Traditional tavern serving sandwiches & American mains in a 19th-century building with a fireplace. Based on 317 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
14 Prospect St, Madison, NJ 07940
Phone: (973) 295-6255
Website: http://www.theprospecttavern.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12:30–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12:30–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12:30–10 PM |
| Friday | 12:30–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12:30–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12:30–9 PM |
| Monday | 12:30–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J
I’ve always passed this place when in the area, and I finally had some time to go inside and enjoy an early dinner with my wife. It’s a nice pub inside, nothing fancy but it was comfortable and relaxing. We were there during off hours, so it wasn’t crowded. I had the chicken cordon bleu, fried dumpling, and my wife had the salmon dish. Everything was top-notch, and we left happy knowing this place is an option.
… more
George Rapciewicz
4 of us had dinner . The food was outstanding. Service was outstanding. Roast beef sandwiches, prime rib cheese steak , chicken wrap, and I had prime rib. The 4 of us were VERY Satisfied with our meals. You will not be disappointed! Great Food!
… more
John C. Fusi
Nice local pub. Great service. Inspired chef. Reasonable prices. Definitely a winning combination. Only downside…indoors it can be a little loud.
… more
Davey Anthony
Don’t listen to the one star reviews. This place is very warm and great for conversing. It’s not so loud like the other bars around the area. The food is amazing and happy hour prices are great and affordable (you are in a bar after all where drinks are always expensive, but it is very affordable during happy hour). The bartenders are great people and always attend you when you need them. The food is just great! The family are amazing people. No disrespect is tolerated in this location so if you are planning to get drunk and be reckless, well, good luck. It is a great place to eat outside. I have been on a few dates here and always have had a good time. This is a place where you never feel pressure to order right away as some other bars do to customers. This is a peaceful bar/restaurant with a family who deeply cares about their customers. Anthony is a great person who works very very hard, he is the head bartender and will always try his best to help (It can get very busy). Overall, great place for a date, by yourself, or just to hangout with friends. Great atmosphere. I completely 100% recommend it for anyone who wants to get a quick drink or bite, or even relax. Happy hour is 3-6 and prices are amazing. Take my word for it, give it a try. Food is great.
… more
N A
loooooove this place. was here last night n the bartender was on it! food was great. drinks awesome. and service was quick n friendly. will def be back.
… more
Jessica Kaminskyj
This place is great! There were a lot of people there (it was a Friday night) but you do not feel cramped at all. Service was great. There is a large selection of drinks. The food was very delicious I ordered French onion soup, it was good not too salty! For dinner I ordered a strawberry brie salad. It was absolutely delicious, great portion size for only 12 dollars! I would recommend going with friends, not ideal for a date 🙂
… more
Barry Morgenstein
Perfect atmosphere! Looks like a quaint, cool pub, but the food happens to be excellent also! A must if you are in Chatham or live in the area. Better than just bar food! Inside and outside is very cozy and appealing!
… more
Hank Chang
Solid fries and teriyaki wings. Good selection of beers. Some parking to the side. Happy hour from 3 to 6 weekdays. Pulled pork good but too sour and needs a stronger bun. Mozzarella sticks too dry. The big pretzel was a hit though! Coworkers like the beer selection here.
… more
Dan Matarazzo
Good food in a casual setting. They have a large bar, plenty of indoor seating, and a lovely outdoor section. The food is a step above pub/ tavern food, with the lobster Mac and cheese being a favorite amongst our family. They have a nice selection of appetizers and other items, so you can get a full meal or just snacks with drinks.
… more
Jacqueline Almeida
Overall okay experience. Pretty pricey. Some drawbacks were that it took a little long, pasta was a la dente (too hard for me) and decent nothing great. App was pretty good (mac and cheese balls). Wine was good and hubby had beer (miller lite although selection was good). Dessert was alright (Molten cake with ice cream) was a little on the dry side. Nothing to really complain about but nothing to rave about either. Service was good.
… more
… View more