Toasty-Subs Menu – Springfield, IL

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Springfield, IL

Based on 163 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Toasty-Subs 62704

Address:
2025 S MacArthur Blvd, Springfield, IL 62704

Phone: (217) 679-5664

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 10:30 AM–8 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
10:30 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Friday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM–9 PM

Menu

Toasty-Subs Menu (All of our Sandwiches and Sides are served with a Side)
Italian Stallion
Spicy Italian style sandwich on Italian herb and cheese bread, panini pressed with ham, salami, pepperoni, topped with mayo, tomatoes, onion, banana peppers, Jalapeño and Pepper Jack cheese
$7.99
The Toasty Club
Toasty-Subs Special Club with ham, turkey, bacon, and cheddar cheese, served toasted on sweet bread
$8.99
TBR Aka Turkey Bacon Ranch
Oven-roasted turkey and applewood smoked bacon topped with homemade ranch and white cheddar, served toasted on French bread
$6.99
BLT
Applewood Smoked bacon with lettuce, Roma tomatoes, mayo, and Provolone, served pressed on French bread
$6.99
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Our homemade chicken salad with provolone and lettuce on sweet bread served cold.
$6.99
Wicked Tuna
Our homemade tuna salad with provolone and lettuce on sweet bread served cold.
$6.99
TOASTY SPECIALS
Cheesy Tomato Basil Griller
Fresh sliced tomatoes & basil pressed on Texas Toast with Cheddar, White Cheddar, Provolone, and Swiss cheeses, served pressed.
$4.99
Bombay
Traditional Bombay street sandwich pressed on Texas Toast with mint chutney, potatoes, red onions, tomatoes with shredded Monterey and Cheddar cheese, served pressed.
$5.99
Roast Beef
Roast Beef and Cheddar Cheese with Mayo, Lettuce, Tomatoes and Onion on French Bread.
$7.99
The Veggie
Romaine and Spinach blend with Roma tomatoes, green peppers, sliced cucumber, onion, and banana peppers with white cheddar with our homemade Italian dressing, served cold.
$5.99
Pressed Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken strips with Applewood Smoked Bacon, Creamy Provolone & shredded Mozzarella, and Ranch dressing on French, served pressed.
$7.99
Classic Cubano
A pressed pulled pork, ham, yellow mustard, dill pickle, and Swiss cheese on French bread.
$7.99
Buffalo Cauliflower
Hand-breaded baked cauliflower on French bread with lettuce, onion, tomatoes, and Pepper Jack cheese with our homemade dressing and ranch, served pressed.
$6.99
Arnold’s Reuben
Traditional Reuben with Corned Beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing, pressed between two slices of Rye Bread, served pressed.
$5.99
PB & J
Our house-made peanut with strawberry or grape jelly on Texas Toast, served pressed or traditional.
$2.99
Mighty Meatball
Fresh cooked meatballs in seasoned marinara sauce topped with grated Parmesan, shredded Mozzarella, and sliced Provolone, red onions, green peppers, Italian Herbs and Spices on French, served toasted.
$6.99
MAKE IT A COMBO
Add Chips And A Drink To Any Sub $1.99
SOUP
Cup Of Soup Of The Day $1.99
Bowl Of Soup Of The Day $2.99
SIDES
Pickle $0.76
Chips $1.69
SWEETS
Fresh Baked Brownie $1.69
Fresh Baked Cookie $1.99
BEVERAGES
Small Fountain Drink $1.49
Large – Fountain Drink $1.99
Fresh Brewed Coffee $0.99
Iced Coffee $2.99
Water $0.99
Arizona Iced Tea $1.00
Energy Drink $3.49
Body Armor $1.49
Stubborn Soda $2.10
Canned Soda $0.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Prarthana R
Plenty of vegetarian options. You can make your own custom sandwich as well. We had Bombay sandwich (Texas toast) and Buffalo cauliflower(flat bread) Both were great. We also had custom sandwich with Italian bread. Breads were super fresh and tasty for all 3 of them. Sandwich comes with one free side. Plenty of options to choose from for your side – fruits/chips/ cookies etc.

… more

BigLetsPlays
Great food. Food was delivered in a timely fashion and staff was friendly and made great recommendations. I had the Italian Stallion, which tasted amazing. I also ordered a cheesecake brownie, which was decent. The only reason I am giving it a 4 star is because the food was a bit too pricey for what you are getting, but overall it is worth it and when I come back to Springfield I will be back for more.

… more

Trinity Swick
The service was excellent, super sweet. A great place to visit when you’re craving tasty sandwiches. I do have to give an honorable mention to the cheesy garlic bread, which was spectacular. 10/10 recommend and will come again.

… more

Drake Bailey
Every time I come here, I am absolutely floored by how good everything tastes. Took a few friends here recently and they all loved it too. With how many options they have, you’re bound to find something you like, and you can be sure it’ll be made to perfection. Keep up the great work!

… more

Chase Kauffman
My buddy and I were doing sub shop reviews in the Springfield area and this was one of the last places we tried out. Needless to say it was a very pleasent surprise as there was no other sub shop doing these hot pressed subs or whatever. Food amazing, small business with great people, chill atmosphere, and a good choice of drinks and sides as well. We enjoy coming here over and over again because it always bangs. Dope sub shop

… more

Danielle Wright
Disappointed. Prices are not worth the quality of food. The restaurant doesn’t provide a welcoming atmosphere and appears cheaply put together. I ordered a chicken salad sub. The chicken salad didn’t even cover the whole sub and only included a pile of shredded cheese. The hot chocolate was mostly a cup of hot water with a sprinkle of hot chocolate mix. I likely won’t go again.

… more

gustintendo
I happened to notice this lil’ diamond in the rough while driving to work so decided to dine in that same day for lunch. Joe, who seemed to be the manager/co-owner, gladly prepared my Italian Stallion while politely chatting with me about the store and it’s history along with how they strive to keep everything needed for a delicious sandwich fresh daily (especially the bread). The sandwich was worth the wait (mine was pressed for 2m30s) and irresistibly delicious. I highly recommend any sandwich lover to give this local business a chance. I look forward to my next visit! Keep up the great work!

… more

John Molony
The Bombay and the Club are big favorites, but everything we’ve tried so far has been good. The veggie is better than at a lot of other places. And they have good quality pickles.

… more

Chris Evans
Strictly based of service. I ordered online, it said it’d ready in 20 min. I show up about 25 min later. They hadn’t made it, it took about another 10 minutes to make.

… more

jeremy fickling
Was planning on going to Darcy’s paint, but forgot that they were closed. Went down around the corner and found the sandwich shop. Very good good people definitely highly recommend her. Thanks again.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions