Chain outlet serving pizza, plus pasta, calzones, chicken wings & submarine sandwiches. Based on 306 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
800 S Potomac St, Waynesboro, PA 17268
Phone: (717) 749-7007
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joe Christiano
Terrific neighborhood restaurant. The pizza is delicious, and they offer a wide selection of sandwiches, salads, and Italian cuisine. The service is always prompt, and most of all, friendly. Don’t miss it.
… more
Heather Beatty
Will not be ordering from here again. Waited over an hour just for the driver to call and say she knocked, but no one answered. She took a video but couldn’t call before she went back to the store. This is the same driver that yelled up the hill at us last time because she “didn’t get an answer” and wanted a tip. Even told us to “come pick it up” next time. Great personality for the business. Never had issues till this one driver. Absolutely done with this place.
… more
Danny cross
After waiting for two and a half hours for the food that was forgotten the first time! I had to call for a third time. I was talked to like a child. Told that they came to my house and called me! Which were lies. I was told I could get my money or the pizza that was forgotten the first delivery. I tipped 15% . Very poor business! Very unprofessional of who I was told was the owner on the phone. I try to support local businesses, but I would never order here again. Nor would I recommend this place!
… more
J Alison
Very good service, friendly counter people and cooks as well! The stuffed pizza is all I have had from here, so far, but it was SOOOO super yummy-in my opinion. I have heard that their subs are pretty amazing as well and reasonably priced food on their menu, all ways around..go there!
… more
T Snyder
The food is delicious! We have never ordered anything there we did not like! They make their own bread, and it is served warm with your meal!
… more
Michael J. Metzger
First impressions apparently aren’t everything all the time. If they were I wouldn’t now be a repeat customer of this establishment. The first time my family and I got food from here it was not that great to say the least. The food was cold, it was wrong and when we called to complain whoever we talked to was less than concerned about our complaints. We had since gave them a second chance, tried them again and I’m happy to say we had no issues and have now become repeat customers now. Its possible that they were just having a bad evening on our first try. The Stacy’s salad which I’ve had several times is great and more recently I have had one of their meat lovers calzones and it was still even good when I heated it back up to finish it the next day. I also tried the Italian sub which was good as well and I think the bread was what made it for sure. With everything that had and has been going on with the pandemic and all of the businesses that have not been able to survive Toledo’s is a local Waynesboro restaurant which has managed to survived by staying open and offering carry out and delivery options. Keep up the good work Toledo’s owners and staff your doing good work.
… more
Michelle Adams
Not a fan of their pizza. (I don’t like sweet sauce) but the cheese steaks with mushrooms green peppers… DELICIOUS!!! The french fries, DELICIOUS.. that’s all I ever get when I go there. That’s all i need!!
… more
Janel Burgan
Toledo’s is a go-to for delicious pizza, pasta and subs. The food is consistently fresh and delicious. The service, however, is consistently terrible. Plan on carry-out or delivery if you’re short on time. If you decide to dine in, plan on slow service, incomplete orders and forgotten items, difficulty getting drink refills, and not being given a check. On the plus side….plenty of time and space to catch up with a friend or have a small meeting.
… more
Engine Ear
Very good local pizza joint in town. Their pizza is good for a classic NY style slice. I wish they would do something to separate themselves, because it’s very similar to the other pizza places in town. Their sandwiches and main dishes are all good quality. I recommend this place to try out.
… more
Chump Myster
Very friendly service. Pizza was good but there is better out there. Don’t be afraid to stop here. Could have been more steak. It was a steak, onion, garlic, provolone pizza. Crust was good.
… more
… View more