The Sandwich Mafia is an Italian deli, specializing in sandwiches and pizza. You will find quality food that is very fresh, and a friendly staff waiting to help make your lunch or dinner experience exactly what you need. Featuring local breads, Boar’s Head meats and gluten-free options.
Based on 266 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
100 Cleave St, Estes Park, CO 80517
Phone: (970) 591-2400
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Carl Meredith
I’d give this place a pass. Food sounds good but it’s not. French bread was hard as a rock. Roast beef was clearly store bought or old. Pizza crust was burnt. 6 people behind the counter and it took 20 mins to get 2 sandwiches and a kids cheese pizza when no one was in front of me. So many better choice is Estes.
… more
Kadir Pala
Very friendly stuff, pizza was amazing. Definitely I will come again.
… more
Antoni Davis
BLT and the Uncle Tony were good sandwiches. But they were just sandwiches. Estes Park is a tourist town and we were tourists and loved this was exactly what we needed to have the energy to walk the town. Wonderful experience, picnic table outside seating and does have a main road entrance.
… more
Mark Winchester
This place is cool in theory. A small sandwich shop with a mafia theme. However, the service was severely lacking. I had to repeat my order to the gentleman working the register 8 times (this is not an exaggeration) and he still omitted 1/3 of our food. To their credit, the pizzas were good and seemed fresh (which is why I gave 2 stars). But the Nonna’s meatball sandwich seemed to have either been made with old or freezer burned meat or it was overcooked. The meat was dry and unusually dark. Not worth the $13 I paid. Overall, I would look elsewhere for food in Estes Park.
… more
Samuel Robertson
Cute restaurant down an alley which was neat. Service was great. Had some interesting sodas to choose from (including root beer made right in Estes). 4 stars simply due to the fact that even though the sandwiches are good, they’re essentially just your every day lunch meat. Clean restaurant.
… more
Callum Markel
Place was small but nice. The drink options were a little meh, they didn’t have water despite having 20 different soda options. The pizza was okay at best and the lack of napkins or plates was hard.
… more
Mitch De Zwarte
Cool little sandwich shop tucked away from the main tourist shops. Food was fresh and tasty. Staff was friendly. They even gave me a free strawberry cannoli!
… more
Bradley Harvey
Absolutely the worst sub I have ever had. We ordered 2 jimmy conway sandwiches and just got a very little amount of meat and no toppings like it said. They do not answer the phone. Subway is a better choice. I would never go here again and would never recommend this establishment.
… more
Kelsey Barbare
We stopped by after hiking in RMNP since it was one of the only things open and it was fantastic! Our daughters split pizza slices and a grilled cheese, both were delicious. Our oldest loved that she could pick up to four cheeses for the grilled cheese and they had her favorite, provolone. My husband had the roast beef sandwich and I had the Guilianna which was amazing.
… more
J T
Meh. Sign says freshly made expect a long wait of up to 20 minutes, when a two topping large took almost an hour. The crust seemed too chewy and not fully cooked (this is the second time I’ve ordered here same results). Veggies tasted canned, sauce tasted like prego. Cheese was skimpy. Upstairs tables were dirty with obvious crumbs. Prices were A lot for a lack luster wet pizza.
… more
… View more