, with its yummy chutney dressing. Which my kids use on their pizza crust also. This place took over Yummy Yummy, and its a nice replacement, although im disappointed they left. My family loves this pizza, which can be really greasy at times and their sandwiches. Many to choose from.
… more
Terri Brennan
Absolutely horrible! Pizza was cold. Ordered a “Caesar Salad” that came with onion, carrots and tomato? When I called back to question was told that is their Caesar.not to mention the Caesar dressing?? Ugh, no clue what it was! First and last time.
… more
Sandra Silveira
Fabulous thin crust pizza. We chose both a white and red. Loved both! Our red was a sausage and caramelized onion – perfect blend of savory and sweet. Our white was the Frederico, OMG blue cheese, perfectly tangy on the pizza. Both of them – new favorites. Fresh ingredients, crisp salads, and overall delicious. Had an order delivered, the driver was on time and courteous. This will be our go to place for lunches.
… more
… View more