Based on 58 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
912 W 5th St, Wilton, IA 52778
Phone: (563) 732-9396
Website: https://www.facebook.com/sicilianpizzeriawilton
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 3–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sheruff Muscatine
Pizza was ok. But I ordered a turkey club (its literally on their menu) what they gave me was a hot ham and cheese sub. I called and the person said they don’t have a turkey club (even though it’s on their menu) so they gave me a hot ham and cheese instead. Didn’t even ask if the substitution was ok, because I wasn’t ok with it. It wasn’t good, I threw it away. I’ve never eaten somewhere where they purposely make a substitution without telling you, then just charge full price and don’t do anything to make it right.
… more
cooper wehage
Pizza was greasy, crust was burnt and hard. Not worth the $47 we paid for 2 large pizzas. Ended up making all of our stomachs hurt after because of the grease. Would not recommend their pizza. They get another because their other food is good, just not the pizza.
… more
Braaptism
For a little hole in the wall Italian joint it doesn’t disappoint. The bill was a little steep but for the amount of food and quality of the food, I have no complaints. If you leave hungry thats your fault. The type of full that leads to a nap..not the toilet. Ill definitely support this small business next time I’m in the area. Thanks for the hospitality folks..appreciate it.
… more
Steve Petersen
Excellent pizza, Excellent service, not a fancy place, very reasonably priced. They also offer many pasta dishes, appetizers, calzones and some good ole American food too. Carry out, delivery and take and bake available. I’ll definitely be going back.
… more
T E
Great pizza and great people… great customer service.
… more
JayLyn Burroughs
Such a great experience! Wonderful people running the place and amazing food! I will always recommend this place when we’re craving delicious food!
… more
The Lawman
Good pizza! I’ve had it a couple of times and would recommend. I’m a fan of the classic pizza ovens and the crust. Pretty quick too.
… more
Melissa DeWitt
Traveling from Utah to Indiana. Easy to find and short drive off the 80. So much better than a chain pizza restaurant! Fresh veggies on the pizza and the crust was great. Not too saucey. I mentioned on the phone we were traveling, when we arrived for pick up they had paper plates and napkins bagged and ready for us with our pizza. Fast service, great price, kind people and delicious pizza. Glad we stopped!
… more
Zach Grantham
Would give 0 stars if I could first off I ordered over $30 in food from them. Then I waited over an hour and a half for my pizza. When they delivered it, I found plastic in my cheese sticks. I called, and the manager was rude and made nothing but excuses. There are no excuses for terrible customer service and garage pizza. Mediocre at best.
… more
todd fusco
I grew up Italian, my childhood was spent in my family’s pizza shops and restaurants East coast. I gave this place a shot couple years ago and hadn’t returned because the cost/ pricing was not worth the quality. I gave them another chance tonight just to avoid frozen pizza or Casey’s. Same experience! First the large pizza was actually a MEDIUM SIZE. The dough was over worked and hard . The cost was ridiculous. But to top the dissatisfaction off – they charged a 3.00 surcharge for using a debit card .
… more
… View more